News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Earn-IT threatens encryption and therefore user freedom by charcircuit on Thursday March 10, 2022 @09:01PM (#30635254)
>Are you "hiding" when you lock the door of your home every day, just because the government is not permitted to enter it without a warrant

If this is your reason then I would say you are trying to hide.

>Is it "hiding" to seal the envelope of the card you're sending your Valentine?

Yes, the point is to keep it a surprise.

>helps protect queer youth from intolerant violence (at home and abroad, as in Ghana).

E2EE doesn't prevent a parent from taking their phone and seeing their messages. These kids aren't communicating to their friends over their parent's IRC server. Most parents aren't technical and wouldn't even know how to MITM even an unencrypted messaging app.

>helping victims out of these relationships by enabling them to contact friends for help

Again most people don't know how to MITM this traffic. Especially if you are using mobile data.

Even in regard to whistleblowers they only need anonymity. They want to do the opposite of hiding their messages. They want the opposite. For as many people as possible to see their messages.

Re:Earn-IT threatens encryption and therefore user freedom by c1ccccc1 on Thursday March 10, 2022 @09:31PM (#30635443)
Even if most people don't have the technical chops spy on traffic themselves, I can imagine a world where there are companies that provide such things as products / services. (Probably there are already a few companies like this, I haven't checked.) For example one might be able buy a gizmo with an antenna that listens in on people's wifi and mobile connections. If end to end encryption was banned, I'm guessing that spying on that non-encrypted traffic would take about $50 and an afternoon of setup, and would not require any special skills.
Re:Earn-IT threatens encryption and therefore user freedom by tjpnz on Thursday March 10, 2022 @10:19PM (#30635730)
>I'm guessing that spying on that non-encrypted traffic would take about $50 and an afternoon of setup, and would not require any special skills.

I could see it even becoming a feature in consumer grade network equipment. A bit like HDCP circumvention in video capture boxes or region free playback in optical media players. All you'll have to do is shop around.

Re:Earn-IT threatens encryption and therefore user freedom by charcircuit on Thursday March 10, 2022 @09:34PM (#30635466)
Thankfully with the mass adoption of HTTPS most messages are going to be encrypted over the person's network you are using.
Re:Earn-IT threatens encryption and therefore user freedom by NotEvil on Thursday March 10, 2022 @09:54PM (#30635578)
And with the law. We whould have a backdoor in tls. And HTTPS will be meaningless
Re:Earn-IT threatens encryption and therefore user freedom by c1ccccc1 on Thursday March 10, 2022 @11:28PM (#30636187)
It's possible that the commission will require ISPs to block non-backdoored TLS. But I'd consider that to be more of a worst-case scenario, rather than something that's particularly likely to happen. More likely outcome is companies that store user messages on their servers won't be allowed to provide end to end encryption, and would be forced to store the messages on their servers in plaintext, or using backdoored encryption. The bill allows for differing requirements for different kinds of services, so hopefully ISPs would not have much of a change from the current situation.

Of course, even just that scenario is bad enough. It would mean that the police, the FBI, the NSA, people at the messaging company, and hackers who breach the company's security would all be able to read those messages.

Re:Earn-IT threatens encryption and therefore user freedom by charcircuit on Friday March 11, 2022 @12:34AM (#30636632)
No we wouldn't. This law doesn't even ban E2EE. E2EE eliminates any liability of transferring the messages.
Re:Earn-IT threatens encryption and therefore user freedom by c1ccccc1 on Thursday March 10, 2022 @10:14PM (#30635699)
True, and definitely a good thing.
Re:Earn-IT threatens encryption and therefore user freedom by happytoexplain on Thursday March 10, 2022 @09:07PM (#30635303)
They are comparing to the word "hide" in the context authorities use it, e.g. "nothing to hide". They are not drawing comparisons using the word generically, and they make this explicit. Your two assertions seem to ignore this (i.e. it seems like you're "playing word games").
Re:Earn-IT threatens encryption and therefore user freedom by charcircuit on Thursday March 10, 2022 @09:21PM (#30635388)
At least with locking your door because you are afraid the government is going to break in to your house without a warrant is the same. If someone is doing this either they have done something illegal, e.g. "have something to hide", or they are have a mental issue where they have problems with trust and are overly paranoid.
Re:Earn-IT threatens encryption and therefore user freedom by judge2020 on Thursday March 10, 2022 @09:36PM (#30635480)
Everyone has something to hide from public view, at least in the sense that you don't want anyone (government or civilian burglar) being able to steal your stuff or know what sort of stuff you have on your hard drive. And by everyone, I include regular people who might have a regular desktop or laptop without disk encryption.
Re:Earn-IT threatens encryption and therefore user freedom by charcircuit on Thursday March 10, 2022 @09:43PM (#30635519)
>Everyone has something to hide from public view

But we aren't talking about making something public. We are only talking about a case where the government already has a warrant.

Re:Earn-IT threatens encryption and therefore user freedom by cgriswald on Thursday March 10, 2022 @10:38PM (#30635859)
There's literally no difference. None. This was tried before with special locks that 'only the TSA had the keys to open'. The keys were posted online for anyone to make their own. It's also been tried commercially with various DRM and failed.

There is no such thing as a 'government only, and only with a warrant' backdoor. There is either private or not private.

Re:Earn-IT threatens encryption and therefore user freedom by charcircuit on Friday March 11, 2022 @12:45AM (#30636702)
The problem with TSA keys is that they are all the same, can easily be cloned, and couldn't be rotated.

It is possible to design a system where judges have their own hardware keys. Hardware keys can not be cloned assuming strong tamper protection. If a hardware key gets stolen it can be revoked as being valid and a judge can be issued a new one.

DRM is different because the client ultimately has to have the keys to decrypt the content they have been permitted access to.

Re:Earn-IT threatens encryption and therefore user freedom by baash05 on Friday March 11, 2022 @03:26AM (#30637623)
Shot in the dark here? Which Government are you talking about? Saudi? Where being gay is a death sentence? No? How about the US where being Japanese was illegal? China's got the most people, perhaps we take a wold wide vote to see? Biggest land mass? Millionaires per population (the 1%)?

Who would control the creation of the keys? I mean which tech vender would control access to my android phones encryption? My phone was made in China, and the chips inside it were made in China. They also have the most people, so it seems fair they control the keys.

Re:Earn-IT threatens encryption and therefore user freedom by pdonis on Thursday March 10, 2022 @10:36PM (#30635849)
No, we're not. We're talking about the EARN-IT act, which wants to legally require all website owners to report all kinds of things to law enforcement, without any probable cause that anyone has commmitted a crime and without any kind of warrant.
Re:Earn-IT threatens encryption and therefore user freedom by charcircuit on Friday March 11, 2022 @12:40AM (#30636669)
We were on a tangent. E2EE isn't even banned by the bill so it's all somewhat off topic to talk about.
Re:Earn-IT threatens encryption and therefore user freedom by pdonis on Friday March 11, 2022 @01:00AM (#30636804)
> E2EE isn't even banned by the bill

Not explicitly, no. But it is not feasible for applications to comply with the provisions of the bill while still supporting E2EE, so the bill's effect will be to largely eliminate the use of E2EE.

Re:Earn-IT threatens encryption and therefore user freedom by detcader on Thursday March 10, 2022 @09:32PM (#30635451)
What is an example of a right that you think people should have (by law), which constrains the government in some way?
Re:Earn-IT threatens encryption and therefore user freedom by charcircuit on Thursday March 10, 2022 @09:39PM (#30635497)
The right to not be randomly murdered by the government.
Re:Earn-IT threatens encryption and therefore user freedom by detcader on Tuesday March 15, 2022 @03:59PM (#30690680)
Why are you afraid of the government randomly killing you? I think you only have to think about that if you're doing or planning something very illegal. People who have problems with trust and are overly paranoid might fantasize about that sort of thing, but the average citizen who doesn't do anything wrong will be fine.
Re:Earn-IT threatens encryption and therefore user freedom by heavyset_go on Thursday March 10, 2022 @10:51PM (#30635938)
> Most parents aren't technical and wouldn't even know how to MITM even an unencrypted messaging app.

Give it a couple of weeks and someone will have put together surveillance and parental control system for it.

Re:Earn-IT threatens encryption and therefore user freedom by charcircuit on Friday March 11, 2022 @12:38AM (#30636662)
>Give it a couple of weeks and someone will have put together surveillance and parental control system for it.

????? CSGO chat is unencrypted. It's been more than a few weeks since source games have been out. Show me this parental control system you theorize would have been created.

Re:Earn-IT threatens encryption and therefore user freedom by detcader on Thursday March 10, 2022 @09:30PM (#30635438)
> Even in regard to whistleblowers they only need anonymity. They want to do the opposite of hiding their messages. They want the opposite. For as many people as possible to see their messages.

This website is freeeeeeeee