News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Putin signs law to seize funds of officials that exceed d... by callmeal on Sunday March 06, 2022 @01:14PM (#30579611)
>[sum of family's last 3 years income] + 10,000 rubles > [sum of family's account balances].

Wowow that is crazy. Anyone who was disciplined about saving/investing and has been doing so for > 5 years will easily meet that criteria!

Re:Putin signs law to seize funds of officials that exceed d... by Volundr on Sunday March 06, 2022 @01:54PM (#30580014)
Assuming this is anything like the US, capital gains and interest both count as income. Your (probably) not in trouble here simply for being a savvy investor.

Obviously, INAL and definitely not a Russian Lawyer.

Re:Putin signs law to seize funds of officials that exceed d... by derefr on Sunday March 06, 2022 @02:25PM (#30580321)
You missed the key point: it’s lifetime-to-date net worth (heuristic: current bank account balances) vs. recent income.

As in, if you make X per year; and you have >3X in savings from Y>3 years of spending (a lot) less than you make and stuffing the difference under a mattress, then all your savings in excess of 3X get confiscated.

In other words, similar to people on welfare in America, public servants in Russia are now not allowed to retain assets in excess of a certain limit proportional to their income—even when that income all came directly from their (government) job.

This is analogous to a progressive wealth tax, but not the same; as a wealth tax still allows disproportionate wealth growth for the highest-income earners; while the goal of this measure is to leave you with at most exactly three years of however-much you’re currently making, and nothing more, no matter what your assets looked like before that.

The key “feature” to observe about this approach, IMHO, is that under this system people who are close to the savings cap already, are incentivized to spend every ruble they make, as any extra “left over” come audit time will be taken away. (It’s a bit like the game-theoretic consequences of yearly-limit insurance coverage, actually!)

Re:Putin signs law to seize funds of officials that exceed d... by Volundr on Sunday March 06, 2022 @08:45PM (#30583281)
> You missed the key point: it’s lifetime-to-date net worth (heuristic: current bank account balances) vs. recent income.

I've now reread the original article several times, and I can't figure out where your getting that from. The phrasing used in the article is "If it turns out that the proceeds from them exceed the total income of the official and his relatives for three years by more than 10,000 rubles", which I can't parse into that and the source for the article appears to both be down and Russian, so I guess I'll take your word for it.

Re:Putin signs law to seize funds of officials that exceed d... by db48x on Sunday March 06, 2022 @09:39PM (#30583622)
“proceeds from them” = the amount in all of your accounts and the accounts of your relatives (no definition given here but presumably they mean your dependents).

“total income … for three years” = you and your relatives/dependents income for the last three years.

“X exceeds Y by more than ₽10,000” = X > Y + ₽10,000.

Let’s make up some numbers and see where they lead. Suppose that you are a middle–aged civil servant and your salary has been ₽100,000 for the last three years. Y = ₽300,000, obviously. You’ve been saving for your whole life, so the sum total of all of your accounts, X, is ₽500,000. Most of that is in whatever the Russian equivalent of pensions or 401ks are, so they have been earning money for you. Either collecting interest, or by gaining value on the stock market or whatever. Let’s say that your average growth over the last 3 years was 5%. That means you earned ₽68,000 in interest over those three years. Assuming that this adds into Y, your total income, then Y is ₽368,000. Well, ₽500,000 is certainly larger than ₽378,000, so your name comes to the attention of the prosecutor.

However, I disagree that this means that you automatically lose anything. The article says: “In order not to lose money, the official will have to prove the legality of their appearance on the account.” Presumably then you won’t lose anything if your records show that you obtained it all legally.

On the one hand, you do want to catch corrupt officials who have been taking bribes or kickbacks. On the other hand, choosing this means to do it seems counter–productive, since you have to expect that everyone who is saving up for retirement in some way will qualify for investigation. Since the criteria for investigation are not correlated with the crime that they are trying to detect, they are going to have all the false positives.

Re:Putin signs law to seize funds of officials that exceed d... by derefr on Sunday March 06, 2022 @11:37PM (#30584270)
> Presumably then you won’t lose anything if your records show that you obtained it all legally.

That presumes you have perfect record-keeping. Perhaps, if you can't prove 100% of your income and expenses (i.e. if you can't present an immaculately-balanced ledger — and who can?), you'll have your assets confiscated anyway. They can hold you as having violated the letter of the law, even if you kept to the spirit.

One assumption further: the regime perhaps told the people it wanted to keep around, long in advance, to get (or fabricate) such a detailed personal accounting.

Re:Putin signs law to seize funds of officials that exceed d... by manicdee on Tuesday March 08, 2022 @03:12AM (#30597686)
Perhaps the entire point is false positives: if we throw you into a pool and you float, you are a witch. If you drown, you were probably innocent.
Re:Putin signs law to seize funds of officials that exceed d... by cultofmetatron on Sunday March 06, 2022 @03:57PM (#30581188)
my first thought was "maybe they'll buy into gold or bitcoin" but then who's going to be accepting rubles for gold or bitcoin at this point. The Ruble is essentially worthless now.
Re:Putin signs law to seize funds of officials that exceed d... by __s on Sunday March 06, 2022 @01:58PM (#30580072)
Try to evaluate the rule with some reasonableness. There's likely a mechanism to report interest as income, or the balance of investments would be based on deposits & not effective worth
Re:Putin signs law to seize funds of officials that exceed d... by Bootvis on Sunday March 06, 2022 @02:34PM (#30580410)
Confiscating money if people have too much according to some weird heuristic is inherently unreasonable.
Re:Putin signs law to seize funds of officials that exceed d... by 411111111111111 on Sunday March 06, 2022 @05:06PM (#30581748)
Not necessarily, it depends as always.

Heavily penalizing accumulation of cash like that could be reasonable, but doing it without announcing it at least a year forward makes it hard to argue that it's anything but a cashgrap.

But the idea issue is viable if the explicit goal is to make high cash reserves impossible. People would instead have to invest and various accounts (I.e. pension plans etc) have to be exempt. So it's theoretically reasonable if the economy is suffering because the wealth is never being spen, but that sounds like a very unlikely situation to occur in today's consumption society.

Re:Putin signs law to seize funds of officials that exceed d... by csomar on Sunday March 06, 2022 @09:59PM (#30583755)
> Heavily penalizing accumulation of cash like that could be reasonable, but doing it without announcing it at least a year forward makes it hard to argue that it's anything but a cashgrap.

Penalizing accumulation of cash (ie: negative rates) vs. Seizing cash are completely different things.

Re:Putin signs law to seize funds of officials that exceed d... by imtringued on Monday March 07, 2022 @03:30AM (#30585442)
I advocate for a negative interest rate so that well developed econonies are no longer under an artificial pressure to grow at the expense of sustainability and other economies.

However, that doesn't mean the proposed mechanism i.e an explicit wealth limit is actually reasonable.

By the way an economy suffering because the wealth is never spent is the root cause of every single economic depression in history. Bill Gates is rich enough that he could never spend it all.

Today's consumption society is just an unsustainable method of avoiding a depression. All money saved must be invested because nobody tells the wealthy to stop playing the accumulation game. A negative interest rate would get rid of the need to increase debt.

Re:Putin signs law to seize funds of officials that exceed d... by lowkey on Sunday March 06, 2022 @07:19PM (#30582660)
And yet that is exactly what happened to people who held savings in bank accounts in Cyprus after the GFC when the government decided the banks needed a bailout more than the people needed a retirement.
Re:Putin signs law to seize funds of officials that exceed d... by geysersam on Sunday March 06, 2022 @03:08PM (#30580747)
It's a tool to investigate and deincentivize corruption. Not some state income tax.
Re:Putin signs law to seize funds of officials that exceed d... by grey-area on Sunday March 06, 2022 @03:17PM (#30580844)
Putin is the most corrupt individual on earth who has stolen billions from his country and runs a mafia state. this law is not to ‘deincentivize corruption’, but I guess it might help stave off state bankruptcy for another week.
Re:Putin signs law to seize funds of officials that exceed d... by nojonestownpls on Sunday March 06, 2022 @02:42PM (#30580492)
> reasonableness

Tough ask in the current climate, in a Russia-related thread.

Re:Putin signs law to seize funds of officials that exceed d... by AniseAbyss on Sunday March 06, 2022 @06:01PM (#30582153)
Punishment for using a Russian bank and not offshoring your assets... What is next building a wall to keep people from "voting with their feet"?