News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:I shaved 187MB off United Airlines' 439MB iOS app by azalemeth on Wednesday February 23, 2022 @12:06PM (#30443339)
I once flew United and, like the author, didn't realise this until I was on the plane for a ten hour flight. Downloaded the app for Android. I opened it. I was immediately ip-blocked for having a rooted phone, which was then kicked off the network and couldn't get an IP address. United cabin crew then started trying to sell me an iPad loan for the duration. I read a book and vowed never to fly with them again.
Re:I shaved 187MB off United Airlines' 439MB iOS app by _fat_santa on Wednesday February 23, 2022 @01:10PM (#30444258)
Unrelated to their inflight entertainment, United pulled this stunt on me the other day.

- Flight at 11AM, boarding at 10:20.

- Show up at 10:25, boarding doors are closed.

- "Didn't boarding start 5 minutes ago"

- "Yeah we close the doors once 95% of people show up, sorry, you should show up when boarding starts"

- "Yeah but didn't boarding start 5 minutes ago, how was I to know"

- "You should have known, sorry"

Re:I shaved 187MB off United Airlines' 439MB iOS app by assbuttbuttass on Wednesday February 23, 2022 @02:54PM (#30445529)
They managed to board all the other passengers in less than 5 minutes? In my experience boarding takes at least half an hour just for everybody to sit down. Was the flight exceptionally empty?
Re:I shaved 187MB off United Airlines' 439MB iOS app by trelliscoded on Wednesday February 23, 2022 @04:31PM (#30446748)
They may be queued up in the jet bridge. I've been stuck inside one after the doors closed while we waited for everyone to get into the plane.
Re:I shaved 187MB off United Airlines' 439MB iOS app by sb057 on Wednesday February 23, 2022 @01:44PM (#30444681)
>Yeah we close the doors once 95% of people show up

So they are essentially scamming 5% of passengers out of their tickets?

Re:I shaved 187MB off United Airlines' 439MB iOS app by vel0city on Wednesday February 23, 2022 @03:28PM (#30445982)
I mean, you're supposed to be at the gate when boarding starts. For all practical purposes if you miss boarding you've missed your flight even if the plane hasn't left the ground due to safety rules about letting passengers go after the door is considered closed.

There's a bit of a checklist of things that need to be completed after the door gets closed and the gate pulls away. They're often incentivized to try and speed things up, so if there's nobody at the gate anymore to board they might assume those passengers decided not to go on the flight. Especially with people now checking into flights the day before, the airline may not even know if the passenger is even at the airport and would realistically show up to the gate anytime soon as checking in means pretty much nothing these days.

They're not scamming anyone. Your ticket said you were supposed to be at the gate to board at a certain time. You weren't there, so you missed the flight.

Re:I shaved 187MB off United Airlines' 439MB iOS app by wrggwwr on Wednesday February 23, 2022 @06:02PM (#30447858)
Luckily, common air carriers do not run on anarchy and made-up rules. United, like every airline, has a Contract of Carriage, which clearly requires being at the gate only 15 minutes before a scheduled domestic flight:

> All Passengers must be present at the loading gate for boarding at least 15 minutes prior to scheduled departure.

The OP was clearly involuntarily denied boarding even if it was an international flight, and is eligible for that compensation.

https://www.united.com/en/us/fly/contract-of-carriage.html#r...

Re:I shaved 187MB off United Airlines' 439MB iOS app by pdx_flyer on Wednesday February 23, 2022 @08:54PM (#30449367)
Exactly. Contact United and if they push back, contact the DOT. There's a process for how this kind of stuff gets handled.

UA's team has access to exactly when the door closed and if it was greater than 15 minutes before the scheduled departure time, they owe the OP.

Re:I shaved 187MB off United Airlines' 439MB iOS app by tedunangst on Wednesday February 23, 2022 @07:43PM (#30448862)
OP showed up five minutes late, not fifteen minutes early.
Re:I shaved 187MB off United Airlines' 439MB iOS app by nopzor on Wednesday February 23, 2022 @08:05PM (#30449035)
op was more than fifteen minutes early to the departure time. boarding time is irrelevant to the clause in the coc.
Re:I shaved 187MB off United Airlines' 439MB iOS app by tedunangst on Wednesday February 23, 2022 @08:34PM (#30449241)
Oh! I should read more carefully.
Re:I shaved 187MB off United Airlines' 439MB iOS app by ricardobeat on Wednesday February 23, 2022 @07:55PM (#30448960)
There is a boarding time on every ticket. Anyone who has flown more than once knows this is not optional - closing the gate and departing early is at the airline’s discretion.

Once they started boarding and the queue is empty, they will continue with the procedures for the flight, they have an incentive to keep their on-time stats. It’s not like a train where you can simply step in a minute before it leaves.

Re:I shaved 187MB off United Airlines' 439MB iOS app by wrggwwr on Wednesday February 23, 2022 @08:35PM (#30449242)
There is not a boarding time on any airline ticket; you can book a flight for yourself and look at the issued eTicket. Your ticket will only have a departure (and perhaps arrival) time.

Some airlines print a boarding time for their flights onto their boarding passes, or show it in their app. This is often a fake number simply computed by deducting 30 or 40 minutes from your flight's departure time; it's certainly not adhered to very closely or involved in most contract of carriages.

One reason for this is that an airline is usually not involved in issuing all of its boarding passes, and so many boarding passes simply do not have a "boarding time" on them. Air India is perfectly capable of issuing boarding passes for United, but are unlikely to have easy access a "boarding time" from United (since it's not very important).

United makes passenger obligations clear -- arrive 15/30 minutes before a domestic/international departure. Otherwise, it's an IDB.

Re:I shaved 187MB off United Airlines' 439MB iOS app by ricardobeat on Friday February 25, 2022 @07:58PM (#30474329)
Right, I meant boarding passes. Since as you said, (estimated) boarding time is usually set to 30-40 minutes before departure, and gates usually close 20m-15m before departure, arriving 15m after the announced "boarding time" is obviously risky. Not sure what's up for debate here.
Re:I shaved 187MB off United Airlines' 439MB iOS app by dlubarov on Wednesday February 23, 2022 @08:37PM (#30449252)
According to what? To me "boarding time" doesn't mean anything other than the time they plan to begin boarding. Is there actually a policy that passengers must be present by that time?

What the parent quoted seems to be United's actual policy, i.e. that they'll accept any (domestic) passengers who arrive 15+ minutes before departure.

Re:I shaved 187MB off United Airlines' 439MB iOS app by xmprt on Wednesday February 23, 2022 @04:31PM (#30446743)
I get that rule. But why does the door close at boarding time and not at the flight time or some predetermined time like 10 minutes before flight time or when boarding completes, whichever is later.
Re:I shaved 187MB off United Airlines' 439MB iOS app by vel0city on Wednesday February 23, 2022 @04:44PM (#30446943)
The door closes when it seems like there's no more passengers so they can hurry up and start working on the checklist. They do this so they can potentially get going sooner in case there are delays elsewhere in the many steps that goes from passenger boarding to plane in the air. Theoretically they could be more rigid about having a time for the door closing, but that could potentially mean there are more actual delays as now they no longer have a chance to gain some time in their schedule to make up for potential delays elsewhere.

If the door closed at flight time then the plane wouldn't be leaving at flight time, it would be leaving at flight time + the time it takes to go from boarding to getting in the air. Flight time is the time the plane is scheduled to take off, which means the flight time would diverge from the boarding time, and then you'd once again be asking why the boarding time is different from the flight time and why they don't let you board until the flight time, rinse and repeat.

Re:I shaved 187MB off United Airlines' 439MB iOS app by IshKebab on Wednesday February 23, 2022 @05:28PM (#30447460)
Sounds like you're describing some impossible system but that is how it works in the rest of the world. There's a time at which the gates close, and if you're at the gate before then then you can go on the flight. If not then they might wait for you for a bit if you've already checked in but nothing is guaranteed.

They can still go early if all of the passengers have boarded.

I got to Dublin airport once at the time that the gates were supposed to close and they said they would wait for us if we were fast... Got to the concourse and it was the furthest gate possible - the sign said to allow a 15 minute walk! Had to run all the way but we made it.

Re:I shaved 187MB off United Airlines' 439MB iOS app by vel0city on Wednesday February 23, 2022 @06:20PM (#30448054)
> There's a time at which the gates close

And there's a time in the US as well, that's called the boarding time. Those there at the boarding time get on the plane, those aren't there at the boarding time missed their flight. Banking on getting on 5-10 minutes after boarding time is gambling that they're running behind schedule.

Re:I shaved 187MB off United Airlines' 439MB iOS app by larrybud on Wednesday February 23, 2022 @10:14PM (#30449798)
Um, no. Read the thread about 2-4 parents up. United’s contract of carriage says 15 min before departure for domestic flights.
Re:I shaved 187MB off United Airlines' 439MB iOS app by xmprt on Wednesday February 23, 2022 @06:26PM (#30448124)
In that case, every single airline in the US doesn't care about their passengers' time because I can't remember the first time that boarding actually started at boarding time. And when it does, I'm stuck waiting an extra 15 minutes so all the priority and higher class passengers can board first.
Re:I shaved 187MB off United Airlines' 439MB iOS app by digisign on Wednesday February 23, 2022 @01:24PM (#30444437)
United is famous for its customer service. I have a few good ones myself, but won't bore you.
Re:I shaved 187MB off United Airlines' 439MB iOS app by quacked on Wednesday February 23, 2022 @02:00PM (#30444871)
If you think that airline customer service stories are boring, then I request that you do your best to bore me.
Re:I shaved 187MB off United Airlines' 439MB iOS app by magicroot75 on Friday February 25, 2022 @01:09AM (#30464153)
I have trouble believing this is the entire story. You're saying you were at the gate thirty-five minutes before the scheduled departure time on the originally scheduled flight and were denied boarding? I could see this happening if there were a delay that was later truncated. In that case the airline does often expedite boarding to make up for the delay.
Re:I shaved 187MB off United Airlines' 439MB iOS app by cromka on Wednesday February 23, 2022 @07:30PM (#30448739)
Is this even legal?
Re:I shaved 187MB off United Airlines' 439MB iOS app by agar on Wednesday February 23, 2022 @02:18PM (#30445083)
This was probably a response to a hack that occurred in 2014. It wouldn't surprise me if it was mandated by the FAA or similar regulatory body.

https://www.cnn.com/2015/05/17/us/fbi-hacker-flight-computer...

> During FBI interviews in February and March, the document says, Roberts told investigators he hacked into in-flight entertainment systems aboard aircraft. He claimed to have done so 15 to 20 times from 2011 to 2014.

> He also said, according to the document, that once he had hacked into the systems and then overwrote code, enabling him to issue a “CLB,” or climb, command.

> “He stated that he thereby caused one of the airplane engines to climb resulting in a lateral or sideways movement of the plane during one of these flights,” the document says.

Re:I shaved 187MB off United Airlines' 439MB iOS app by tyingq on Wednesday February 23, 2022 @02:23PM (#30445145)
I doubt it. You can bring a "rooted" linux laptop onto the plane and it works, so banning rooted phones from inflight WiFi would be a little silly.

I am interested in the linked story, but it's very odd that a passenger wifi network would be cross-connected with flight controls.

That the network on a non-wifi seatback entertainment system could be is a little more believable, but I'm still curious how it wouldn't have resulted in an extended grounding of all aircraft of that type if it were true. There was no grounding, or order to modify that system following his twitter posts and subsequent arrest.

Edit: If you search around for what happened after the incident described above, it seems pretty clear he did not send any commands to flight systems. He seems knowledgeable about them, but seems to perhaps have been caught out talking about a theoretical scenario as if it happened. He wasn't charged, and as mentioned, no actions were taken to change anything. I suspect the networks are properly isolated.

Re:I shaved 187MB off United Airlines' 439MB iOS app by xmprt on Wednesday February 23, 2022 @04:33PM (#30446776)
I hate when apps lock out rooted Android phones for "security purposes" when it's so simple to get around it by just directly accessing the API or spoofing. It's even dumber when the app/website can be accessed through a laptop which is much more permissive than a rooted phone. I've never heard a reason for why companies do this.
Re:I shaved 187MB off United Airlines' 439MB iOS app by throwinthisaway on Wednesday February 23, 2022 @08:13PM (#30449106)
I’ve worked with Chris. I wouldn’t believe a word out of his mouth.
Re:I shaved 187MB off United Airlines' 439MB iOS app by tyingq on Wednesday February 23, 2022 @01:27PM (#30444481)
I'm surprised there would be that kind of integration between the United app and their on-board WiFi, which appears to be run by Panasonic.

It sounds like you're saying the United app noticed your phone was rooted, and somehow it notified the on-board WiFi to block your ip/mac? Or am I not reading this right?

Re:I shaved 187MB off United Airlines' 439MB iOS app by varenc on Wednesday February 23, 2022 @01:46PM (#30444702)
That's also how I read it, which astounds me. Would be technically impressive if it worked like that. And extra vindictive since even if they don't allow rooted devices to play DRM'd video, there's no good reason why they should also be prevented from buying in-flight internet.

(one solution if that's really how it works: rotate your mac address, reconnect, and then never open up the United app again so it can't squeal on you.)

Re:I shaved 187MB off United Airlines' 439MB iOS app by asdff on Wednesday February 23, 2022 @07:50PM (#30448920)
This is pretty common, as stupid as it is. Snapchat would do this too for jailbroken phones, only they'd also permanently ban your account. It was an arms race between snapchat and tweak developers masking jailbreak detection methods for years at least, maybe still ongoing.
Re:I shaved 187MB off United Airlines' 439MB iOS app by tyingq on Wednesday February 23, 2022 @09:36PM (#30449594)
The odd part is tying the airline's app to a wholly separate thing run by Panasonic (the onboard wifi). The United app isn't required, involved, etc, in purchasing and using wifi on the aircraft. No app is required at all...just the browser on the phone. That's why we're confused about the integration that would be needed to accomplish this. The United app would have to be detecting the jailbreak and then sending some unique identifier to the third party via some separate channel.
Re:I shaved 187MB off United Airlines' 439MB iOS app by tyingq on Wednesday February 23, 2022 @01:58PM (#30444840)
You could also wreak some havoc by banning the macs of other devices on the plane that want to use the WiFi...so I'm pretty skeptical this cross-service integration is really there.
Re:I shaved 187MB off United Airlines' 439MB iOS app by iamcreasy on Wednesday February 23, 2022 @01:29PM (#30444505)
> I was immediately ip-blocked for having a rooted phone

What is wrong with using their app on a rooted phone?

Re:I shaved 187MB off United Airlines' 439MB iOS app by tyingq on Wednesday February 23, 2022 @01:50PM (#30444736)
Not saying it's the right decision, but probably because they don't want the liability if a rooted device allows some 3rd party app to hack theirs. Airlines can be somewhat like a small bank in this respect, as being logged in gives you access to things like accumulated loyalty points, not-flown-tickets that can be exchanged/refunded, past flight credit from earlier refunds that were eligible for credit but not a cash refund, etc.

Also, they typically store more personal info than, say, an e-commerce application because some of it is needed for travel. Things like date of birth, known traveler numbers, names/dob/etc of family members, passport numbers, etc.

Re:I shaved 187MB off United Airlines' 439MB iOS app by asdff on Wednesday February 23, 2022 @07:55PM (#30448956)
At that rate why not also ip ban any general purpose compute device from accessing their servers? I can't believe a major airline has programmers who think blocking jailbroken cellphones would do anything at all to thwart a hack. It makes me think twice about flying United certainly if these are the incompetent hands I'm placing my trust in.
Re:I shaved 187MB off United Airlines' 439MB iOS app by tyingq on Wednesday February 23, 2022 @08:52PM (#30449341)
Not that I agree with it, but the usual line of reasoning is that they have laxer rules on a native app. Like no captchas, much longer session timeouts, etc. So they aren't comfortable with the looser rules on a rooted phone.
Re:I shaved 187MB off United Airlines' 439MB iOS app by asdff on Thursday February 24, 2022 @12:31AM (#30450760)
Once again, things that are trivially bypassed by people who are active in this space, and their programmers should know better than using this line of reasoning that must just be ancient procedure at this point, especially considering the cargo they are tasked to ensure is safe.
Re:I shaved 187MB off United Airlines' 439MB iOS app by stevep98 on Wednesday February 23, 2022 @03:49PM (#30446235)
Likely a DRM requirement so you can’t pirate their movies
Re:I shaved 187MB off United Airlines' 439MB iOS app by tyingq on Wednesday February 23, 2022 @07:44PM (#30448872)
You don't need the United App to buy and use WiFi on their planes, so this seems unlikely to me.
Re:I shaved 187MB off United Airlines' 439MB iOS app by mdoms on Wednesday February 23, 2022 @01:39PM (#30444628)
Not defending the blocking of rooted devices, but I think it's excellent that airlines are relying on people bringing their own hardware. I think you'd struggle to find a single person in an airport who isn't carrying a screen with them today, so seat-back screens feel very redundant to me.
Re:I shaved 187MB off United Airlines' 439MB iOS app by asdff on Wednesday February 23, 2022 @07:58PM (#30448986)
They aren't doing it to be green, they are doing it to save money on chair replacements. I'm surprised how rare it is even to get a seat with power hookups these days. Even in the actual airport itself plugs are still relatively rare and closely guarded, actual functioning plugs rarer still. I remember when economy meant a new set of headphones and the billboard top 20 playing from the arm rest.
Re:I shaved 187MB off United Airlines' 439MB iOS app by pdx_flyer on Wednesday February 23, 2022 @08:52PM (#30449345)
And weight from the video boxes under the seats. Multiply that weight * 2-3 for every row and it adds up quickly.
Re:I shaved 187MB off United Airlines' 439MB iOS app by rekoil on Wednesday February 23, 2022 @02:37PM (#30445296)
As a person who carries a 5.4" iPhone 12 mini, please keep seat-back screens. I wouldn't mind if they were just HDMI-devices I can extend my devices screen to though, that would be amazing!
Re:I shaved 187MB off United Airlines' 439MB iOS app by tonywastaken on Wednesday February 23, 2022 @12:27PM (#30443667)
They had a similar check for jailbroken iPhones. The last time I flew with them they seem to have fixed it.
Re:I shaved 187MB off United Airlines' 439MB iOS app by digisign on Wednesday February 23, 2022 @01:26PM (#30444462)
Fixed to block or not block?