If you need that much evidence to tell that humans are outperforming AI then they may as well be driving to the same standard. Arguing there is a difference when someone might not be able to detect the difference in a lifetime is getting rather lost in the weeds.

By the time humans have been proven superior there is a real chance that the AIs will have improved to be superhuman. The experience in gaming is that state of the art goes from ok vs amateurs to superhuman quite quickly.