News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:On the Origin of the iPhone by heavyset_go on Saturday February 26, 2022 @07:20PM (#30483765)
OS X at its core, is just Mach + FreeBSD. People were running Darwin in limited resource environments for years.

By the time the iPhone hit the market, there were already plenty of handheld devices that had similar specs that were running full-blown Linux.

Pretending that the iPhone was "at the edge of what was technologically possible" is rewriting history.

Re:On the Origin of the iPhone by tambourine_man on Saturday February 26, 2022 @07:53PM (#30484090)
OS X is not Darwin. All the interesting parts are on the layers built on top of it.

What was remarkable was being able to run a graphic accelerated version of AppKit built for touch screens (UIKit) and have RAM to spare to run a non trivial app, like, you know, a full blown web browser, all in 128MB.

So yeah, Darwin + window server + springboard + Safari + webpage > 128MB is pretty impressive indeed.

Re:On the Origin of the iPhone by wvenable on Saturday February 26, 2022 @08:23PM (#30484330)
128MB is absolutely massive compared to the hardware that NextSTEP / OS X was designed to run on.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/NeXTstation

Re:On the Origin of the iPhone by tambourine_man on Saturday February 26, 2022 @08:25PM (#30484344)
NextSTEP didn’t run Safari, nor Quartz or Aqua. And NextSTEP was slooooowww. One of the reasons some of us rooted for BeOS.
Re:On the Origin of the iPhone by gcanyon on Saturday February 26, 2022 @11:06PM (#30485323)
Those awesome BeOS demos! They would open a dozen apps to max out both CPUs (25 or 33 MHz as I recall) and then show that you could grab any window and drag it around, and everything else would slow to a crawl, but that window, the one you were interacting with, was still snappy.

Then they would shut off one of the CPUs.

Everything was as slow as winter molasses. And they would grab a window, and it was still super snappy, while everything else almost froze solid.

I miss being the center of my computer's universe like that.

Re:On the Origin of the iPhone by unfocussed_mike on Saturday February 26, 2022 @08:42PM (#30484459)
NextSTEP didn't run Quartz, no.

It used Display PostScript -- a comparably impressive achievement at the time.

It also wasn't that slow on the Intel machines, e.g. the black NextStep PCs Elonex made in the UK. It was quite nippy on some of the earlier NeXT hardware, too.

BeOS was a very different operating system and -- let's be clear -- would have been a terrible, terrible choice.

I tell you what was slow: WebObjects on the Mach subsystem layer on top of Windows NT.

Re:On the Origin of the iPhone by tambourine_man on Saturday February 26, 2022 @09:02PM (#30484586)
Mach was slow, disk access (the spinning beachball Mac OS inherited was supposed to be a CD originally) was very slow. Using a Turing complete language for drawing was scary.

> BeOS was a very different operating system and -- let's be clear -- would have been a terrible, terrible choice.

Oh, sure. But it sure was snappy. And gorgeous. And that file system was awesome.

Re:On the Origin of the iPhone by unfocussed_mike on Saturday February 26, 2022 @09:22PM (#30484696)
> Mach was slow, disk access (the spinning beachball Mac OS inherited was supposed to be a CD originally) was very slow.

https://pbfcomics.com/comics/beach-closing/

> Using a Turing complete language for drawing was scary.

Not particularly sure why. Aren't all apps using Turing complete languages to draw on screen? It's just a question of which layer that happens.

Display PostScript did the same, surely?

Re:On the Origin of the iPhone by dreamcompiler on Sunday February 27, 2022 @01:49AM (#30486014)
The comment is about the display layer. Yes [almost] all computer languages are Turing complete; the distinction is about the level at which they produce drawing instructions. Some simply set particular bits in memory that cause pixels to light up. That's essentially how the original Mac worked. More abstract is producing instructions to "draw a rectangle" or "rotate all future lines by 20 degrees." That's the "display list" approach and it's more flexible than manipulating raw pixels.

More flexible still is producing commands that can contain loops like Postscript. Now we're in tricky territory, because it's easy to make a mistake that e.g. produces an infinite loop and the whole display locks up. And it's much harder to reason about such things as the update rate of the drawing process because the drawing commands are themselves Turing complete.

This doesn't matter when you're merely printing because there is no refresh. Not so with an interactive display. That's why the "Display" in "Display Postscript" was a big deal.

Re:On the Origin of the iPhone by tambourine_man on Sunday February 27, 2022 @02:09PM (#30491462)
I think PostScript was considered “too powerful” for its own good by the industry, which is why it was mostly replaced by PDF (initially a subset of it).

With PostScript, you can have a document that renders differently every time you open it (on purpose). Or a file that will never finish rendering or printing, like the infinite loop you mentioned.

PostScript infinite possibilities are cool and cute, but not all that practical for a graphics description language.

Re:On the Origin of the iPhone by unfocussed_mike on Sunday February 27, 2022 @03:21PM (#30492100)
> With PostScript, you can have a document that renders differently every time you open it (on purpose). Or a file that will never finish rendering or printing, like the infinite loop you mentioned.

There was a font, wasn't there -- was it Just van Rossum's Beowulf -- that drew itself slightly differently every time? Can't find a reference now.

edit: it was!

https://www.fontshop.com/families/ff-beowolf

Re:On the Origin of the iPhone by tambourine_man on Sunday February 27, 2022 @07:15PM (#30494390)
Oh my god. Thanks for this.
Re:On the Origin of the iPhone by addaon on Saturday February 26, 2022 @11:31PM (#30485427)
128 MB is also the base requirement for 10.2, 10.3, and 10.4 (although at least 10.3 will run with much less than that in practice).
Re:On the Origin of the iPhone by tambourine_man on Sunday February 27, 2022 @05:35AM (#30487021)
It will run. It’s just a very bad experience.

The original iPhone was a delight to use, responsive like the desktop counterparts weren’t, despite much slower hardware and running on battery.

Re:On the Origin of the iPhone by GeekyBear on Sunday February 27, 2022 @09:51AM (#30488941)
I think part of that was that the graphics layer on the iPhone was GPU accelerated from the start, and the first few versions of OSX were not.

One of the things that Microsoft got right and Google got wrong was that Microsoft copied the concept of using GPU accelerated graphics with Windows Phone and it took Google quite some time to catch up.

Re:On the Origin of the iPhone by heavyset_go on Saturday February 26, 2022 @08:03PM (#30484172)
> OS X is not Darwin.

iOS is not OS X.

> So yeah, Darwin + window server + springboard + Safari + webpage > 128MB is pretty impressive indeed.

Maemo did all all of this years before, and in 64MB of RAM.

Re:On the Origin of the iPhone by tambourine_man on Saturday February 26, 2022 @08:34PM (#30484403)
I don’t think Debian wasn’t doing double buffering GPU compositing of the UI. Nor was it running WebKit.

Show me a video of a smooth pinch to zoom on a webpage with MicroB

Re:On the Origin of the iPhone by heavyset_go on Sunday February 27, 2022 @03:57AM (#30486540)
Konqueror has modular backend support, and it shipped with WebKit support as backend before the iPhone was released. Rekonq also used it and not KHTML. Epiphany used WebKit since mid-2007, it's now Gnome Web. All were available on Debian and Debian-based distributions. Phone-wise, Symbian used WebKit in 2005.
Re:On the Origin of the iPhone by Jyaif on Saturday February 26, 2022 @10:13PM (#30485022)
My iMac from 2000 had 128MB and ran OS X.
Re:On the Origin of the iPhone by tambourine_man on Sunday February 27, 2022 @05:32AM (#30486999)
And it was terribly slow.

The iPhone was responsive like no other computer at its time, let alone phone. It prioritizes user input above all else, which is the right choice.

Re:On the Origin of the iPhone by Jyaif on Sunday February 27, 2022 @06:07AM (#30487192)
> And it was terribly slow.

https://youtu.be/YW7z0uMOYrw?t=364 Does that look terribly slow to you?

Re:On the Origin of the iPhone by tambourine_man on Sunday February 27, 2022 @02:17PM (#30491536)
That's a 600Mhz G3 with 256MB of RAM. Probably 3X faster CPU and twice the RAM.

I was a user at the time. Had many iMac G3s.

But even on this machine, try navigating through nested menus, dragging windows around. Now boot from Mac OS 9 and do the same. It's night and day.

Re:On the Origin of the iPhone by mushyhammer on Saturday February 26, 2022 @07:37PM (#30483922)
Show me the handheld devices that were running full-blown Linux at the levels the iPhone was (i.e. with a responsive UI). Linux being Linux I’m sure it can be run on a sock but that’s not the same as what iPhone OS 1.0 was.
Re:On the Origin of the iPhone by unfocussed_mike on Saturday February 26, 2022 @07:45PM (#30484003)
Well of course they weren't running it at iPhone level performance.

First because the device and the software hadn't been optimised for each other.

And second, the fact that iPhone OS was not a "full blown" Unix OS is precisely why it _did_ have that performance on otherwise reasonably similar Samsung ARM hardware (better specs but not, you know, alien technological advance stuff).

The point is that there is this tradeoff. Developers who'd squeezed full multitasking Linux into phones would have been well aware of the kind of performance they'd see without multitasking and without a BSD subsystem.

FWIW Jim Gettys' handhelds.org project was demonstrating -- years earlier -- pretty impressive Linux GUI performance on much earlier hardware that had been only modestly adjusted for it [0]. Including for example tilt-sensitivity.

Those who knew about those projects could see that Apple had likely benefited enormously from seeing what was being done, and had decided to make an OS profile for iPhone that prioritised single-app performance with a sizeable slice of OS X.

[0] The iPaq as a product was designed in part to explicitly accommodate research from the DEC Itsy on off-the-shelf devices

Re:On the Origin of the iPhone by heavyset_go on Saturday February 26, 2022 @07:58PM (#30484127)
> Well of course they weren't running it at iPhone level performance. First because the device and the software hadn't been optimised for each other.

I disagree entirely. Maemo as designed, built and optimized for low-powered mobile devices compared to desktops.

Re:On the Origin of the iPhone by wmf on Sunday February 27, 2022 @01:09AM (#30485840)
If it was so optimized, why did it let apps run down the battery in 30 minutes?
Re:On the Origin of the iPhone by heavyset_go on Sunday February 27, 2022 @04:17AM (#30486638)
I don't know, you tell me? I could get hours of FreeCiv out of the N770, and that will steal a core of even a modern processor for a while.

Both the N770 and N810 were marketed as products for early adopters and developers.

Re:On the Origin of the iPhone by imwillofficial on Sunday February 27, 2022 @12:49AM (#30485750)
Ah the goals are shifting I see
Re:On the Origin of the iPhone by unfocussed_mike on Sunday February 27, 2022 @09:43AM (#30488885)
Too few words to tell if you're being sarcastic, rude or whimsical. (edit: I'm going with rude)

The entire mobile phone industry was -- and still is -- making these tradeoffs. (Android used and uses a slightly more advanced process model that iOS eventually adopted, but even it does not and did not offer full multitasking).

It's not shifting goals, it's an indication that there's more than one possible goal to shoot at.

Re:On the Origin of the iPhone by heavyset_go on Saturday February 26, 2022 @07:56PM (#30484117)
Nokia Nxx series like the Nokia N770 and Nokia N800, and then the N810 and N900. Maemo[1] was full-fledged Linux, and you could run full-blown Linux applications. GTK apps were natively supported. I played a lot of FreeCiv on them and used SSH's X forwarding on them. Maemo became Meego, which became SailfishOS.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Maemo

Re:On the Origin of the iPhone by filmgirlcw on Saturday February 26, 2022 @10:07PM (#30484983)
The N810 and N900 were AFTER the iPhone (N900 significantly so), and it’s quite revisionist to compare the N770 or N800 (or N810 for that matter) to the first iPhone, in terms of its performance and feel. Yes, on a pure feature list comparison, the N770 and N800 might have compared well (or even better, especially for iPhone OS 1.0), but those devices never felt the same as an iPhone. Capacitive touch screens made a big difference too.

The N-series Nokias (including the N95 and N97 phones) were really special, but they weren’t iPhones. The iPhone just made everything else feel old instantly.

Re:On the Origin of the iPhone by stonogo on Saturday February 26, 2022 @11:46PM (#30485490)
Until you tried to copy/paste text, and then you went back to your Nokia. This is a pretty subjective thing you're trying to argue, here.
Re:On the Origin of the iPhone by unfocussed_mike on Saturday February 26, 2022 @07:28PM (#30483844)
It was at the edge in a few small ways but it was carefully profiled to be that; it had limitations (single process model) that didn't really matter (except the absence of 3G) in favour of performance (graphics, capacitive multitouch) that did.

It was out in front in a lot of ways but not witchcraft.

Re:On the Origin of the iPhone by cpuguy83 on Saturday February 26, 2022 @08:17PM (#30484276)
That's just it, craft. They took the time to craft the system to fit a certain profile which people found desirable and it changed the industry.
Re:On the Origin of the iPhone by unfocussed_mike on Saturday February 26, 2022 @08:31PM (#30484387)
Right.

The common criticisms about Apple kit, at any point in time, will be led by feature comparison rather than benefit comparison.

On almost every level, the iPhone prioritised benefits (consistency, simplicity, responsiveness, discoverability) over features.

And in all but really two of the feature cases (text management/copy and paste, and the absence of 3G), they gambled right: people cared about the benefits they'd engineered for, and not about the features they'd skipped.

(They managed to bluff past the apps question: we knew they had to be working on it and they managed to tell us they were working on it without telling us they were working on it)

Commentators still make this mistake with Apple.

Re:On the Origin of the iPhone by imwillofficial on Sunday February 27, 2022 @12:51AM (#30485760)
“It was out in front in a lot of ways but not witchcraft.”

I’ve been running Linux since 14.

Had all the great smartphones of the age.

At 19 I purchased the first iPhone.

It was fucking witchcraft.

Re:On the Origin of the iPhone by unfocussed_mike on Sunday February 27, 2022 @10:02AM (#30489041)
> I’ve been running Linux since 14.

Judging by the maths I was running it when you were four or five and have done ever since. I'm not sure what point you're making.

> Had all the great smartphones of the age.

Good for you. So you ran the handhelds.org linux project on a Compaq iPaq back in 2002-2003, or no?

> It was fucking witchcraft.

It was not. Apart from the multi-touch implementation which is transformational.

Apple did not put anything in that device that other manufacturers didn't have access to, and their device lacked capabilities others had.

They just did it right.

Re:On the Origin of the iPhone by imwillofficial on Sunday February 27, 2022 @11:43PM (#30496505)
Nope, I contend chicken blood must have been spilled in pentagram marked areas because after using the first iPhone I was spellbound.
Re:On the Origin of the iPhone by cpuguy83 on Saturday February 26, 2022 @08:12PM (#30484248)
I think you are mis-remembering history.

People were in awe of how responsive the system was. Things like the pins dropping on the google maps app seemed faked, bo way they could do it.

Re:On the Origin of the iPhone by pinephoneguy on Saturday February 26, 2022 @09:30PM (#30484747)
I had a Zarus at the time. It could run X11 and java apps and even had a self hosting dev environment.

The iPhone was mostly a regression from that.

Re:On the Origin of the iPhone by imwillofficial on Sunday February 27, 2022 @11:45PM (#30496512)
What everyone wants, X11 and dev environments on their cell phones. You sir, are a visionary.
Re:On the Origin of the iPhone by pinephoneguy on Monday February 28, 2022 @07:01AM (#30498937)
People don't like the constraints of smartphones but they don't understand computers well enough to articulate it. That you do and then you mock me for pointing it out indicates a particularly ugly kind of follower mentality.

X11 isn't that important, it's the large app library it brings with it (many apps that after 24 years still have no replacements on either smartphone OS.) For power users the flexibility is nice too.

Onboard dev environments aren't useful to most people but it indicates/allows a few things:

1) Individual users who are inclined can easily improve the platform with very little effort.

2) The owners of the platform aren't stopping people from doing what they want with their own devices.

Re:On the Origin of the iPhone by imwillofficial on Monday February 28, 2022 @09:47AM (#30500343)
“stopping people from doing what they want with their own devices.”

I’m guessing you don’t use toasters or Nintendos either then, because you can’t do what you want with those.

The tired arguments you trot out have been covered to death. You are a hyper niche use case, pretending the general users feels like you do is delusional.

Re:On the Origin of the iPhone by imwillofficial on Monday February 28, 2022 @09:45AM (#30500321)
Wrong, people love the constraints. Or else smart phones wouldn’t be the most popular computing devices in history, and we’d all be rocking mobile terminals.
Re:On the Origin of the iPhone by pinephoneguy on Monday February 28, 2022 @10:27AM (#30500820)
>Popularity -> utility

Talk about tired arguments. All popularity really means is good PR.

As to toasters and Nintendos, yes I do whatever I want with those, toasters have nothing to stop me and Nintendos are usually trivial (and often have flash carts available) to get a shell on.

[dead]
Re:On the Origin of the iPhone by pinephoneguy on Monday February 28, 2022 @01:12PM (#30502998)
Why wouldn't applying reason (especially since you're familiar with your personal situation) result in better decisions than just listening to people who are paid to tell you what to think? What argument are you even making here?
Re:On the Origin of the iPhone by imwillofficial on Tuesday March 01, 2022 @01:45AM (#30510501)
You are extrapolating your own personal niche tastes to the wider market. This is obviously a mistake.

Personally I am happy you have devices that satisfy your needs. I also understand that the average person makes different value calls and that drives different choices.

Summing all that up as good PR is lazy and intellectually dishonest.