But the argument which makes the discussion now mostly irrelevant is simply: all available and reasonable designs are vastly expensive and take at least a decade to build, if not two including planning. That makes the question just moot. Not even France, which is all-in on nuclear has an answer to that.
Renewables are comparatively cheap and can be set up quickly. Germany already depends to a large part on renewable electricity. That is the cheap and efficient way forward. On top of that, nuclear power plants don't work well together with renewables, as they can't switch their output level enough.
Gas is the ideal partner for renewables and eventually will also be produced from renewable energy. Just recent events messed up the plan a bit, but not too much. We have to push quicker for renewables and pay a bit more for gas.
The reality is that our world is inherently too unstable for the half century commitment necessary for each reactor. External influences always drive risky decisions which ultimately result in less than completely safe outcomes for both the operation of the reactor and the containment of the waste.
Yes we do. I post this is almost every thread about nuclear power, and it seems I find new people each time.
If you combine https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nuclear_reprocessing with https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Breeder_reactor you have essentially zero nuclear waste, and you also need something like 98% less Uranium.
This is a completely solved problem.
> On top of that, nuclear power plants don't work well together with renewables, as they can't switch their output level enough.
This isn't true either.
It's like everyone's opinion of nuclear power is stuck in the past, and no one can ever update their info.
Please point me out to a nuclear reactor design that can be switched from 100% to 0% in the matter of hours and back again.
Germany stored some nuclear waste in a salt mine, that turned into a huge debacle after only 30 years requiring now an immensely expensive recovery operation: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Asse_II_mine
Oops.
Over those time frames that you mentioned the waste mostly the toxic properties are important. Btw how are we handling all that toxic chemical waste that is going to be toxic and dangerous not only for hundreds but thousands of millenia. Maybe we could just put it there.
> I mean, what's the point of a "nuclear waste free Earth" if our civilization collapses due to climate change?
That is a bit panic-fuelled and frankly even religious, while completely ignoring the immediate threat of radiation, which cannot be reversed for hundreds of thousands of years.
PS.: Climate change is going to happen whatever we do. This happened even before we existed.
Waiting hundreds of thousands of years is the simplest way to reverse the "threat of radiation". Each radioactive isotope has a half-life; if you wait ten half-lives, the "threat of radiation" is reduced by a thousand times, and the isotopes with very long half-lives aren't that radioactive to start with (roughly simplifying, the shorter the half-life, the more intense the radiation).
There has been a historic reversal in German foreign and security policy this week! Germans are already revising their opinions about Russia, climate, energy, defense and what the government and media espouse since they may have been the original impetus in forming their opinions.
I'm not sure anyone here will have a good answer for you, but anti-nuclear sentiment in Germany is incredibly strong.
Risks aside, renewables are cheaper. So why use an outdated technology like nuclear?
(Now, fission would be a different story. I am all for researching this intensively).
Nuclear is much better suited for base load power than solar and wind. Take a look at this graph of German energy by source and Tw/H.
https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Energy_in_Germany#/media/Fil...
For all their good intentions of replacing nuclear with something cleaner and safer, you can see wind and solar grow, but not enough to offset the nuclear decrease. Natural gas consumption grows more to replace it. “Solar and wind instead of nuclear” is a false dichotomy because one can’t just swap out one with the other, at least not until grid batteries are far more available.
Regardless, it's not either nuclear or renewables. It should be a combination that works.
Apart from that, it is not like big windmills and sun farms have zero impact on the environment. In this case a nuclear factory might be big and ugly, but globally its immediate impact on nature might be a lot less than the aforementioned renewables.
1 kg of natural uranium gives 45,000 kWh of electricity; so the extraction of raw materials for nuclear has less impact on nature as well compared to many other solutions (e.g. for the same amount of electricity you would need nearly 10,000 kg of mineral oil or 14,000 kg of coal). [1]
Of course with nuclear you have problems with storage of waste and possible accidents, but its positive impact on climate change, great capacity for producing electricity and lower impact on nature than many other solutions, might make it the best solution we have at the time being?
Remember that heating in most of Europe is provided by natural gas. The primary need for heat is during the nighttime. Solar works only during the day, wind works great at dawn and dusk but not particularly well at night, and both of these systems have inherent unpredictability. You never know that there isn't some weather pattern that's going to take all your solar/wind down to 30% of its normal capacity for a week. Hydro and geothermal may fit the bill, but AFAIK Germany and Europe in general doesn't have the capacity.
The ultimate goal is a 100% renewable grid consisting of an energy storage system which will work all night, and will be recharged by solar and wind when those systems are operating at peak capacity. Natural gas heating will be replaced by heat pumps with a fallback to electric resistive heating when temperatures drop too low for a heat pump to be effective. Right now, there is no such energy storage system that will scale to meet these needs.
We'll get there one day, but until then, we need an energy generation technology that works all day every day with no dependencies on weather, and scale to the size of a continent. The only -- the only -- technologies that currently exist which do this are coal, natural gas, and nuclear. Pick one. You must pick one -- platitudes about renewable energy and technology which may or may not exist in a decade will not prevent the pipes from freezing tonight.
Right now, Germany has chosen coal and natural gas, and has phased out nuclear. IMHO this was the wrong choice.
(Before anyone says Germany has phased out coal, they have not phased out coal. Germany mines coal, selling coal to Poland, Poland uses coal to produce electricity, Germany buys electricity from Poland.)
> (Now, fission would be a different story. I am all for researching this intensively).
I suspect you meant fusion; I don't normally point out typos, but in this case, I think it's important.
/me thinks of the green instead read stripe of some Inter City Expresses and giggles :)
I think its more likely that we find a technical solution to radioactive waste then find a technical solution to a destroyed world (aka 3 Celsius hotter)
Honestly, as a German myself I'm rather doubtful of that unfortunately. Some? Maybe. Many? Probably not. I cannot even convince my parents (who grew up in Germany during the time when the anti nuclear sentiment really started) to rethink their anti nuclear stance (despite having a great relationship with them). I say that as a physicist that absolutely sees there are flaws with aging nuclear plants.
But people who are not able to a) appreciate the energy density of nuclear and b) see that climate change is an urgent problem we face, whereas any issues from nuclear waste are long term problems (not even talking about future reactor technologies etc. etc.) is just... I don't know? It sounds insane, but indoctrinated? I just utterly fail to understand.
I mean, what's the point of a "nuclear waste free Earth" if our civilization collapses due to climate change?