Re:“I hate almost all software” — Ryan Dahl
by patrickc on Friday September 30, 2011 @12:08AM
(#3055636)
To quote Douglas Crockford on JavaScript, "Lisp in C's Clothing"
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:“I hate almost all software” — Ryan Dahl
by rbranson on Friday September 30, 2011 @12:09AM
(#3055638)
Before I learned a Lisp, I agreed with that statement. Now, I think nothing could be further from the truth.
Re:“I hate almost all software” — Ryan Dahl
by GeneralMaximus on Friday September 30, 2011 @01:11AM
(#3055765)
Indeed. Lisp is a simple language that can be completely defined in half a page. A naive implementation takes less than a thousand lines of code. The language is homoiconic, i.e, there's no difference between programs and data -- everything is a list. This enables programmers to perform complex transformations on code using macros. Lisp compilers such as SBCL generate code that is almost as fast as C++. Oh, and the original Lisp as described by McCarthy is strictly rooted in mathematics. If you limit yourself to writing only a subset of Common Lisp/Scheme -- one that emphasizes immutability and recursive functions on lists of symbols -- it is possible to use formal methods to prove the correctness of your code.
None of that is true for JS. I don't think Crockford thought his remark through.
Re:“I hate almost all software” — Ryan Dahl
by asynchrony on Friday September 30, 2011 @02:46AM
(#3055956)
As a lisp (Scheme and Clojure) user who nonetheless takes issue with this statement:
1. Modern (JS) runtimes have JITs that can generate code almost as fast as C++.
2. You can write purely functional code in JS.
3. JS has arguably less features than R5RS Scheme, which itself is hard to fit on half a page.
Re:“I hate almost all software” — Ryan Dahl
by sausagefeet on Friday September 30, 2011 @10:00AM
(#3057005)
What do you mean by point 2? Unless you don't plan on doing any I/O, you can't write purely functional code in JS. Not that you can in Lisp either...
Re:“I hate almost all software” — Ryan Dahl
by asynchrony on Friday September 30, 2011 @03:31PM
(#3058268)
I meant that there is nothing about JS that prohibits
writing pure functions and reaping all the associated benefits (formal reasoning, etc.)
Re:“I hate almost all software” — Ryan Dahl
by patrickc on Friday September 30, 2011 @12:48AM
(#3055728)
If it ain't got macros, then it ain't a Lisp. Javascript is definitely no Lisp, but I really like that it allows function composition, which is somehow reminiscent of a Lisp.
f(g(h(x))); instead of (f (g (h x)))
Re:“I hate almost all software” — Ryan Dahl
by eurleif on Friday September 30, 2011 @12:54AM
(#3055741)
Um, pretty much every C-derived language supports function composition, and uses that syntax for it. Am I missing something?
Re:“I hate almost all software” — Ryan Dahl
by patrickc on Friday September 30, 2011 @01:32AM
(#3055794)
You're right. I meant to say passing first-class functions as arguments, rather than pointers to functions as you would in C or an object method as you would in Java.
Re:“I hate almost all software” — Ryan Dahl
by sausagefeet on Friday September 30, 2011 @09:59AM
(#3057001)
I agree. I think this "JS is Lisp" nonsense is a pretty little platitude that many developers use simply because they don't know any better.