I toured SpaceX HQ just yesterday and saw this video (or some of it). The employee presenting said that landing on Mars w/ a parachute is not a good option. Powered landing makes their craft able to land on any surface.
This is a paraphrase; and I am not a rocket scientist, so don't quote me on this.
Absolutely correct. I got that vibe from all employees I listened to yesterday. The underlying motivation of the company is: to go to and colonize Mars. Everything they do before then is to gain credibility, survive, and fund R&D toward reaching their ultimate goal.
Aerobraking and parachutes alone aren't enough on Mars, even for small payloads (less than people-sized). Just look at the MER and MSL entry, descent, & landing systems. The reason being that mass scales with the volume while aerobraking and parachutes obviously rely on cross-sectional area. Even MSL, which is an order of magnitude lighter than a Dragon capsule, requires a sophisticated hybrid EDL system.
Also, although it may be Musk's goal to go to Mars, there is good profit to be made in Near Earth Objects and the Moon, none of which have much of an atmosphere to speak of.
http://kerbalspaceprogram.com/
an example: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9RvVjysJKB4
I also recommend Orbiter 2010, but it is a simulator and is not easy.
I love it though.
but i did lol a little when i saw the legs push out from the rocket, when i think reusable i think drop it in the sea and have a boat go pick it up not land on the pad you just fired it from.
if this works out United Launch Alliance with Boing and the rest can just quit the rocket business, its like the intro to Patton "You know i actually pity those poor bastards we're going up against. By God, I do. We're not just going to shoot the bastards. . ."
I'm assuming someone at Space X did at least some back of the napkin math, but color me skeptical.