News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:PeerTube: Free software to take back control of your videos by hannasanarion on Wednesday February 23, 2022 @04:16PM (#30446578)
Putting things on a peer network is the very definition of losing control of your videos. Once something's p2p, can't ever be modified or taken down.

It's a great value prop for pirates who want easy access to illegal movies and trolls who want their inflammatory opinions to ruffle feathers forever, but it's a pretty lousy deal for everyone else.

Re:PeerTube: Free software to take back control of your videos by amelius on Wednesday February 23, 2022 @04:47PM (#30446984)
This is not about controlling which videos are taken down. This is about controlling that video's can't be taken down.
Re:PeerTube: Free software to take back control of your videos by hannasanarion on Wednesday February 23, 2022 @04:54PM (#30447053)
The headline is "take back control of YOUR videos".

Videos that you downloaded from other people aren't yours. You might own a copy, but that's no different from any other system of distribution. The difference between p2p and standard distribution is that the owner loses control.

Re:PeerTube: Free software to take back control of your videos by strogonoff on Wednesday February 23, 2022 @09:02PM (#30449420)
It is a dangerous belief that anything you publish can be 100% reliably unpublished, even if you use a centralized platform that grants you the button to do so. Information does not work that way.

However, a centralized near-monopoly grants itself certain power over the spread of information: if everyone uses it and it bans your video, the video may essentially be unknown—despite your intent. That is losing control, both for you personally and for us as a society: we lose control of our videos by using one big centralized platform, which lets it hide them from us.

An interpretation of PeerTube’s slogan could be that switching to it you take control of your videos by making them less liable to become hidden due to e.g. censorship—but also in that publishing something useful on it you by extension also bring viewers into the ecosystem and thus help society as a whole take that control back by reducing its dependency on a centralized source.

Re:PeerTube: Free software to take back control of your videos by infogulch on Wednesday February 23, 2022 @05:16PM (#30447322)
Who owns it when it's on YouTube?

"The people who can destroy a thing, they control it." - Dune

Google owns it.

With peertube and the like, maybe you don't own it, but at least Google doesn't either.

Re:PeerTube: Free software to take back control of your videos by hannasanarion on Wednesday February 23, 2022 @05:19PM (#30447344)
> With peertube and the like, maybe you don't own it,

Then why are they advertising with the slogan "take back control"???

Re:PeerTube: Free software to take back control of your videos by infogulch on Wednesday February 23, 2022 @05:25PM (#30447419)
Maybe the answer would be more clear if you read the end of that quote.
Re:PeerTube: Free software to take back control of your videos by hannasanarion on Wednesday February 23, 2022 @05:33PM (#30447498)
And maybe you would understand why that statement makes absolutely no sense if you read the headline of this thread.

It doesn't say "take control away from Youtube and Google", it says take back control of your videos. p2p is the ultimate destruction of control, that's the entire point of it. Saying that peertube gives you control is like saying that playing a slot machine gives you ROI.

Re:PeerTube: Free software to take back control of your videos by infogulch on Wednesday February 23, 2022 @06:01PM (#30447855)
You're deconstructing a head of lettuce and wondering why you get word salad. Language isn't that simple. Insisting on narrow interpretations of individual words isn't helpful. You need more context to understand it, not less.

With p2p, control is transferred away from Google to you and anyone else that chooses to host it. This is reasonable justification for using "take back control" to me.

I guess you'd also object to GPL being described as "more free" than MIT.

Re:PeerTube: Free software to take back control of your videos by robwwilliams on Wednesday February 23, 2022 @07:36PM (#30448803)
Brilliant metaphor! Is that your own invention? No hits on DDG.
Re:PeerTube: Free software to take back control of your videos by infogulch on Wednesday February 23, 2022 @08:45PM (#30449284)
Thanks! I came up with it on the spot, maybe because I had recently eaten a salad. :) It could be better, let me know if you improve it.
Re:PeerTube: Free software to take back control of your videos by altantiprocrast on Wednesday February 23, 2022 @05:20PM (#30447356)
> owner loses control

the owner retains control of distributing their voice without a major platform getting in the way

Re:PeerTube: Free software to take back control of your videos by hannasanarion on Wednesday February 23, 2022 @05:27PM (#30447439)
The owner retains control of nothing. From the instant you first seed to p2p, there is nothing you can do anymore to change what might happen next. You completely lose all agency over your own material. That is not "control".

If you want to get off a platform, you can do that with a website. You don't need to give up editorial and retractive control forever (which you must do in order to use p2p, which is why this headline is so wrong) just to step off a platform.

Re:PeerTube: Free software to take back control of your videos by littlestymaar on Thursday February 24, 2022 @07:23AM (#30453859)
> The owner retains control of nothing. From the instant you first seed to p2p, there is nothing you can do anymore to change what might happen next. You completely lose all agency over your own material. That is not "control".

(putting aside the fact that peertube is NOT A P2P distribution platform[1])

P2P is not different from any kind of distribution mechanism for digital content: the moment you put your content online, you've lost a good chunk of control over it since anyone can now download it a re-upload it elsewhere. This is automatic for p2p, but it also happen all the time on youtube, (or worse, porn tubes).

There is no way around it so far, and DRMs have largely failed preventing that. So any content creator must know this at this point: once you've published something online, you cannot reliably unpublish it.

Now, when you go through a centralized platform you also lose one more part of control: not only you cannot unpublish it, but you also cannot guarantee that it will remain published. This is the part of control you can get back by using peertube or other federated or distributed streaming system.

[1]: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30453806

Re:PeerTube: Free software to take back control of your videos by detaro on Thursday February 24, 2022 @07:16AM (#30453813)
I upload a video to a PeerTube instance. I then delete it. What is happening outside my control that won't happen on other hosting?
Re:PeerTube: Free software to take back control of your videos by vorpalhex on Wednesday February 23, 2022 @04:42PM (#30446913)
That's a feature. Youtube (read Google) should not be the global police on what videos are allowed.

Yes, what is posted on the internet can not be taken back. That has always been and remains true.

No, I don't think piracy/trolls/whatever needs peertube, they do just fine without it now.

Re:PeerTube: Free software to take back control of your videos by hannasanarion on Wednesday February 23, 2022 @05:02PM (#30447164)
But that's not what this headline is claiming. It's claiming that PeerTube will give you control of your videos. That's the one thing that p2p services do not and cannot ever do. Putting content on p2p is synonymous with giving up control of it forever.
Re:PeerTube: Free software to take back control of your videos by betwixthewires on Wednesday February 23, 2022 @05:41PM (#30447598)
This argument is weaksauce. Putting anything publicly on the internet immediately means relinquishing control of it. P2P has nothing to do with that.

"Take back control" is geared towards hosts. You can run your own tube site. That's what the slogan is talking about.

Also, peertube is no more p2p than bitchute. It uses webRTC to offload server load onto clients for popular videos, that's it.

Re:PeerTube: Free software to take back control of your videos by eitland on Wednesday February 23, 2022 @05:16PM (#30447312)
On YouTube you cannot control anything:

- YouTube can remove it

- people can store offline copies

On Peertube at least YouTube can't take it down which means you have more control over it.

Re:PeerTube: Free software to take back control of your videos by hannasanarion on Wednesday February 23, 2022 @05:21PM (#30447374)
You don't think that youtube channels have the ability to take down or edit their own videos?

What exactly do you think "control" means?

Re:PeerTube: Free software to take back control of your videos by southerntofu on Thursday February 24, 2022 @08:52AM (#30454632)
I realize you're probably just trolling, but Peertube also has a button to delete your own video. The instance will stop serving/seeding it so even if some people hold a copy it will be hard if possible at all (even with the info hash) to access it.

Of course some people could upload it again someplace else and there's pretty much nothing you can do about it. Not that different from traditional tape media and CD/DVD.

Re:PeerTube: Free software to take back control of your videos by yjftsjthsd-h on Wednesday February 23, 2022 @05:12PM (#30447268)
> It's a great value prop for pirates who want easy access to illegal movies and trolls who want their inflammatory opinions to ruffle feathers forever, but it's a pretty lousy deal for everyone else.

Not everyone else; it's a good deal for anyone who wants their content to be censorship-resistant, which is not just trolls and pirates.

Re:PeerTube: Free software to take back control of your videos by karmanyaahm on Wednesday February 23, 2022 @04:55PM (#30447067)
> can't ever be modified or taken down.

> but it's a pretty lousy deal for everyone else

Is it really a lousy deal for anyone who doesn't agree with YouTube/Facebook/Twitter's moderation (political or otherwise)?

Or do you think that everyone the big platforms disagree with are 'trolls who want their inflammatory opinions'?

Re:PeerTube: Free software to take back control of your videos by hannasanarion on Wednesday February 23, 2022 @05:08PM (#30447235)
Why in the world would someone who wants "control" of their content use p2p instead of youtube?

If you're worried about platform censorship, the solution that gives you more control is to self-host, not to completely resign all editorial power for the rest of eternity by handing your content over to a peer network.

p2p doesn't give you control of content, it takes away all control of content by ossifying it as-is.

Re:PeerTube: Free software to take back control of your videos by southerntofu on Thursday February 24, 2022 @09:02AM (#30454749)
> If you're worried about platform censorship, the solution that gives you more control is to self-host

Thanks for pointing this out! This is precisely what the Peertube project is about. It's *not* a P2P tube where discovery/notification is unmediated between peers. Peertube is a software for selfhosting your own "tube", which supports federation between hosts so your content can be discovered from elsewhere (with allow/deny lists supported).

The P2P bits of Peertube is only for video delivery, which is very clever. It was always possible to setup your own Youtube (eg. with MediaGoblin) but who had the hardware and connectivity to do that?! Especially since:

- if a video has a peak of popularity, a centralized setup has to send a separate stream to every viewer

- if people want to view a video from which your instance doesn't have good connectivity, it will be terrible user experience, unless you as a server operator setup a sort of CDN which is expensive and more complex than it has to be

Peertube has a very interesting hybrid federated/p2p design where the owner retains control on the published material (you can delete videos from your account), but both viewers and federated instances replicating your materials can help seed it to more people.

Peertube is intended for selfhosting for existing communities (non-profits, conferences, classrooms, etc) and it gives us the practical power to do it without requiring thousands of euros of monthly infrastructure bills.

Re:PeerTube: Free software to take back control of your videos by jka on Wednesday February 23, 2022 @04:41PM (#30446881)
Can you see any ways in which uploading your videos to one of a (very) small number of market-leading platforms could be problematic, in contrast?
Re:PeerTube: Free software to take back control of your videos by hannasanarion on Wednesday February 23, 2022 @04:55PM (#30447071)
Certainly. But one thing that they definitely do, and that p2p hosting does not, is give people control of their videos, which is what this headline is claiming.
Re:PeerTube: Free software to take back control of your videos by jka on Wednesday February 23, 2022 @05:03PM (#30447175)
Ok, thanks - I'm more ambivalent about the situation: I think it can be unclear, and can depend on people's perspectives regarding privacy and control, and the behaviours of the platforms and software available (all of which can be culture, context and chronology sensitive).

Perhaps the existence of different options at the moment is necessary until there's (ever?) any consensus on a satisfying unified technology and sharing model for content.

(if this seems confusing, please consider: it's not a technological absolute that use of a peer-to-peer platform means that you have to share your content with everyone; it can be a choice if the technology caters for it)

Re:PeerTube: Free software to take back control of your videos by littlestymaar on Thursday February 24, 2022 @07:14AM (#30453806)
But this is not how it works with peertube: you aren't publishing a torrent containing a video, you are uploading a video to a specific peertube instance, and on top of that there is a WebRTC-based P2P CDN (you're sharing data with other people watching the same video at the same time), but that's it.
Re:PeerTube: Free software to take back control of your videos by imwillofficial on Wednesday February 23, 2022 @04:42PM (#30446911)
You can control how they are shared, if at all.

It’s not a binary choice.

I run a self hosted instance and don’t share anything with anyone.

Re:PeerTube: Free software to take back control of your videos by waffle_maniac on Wednesday February 23, 2022 @04:43PM (#30446926)
When I run ‘youtube-dl’ on your YouTube video will you live in fear for the rest of your life?
Re:PeerTube: Free software to take back control of your videos by xmprt on Wednesday February 23, 2022 @04:55PM (#30447074)
I've deleted/privated/unlisted a few cringy YouTube videos from about 10 years ago. I have fairly high confidence that even in the insanely rare case that my other videos become popular or I become a celebrity, no one will find those old videos. That's not possible with a P2P service.
Re:PeerTube: Free software to take back control of your videos by southerntofu on Thursday February 24, 2022 @08:56AM (#30454674)
It's definitely possible.

First because the list of videos you advertise on an instance/channel is dynamic, not an append-only log like on a blockchain. So you can properly delist a video from your Peertube channel and it will no longer appear to clients.

Second, because even if people still has the infohash somehow and continue to seed it, there needs to be a mechanism to find other peers when someone wants to download the content (how did they obtain the infohash?). It's technically possible (although becoming harder with peertube moving from Webtorrent to WebRTC+HLS) but not a supported use-case (you'd have to write another piece of software for that).

All in all, the situation is pretty similar to that of Youtube. Yes someone could have a copy of your cringy videos and decide to upload them elsewhere, but your followers would not automagically discover them. The same goes with Peertube, which is more federated than P2P in its design.

Re:PeerTube: Free software to take back control of your videos by sp332 on Wednesday February 23, 2022 @07:35PM (#30448787)
It's about the same. If no one cares to seed and save your videos, they will not be accessible.
Re:PeerTube: Free software to take back control of your videos by hannasanarion on Wednesday February 23, 2022 @04:54PM (#30447061)
No, but youtube-dl isn't being marketed at video owners as a way to "take back control of your videos".