News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Stock Market Meltdowns - Why they will happen again and a... by netcan on Tuesday September 16, 2008 @01:48AM (#305480)
I don't understand how the stock market doesn't collapse completely. But, it seems to me that if owning stock makes no sense if there are no dividends Then owning stock makes no sense anyway.

Top technology stocks that pay (eg IBM,MSFT) usually pay <1.5%. Even currently cashed up oil stocks tend to stay under 2%. So either way it seems to me if you were buying to own (isn't that theoretically what you're doing), you'd need to be expecting to earn the majority of your marbles on growth.

I freely admit, I don't understand financial markets. But it always seems like the emperor has no clothes.

Theoretically all those guys holding MSFT should not be willing to pay more then about $9 per share (price is about $25) unless they expect growth & no risk.

Re:Stock Market Meltdowns - Why they will happen again and a... by michaelneale on Tuesday September 16, 2008 @03:47AM (#305550)
Its all about growth. Dividend at best helps offset some costs, for sure, but really, its betting on growth, or at least it has been for a long time.
Re:Stock Market Meltdowns - Why they will happen again and a... by netcan on Tuesday September 16, 2008 @05:12AM (#305603)
Well then there's the strange thing.

As you say, almost no company is issuing dividends that in themselves justify share prices so it's all just betting on growth. Does that mean that rational people are betting on the growth of virtually all (existing) companies?

Re:Stock Market Meltdowns - Why they will happen again and a... by khafra on Tuesday September 16, 2008 @08:18AM (#305693)
Some presumably rational people are betting on the growth of any particular company. Most rational investors go with mutual or index funds, which bet on the growth of the majority of a certain list of companies, or type of company. In the history of the stock market, this bet has never failed over any given 20-year period, even the one starting in 1928.

Of course, the stock market's never before been faced with such a huge influx of stock-owning retirees, or plausible peaks in energy and some metals--without which growth as we know it can't exist--so you pay your money and you take your chances.

Re:Stock Market Meltdowns - Why they will happen again and a... by michaelneale on Tuesday September 16, 2008 @05:14PM (#306305)
yes it is a strange thing. I guess there just has to be One More Sucker to liquidate your stock too...

having said that, a lot of old school companies (at least here) pay good dividends still - so there is a class of "dividend" stock versus growth stock - although some growth is still expected.

Re:Stock Market Meltdowns - Why they will happen again and a... by quasimojo on Tuesday September 16, 2008 @07:39PM (#306446)
But, it seems to me that if owning stock makes no sense if there are no dividends Then owning stock makes no sense anyway.

you can say the same for dollar bills. what is a dollar's INTRINSIC value? zero. its just a piece of paper