News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Prediction that Kyiv falls to Russian forces by April 202... by rdtwo on Tuesday March 08, 2022 @12:28PM (#30602684)
Do people put money on this because 4:1 odds are pretty good. If definition of fall is a mission accomplished type photo op I’d take those odds. If it’s prolonged stable holding then I probably would not
Re:Prediction that Kyiv falls to Russian forces by April 202... by jessriedel on Tuesday March 08, 2022 @12:53PM (#30603114)
To be clear, Metaculus is a prediction aggregation platform, not a prediction market. There's no money at stake, only reputation.

https://www.metaculus.com/about/

It's well recognized, including my Metaculus users and admin, that money can provide a powerful incentive for accuracy which they do not use (presumably because this would be a very different, more legally encumbered platform). However, they attempt to make up for this by having many more predictions and, crucially, but weighting more heavily the predictions of people whose predictions have been more accurate in the past.

Re:Prediction that Kyiv falls to Russian forces by April 202... by s1artibartfast on Tuesday March 08, 2022 @01:53PM (#30604295)
IT looks to me like there is some money to be made:

https://polymarket.com/market/will-nato-expand-in-2022

Re:Prediction that Kyiv falls to Russian forces by April 202... by rdtwo on Tuesday March 08, 2022 @04:21PM (#30607196)
I’d bet on no just cause how long it would take to certify and ratify. I don’t like bets where I put up a lot to win a little.
Re:Prediction that Kyiv falls to Russian forces by April 202... by mdoms on Tuesday March 08, 2022 @01:11PM (#30603433)
Literally the second sentence of the article. Is it that hard to read before commenting on an article?

> This question will resolve positively if it is publicly reported by at least three reputable media sources or from direct statements from at least four Permanent UNSC members that the majority of Kyiv's raions are under Russian military control by April 1, 2022.

Re:Prediction that Kyiv falls to Russian forces by April 202... by yesenadam on Tuesday March 08, 2022 @06:38PM (#30608902)
Please don't comment on whether someone read an article. "Did you even read the article? It mentions that" can be shortened to "The article mentions that." https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
Re:Prediction that Kyiv falls to Russian forces by April 202... by Kranar on Tuesday March 08, 2022 @01:26PM (#30603701)
That doesn't help in anyway and in fact makes things even more ambiguous. On what basis would three "reputable" media sources report that the majority of Kyiv's regions are under Russian military control?
Re:Prediction that Kyiv falls to Russian forces by April 202... by mdoms on Tuesday March 08, 2022 @03:06PM (#30606044)
Well the point of using multiple reputable sources is that regardless of what basis it's reported, there is at least some widespread agreement. How does that "not help in anyway(sic)"?
Re:Prediction that Kyiv falls to Russian forces by April 202... by Kranar on Wednesday March 09, 2022 @01:59AM (#30611663)
Your response doesn't answer OP's question all it does is punt the issue to a news agency. If a news agency reports it on the basis of a "mission accomplished type photo op", does that count? Or does it require a news agency to report it on the basis of a "prolonged stable holding"?

Just saying that the prediction market shall resolve because three reputable news agencies report something is completely devoid of any insight into the nature of issue. It's as logically absurd as claiming that you have cancer because a Doctor told you that you have cancer, or claiming that you killed Jack because a jury delivered a guilty verdict. No, you don't have cancer because a Doctor said so and no you didn't kill Jack because of a jury's verdict; you have cancer because of an actual condition involving the rapid and abnormal cell growth and you killed Jack because you took a knife and stabbed him.

You are certainly justified to believe you have cancer because a Doctor told you so, and I am justified to believe you killed Jack because a jury said so, but a justification is not the same thing as an actual cause.

So going back to the original question: what is the criteria that determines that Kyiv has actually fallen to Russian forces as opposed to what is the justification for believing that Kyiv has fallen.

Re:Prediction that Kyiv falls to Russian forces by April 202... by babyshake on Tuesday March 08, 2022 @12:49PM (#30603046)
Prediction markets for real money that relate to violent outcomes are a very dangerous territory ethically. You could bet the Kyiv will fall and then provide support or resources to the Russian forces, for example. A more practical example would be something like an assassination prediction.
Re:Prediction that Kyiv falls to Russian forces by April 202... by DennisP on Tuesday March 08, 2022 @01:05PM (#30603340)
It'd have to be a very liquid market, to make it profitable to provide enough support to make a material difference.

I'm not convinced assassination markets are practical. If you make a prediction that a person will be assassinated on a particular day, and put money on it, you'll make the odds for that day spike up, thus warning the target to take new and unpredictable precautions.

If you try to counter this effect with less specific predictions, then more people will take your side of the bet so you'll get worse odds.

Re:Prediction that Kyiv falls to Russian forces by April 202... by somedude895 on Tuesday March 08, 2022 @12:56PM (#30603164)
If you have the sort of influence or resources to make something like an assassination or war happen, then it's really easy to make money on those things already, for example by shorting certain stocks. And I'm sure that's already been happening for a while to some extent.
Re:Prediction that Kyiv falls to Russian forces by April 202... by 2OEH8eoCRo0 on Tuesday March 08, 2022 @12:55PM (#30603154)
The insurgency in Iraq was also a minority- most supported the US. I like to imagine that Russia will have a much more difficult time in Ukraine where they are almost universally despised.
Re:Prediction that Kyiv falls to Russian forces by April 202... by usaphp on Tuesday March 08, 2022 @12:58PM (#30603202)
> The insurgency in Iraq was also a minority- most supported the US

Russians also think that most Ukrainians support Russia, it doesn't mean it's true. Same with believes that most Iraqis supported US.

Re:Prediction that Kyiv falls to Russian forces by April 202... by 2OEH8eoCRo0 on Tuesday March 08, 2022 @01:01PM (#30603266)
Have you researched your assertion about Iraqi support for the US?

https://www.theatlantic.com/international/archive/2022/02/da...

> Petraeus: Ukraine is not only bigger but some 50 percent more populous than Iraq, and the Iraqi population included many millions—Kurds, Christians, Yezidis, Shabak, and many of the Shia—who broadly supported the coalition forces throughout our time there. Only a minority of the Iraqi population comprised or supported the Sunni extremists and insurgents and Iranian-supported Shia militia. Though they did, to be sure, prove to be very formidable enemies.

Re:Prediction that Kyiv falls to Russian forces by April 202... by ppvfy on Tuesday March 08, 2022 @01:28PM (#30603739)
I'm not sure David Petraeus is an impartial source regarding the Iraq war, but even in that interview he avoids the claim that the majority of the Iraqi population supported the US invasion. Instead, he says that supporters of the insurgency are in the minority (you can dislike the invasion and occupation of your country by the US without supporting the Sunni insurgency or the Shia militia) and that "many millions" supported the coalition (how many?).

I'm not just posting this to be pedantic - there are strong comparisons between the US attitude that we would be welcomed as liberators in Iraq and the Russian attitude about Ukraine.

Re:Prediction that Kyiv falls to Russian forces by April 202... by JamesBarney on Tuesday March 08, 2022 @01:55PM (#30604338)
Going into Iraq was probably a bad call from the perspective of US interests, and the cause was definitely bullshit.

But Saddam Hussein's popularity doesn't even compare to Zelensky's.

Re:Prediction that Kyiv falls to Russian forces by April 202... by 2OEH8eoCRo0 on Tuesday March 08, 2022 @01:53PM (#30604292)
You aren't citing anything that refutes the claim.
Re:Prediction that Kyiv falls to Russian forces by April 202... by ppvfy on Tuesday March 08, 2022 @02:08PM (#30604657)
Do you have a source for "most supported the US"? This was your original claim and you also haven't posted a source for it.
Re:Prediction that Kyiv falls to Russian forces by April 202... by guelo on Tuesday March 08, 2022 @01:50PM (#30604193)
> most supported the US.

is not supported by

> the Iraqi population included many millions ... who broadly supported the coalition forces

"Many millions" !- "most"

Re:Prediction that Kyiv falls to Russian forces by April 202... by tada131 on Tuesday March 08, 2022 @01:19PM (#30603566)
Most Ukrainians are forced to support Russia because the way how Zelensky "defends" Ukraine by freeing prisoners and giving advice to fight with Molotov cocktails.
Re:Prediction that Kyiv falls to Russian forces by April 202... by baq on Tuesday March 08, 2022 @01:27PM (#30603716)
These people have experienced being part of ussr and really, really don’t want to go back. Source: am Eastern European
Re:Prediction that Kyiv falls to Russian forces by April 202... by tada131 on Tuesday March 08, 2022 @01:31PM (#30603812)
Russia isn't part of USSR either. Source: am Russian
Re:Prediction that Kyiv falls to Russian forces by April 202... by CRConrad on Monday March 14, 2022 @12:35PM (#30674535)
No, Russia isn't part of the USSR any more: It's all that's left of it.[1] Source: am not Russian

___

[1]: But, hey, don't despair: Belarus will join in any day now.

Re:Prediction that Kyiv falls to Russian forces by April 202... by guelo on Tuesday March 08, 2022 @01:51PM (#30604225)
Putin wishes it still was.
Re:Prediction that Kyiv falls to Russian forces by April 202... by unfocussed_mike on Tuesday March 08, 2022 @05:10PM (#30607897)
Putin is not thinking about the USSR. He's not a communist and he is not interested in a soviet union.

He is thinking about the pre-Tsarist Russian Empire. Which included a few countries that were not in the USSR.

Re:Prediction that Kyiv falls to Russian forces by April 202... by CRConrad on Monday March 14, 2022 @12:37PM (#30674575)
AFAICS, it's all the same to him: If he were dreaming only of reviving the Tsarist (why "pre-"?) Russian Empire and not the Soviet Union, he'd hardly have gone on the record saying "the fall of the Soviet Union was the greatest geopolitical tragedy of thetwentieth century".
Re:Prediction that Kyiv falls to Russian forces by April 202... by wizwit999 on Tuesday March 08, 2022 @01:31PM (#30603823)
No party in Iraq "supported" the US. There were various opportunists with different priorities.
Re:Prediction that Kyiv falls to Russian forces by April 202... by ryeights on Tuesday March 08, 2022 @12:50PM (#30603048)
Does PredictIt make markets on the outcomes of military conflicts? That would pose some interesting ethical dilemmas...
Re:Prediction that Kyiv falls to Russian forces by April 202... by quickthrowman on Tuesday March 08, 2022 @01:14PM (#30603474)
I don’t think anyone is going to change their war plans to earn $850 on a PredictIt contract, let’s be real here.
Re:Prediction that Kyiv falls to Russian forces by April 202... by garyrob on Tuesday March 08, 2022 @12:47PM (#30603011)
26% is closer to 3-to-1 odds. :)