News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Japan’s ‘killing stone’ splits in two by adventured on Monday March 07, 2022 @01:08PM (#30591212)
> what if non-religious people are actually the most religious of them all. humor me.

I can't. It's self-contradictory. Religion is wholly based in faith: believing when you have no concrete, demonstrable, scientific reason to. No religion can exist without that core concept, you have to be willing to believe when you have no proof. More broadly all mysticism is based on faith, and all mysticism (ghost hunters! magic rocks! miracles!) similarly runs counter to science accordingly.

So non-religious scientifically-oriented people have more faith (willingness to base their lives and beliefs around things they can't prove exist) than religious people do? No.

In terms of religion, asking for proof, requiring evidence, is the true first sin: thou shalt not! Religion builds upon that first step, you must first suspend your rational mental self and then turn your brain over to someone else's opinions as fact (which you then must accept as true, even if there's no way to prove such; religion is always based on subservience to someone else's faith-based opinions; religion begins at the point where you turn off your brain and hand it to someone else who says: because I say so, and you must believe what they're saying and specifically not let reason interfere). Here's how religion begins for everyone: someone tells you a (typically fantastical) story, with absolutely no evidence to support it, and then you believe it; to believe it you have to shut down inspection, debate, skepticism, reasoning, and so on. One of the core tenets of all religion is: don't ask such questions; who are you to question; etc. Even the more docile religions fold at those corners eventually and require that you stop asking questions or challenging (aka shut your brain off and just believe on faith).

Science is contrary to faith. People occasionally try to worm around that in touchy-feely ways, you'll run across historical quotes by famous scientists saying dumb things like: my science is rooted in a powerful faith, dur dur dur. But that's just someone smart (at a thing) saying something exceptionally stupid about a different realm of thought and should be regarded as such. Like putting much stock into the dumb things Stephen Hawking used to say in the political or economic realm; geniuses are quite typically gifted at one thing, very rarely at two things, and people commonly seem to make the mistake of thinking that translates widely, when the opposite is true and it very rarely translates widely.

Science grows stronger through questioning, debate, inquiry, challenging notions, requiring evidence to believe. Religion - and all faith based systems - wither when confronted by such, without exception. They react in such opposite manners, because they are indeed opposites.

Re:Japan’s ‘killing stone’ splits in two by hunterb123 on Monday March 07, 2022 @02:53PM (#30592537)
Most people who are religious nowadays know that the stories aren't real or are embellished. It's a story to teach a lesson. The faith allows comfort for people who need it, the community does as well. If you don't need that comfort, fine, don't make fun of people who do. They aren't stupid, they're filling a hole in their heart with community and a shared belief / interest. My wife fills mine, some people don't have that or lost it.

Pro-tip, instead of asking for "proof" like an interrogation, ask for clarification to understand the story or viewpoint. Getting in a fight over something neither side can prove is ridiculous.

But if you want to debate what we cannot know, riddle me this, how do you know we're not in a simulation made by a higher being? Math and science is the reverse engineering of our created universe. It's more probable we were created in some way than a random occurrence.

Re:Japan’s ‘killing stone’ splits in two by lmm on Monday March 07, 2022 @10:09PM (#30596007)
> Most people who are religious nowadays know that the stories aren't real or are embellished. It's a story to teach a lesson.

This is a thin excuse. These stories were held up as literal truths for centuries. The moral principles they embody are held up as serious until they become too unfashionable, then those are dismissed as metaphor too. If you claim a given religious lesson is good and valid today, what basis do we have for believing that someone in 40 years won't be saying that that lesson too was something that was never meant to be taken seriously?

> Getting in a fight over something neither side can prove is ridiculous.

Note how you're contradicting your previous argument, because you don't have a position beyond throwing a bunch of arguments at the wall and hoping something will stick. The burden of proof is on the one making claims; otherwise we should all take Russell's teapot seriously.

> But if you want to debate what we cannot know, riddle me this, how do you know we're not in a simulation made by a higher being?

We don't. Act accordingly.

Re:Japan’s ‘killing stone’ splits in two by hunterb123 on Tuesday March 08, 2022 @04:03AM (#30597998)
> This is a thin excuse. These stories were held up as literal truths for centuries. The moral principles they embody are held up as serious until they become too unfashionable, then those are dismissed as metaphor too. If you claim a given religious lesson is good and valid today, what basis do we have for believing that someone in 40 years won't be saying that that lesson too was something that was never meant to be taken seriously?

It's not an excuse, it's reality. Your perception of religious people is outdated, ignorant, and generalizing. Should we not let any tradition modernize? Should all tradition and culture be discarded because it was once done differently at one point in time? Should we all practice life how you see fit?

> Note how you're contradicting your previous argument, because you don't have a position beyond throwing a bunch of arguments at the wall and hoping something will stick. The burden of proof is on the one making claims; otherwise we should all take Russell's teapot seriously.

A bit hostile there. No one is trying to claim anything, they are practicing their beliefs that make them feel good.

> We don't. Act accordingly.

Exactly, just be smug that you have it all figured out and let people go about their business.

Or you can keep judging something you know nothing about and generalizing billions of people.

Re:Japan’s ‘killing stone’ splits in two by lmm on Tuesday March 08, 2022 @09:16AM (#30600102)
> Your perception of religious people is outdated, ignorant, and generalizing. Should we not let any tradition modernize? Should all tradition and culture be discarded because it was once done differently at one point in time?

You can't simultaneously claim that it's valuable because it's a tradition but my perception of it is outdated. Either you're practicing traditional religion - in which case you need to stand by the literal meaning of your religion's teaching. Or you're practicing something new, at most loosely inspired by past religious practices - in which case your new practice should be evaluated solely on its own merits, which are limited to say the least.

> No one is trying to claim anything, they are practicing their beliefs that make them feel good.

Doing something because it makes you feel good is not an approach with a good reputation (indeed it's something religious people often vigorously oppose). If it's just a set of practices and not a factual claim, why do you care about other people pointing out that it's not factually true?

> Or you can keep judging something you know nothing about and generalizing billions of people.

Ironic to accuse me of judging or generalising while falsely and ignorantly claiming I know nothing about religion - I guess it's fine for you to judge and generalise people you know nothing about, hmm.

Re:Japan’s ‘killing stone’ splits in two by hunterb123 on Tuesday March 08, 2022 @11:00AM (#30601354)
I think you need this: https://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/generalize

But yeah I'm judging you, based on your responses, not based on theism. You haven't talked to the billions you are judging and grouping together (generalizing).

Re:Japan’s ‘killing stone’ splits in two by lmm on Tuesday March 08, 2022 @11:34AM (#30601871)
Well you never talked to me about what I do know about religion, so your assertions about me are definitely based on some faulty reasoning process; whether that's because you're generalising about atheists or because you're following some other process for making up falsehoods about me is somewhat beside the point.
Re:Japan’s ‘killing stone’ splits in two by jrm4 on Monday March 07, 2022 @07:06PM (#30594977)
Nah. You're going with a very historically narrow view of "religion," which at various times has included or been synonymous with "science" and "law," and has rarely excluded either.

So yeah, atheists and really religious folk are very similar, mostly in their "certainty about things around them." As a former Catholic, this is a thing I'm trying to discard in both directions? E.g. when I was younger, "It's important to be Catholic to recieve communion in the church." A little older, "Aha, I will NOT recieve communion." A little older than that? "Lol, it doesn't matter, I'll do this myself, at home, with a donut and grape juice with the kids because why not."

Re:Japan’s ‘killing stone’ splits in two by mistermann on Monday March 07, 2022 @05:54PM (#30594446)
As an armchair Taoist, I have a feeling that my impression of your style of thinking is quite similar to your impression of a fundamentalist Christian (or, basically what you've written here about "religion").

Seriously: if you reread your text, do you see no errors (or at least potential errors)?