News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:First gene therapy for Tay-Sachs disease successfully giv... by DaveExeter on Sunday February 20, 2022 @05:47PM (#30410006)
These two children should have never been born. No one should be born with Tay-Sachs, a genetic disease.
Re:First gene therapy for Tay-Sachs disease successfully giv... by Kye on Sunday February 20, 2022 @07:16PM (#30410556)
Eugenics has a somewhat fraught past. Everyone who tried it thought they were doing their victims a favor.
Re:First gene therapy for Tay-Sachs disease successfully giv... by dragonwriter on Sunday February 20, 2022 @07:29PM (#30410634)
> Eugenics has a somewhat fraught past.

That's...an understatement.

> Everyone who tried it thought they were doing their victims a favor.

No, not everyone who did it thought that they were doing their victims a favor. Quite a lot saw their victims as people who ought to be sacrificed for the good of others, and if they thought they were doing them a favor it was only in not murdering them outright as well as preventing them from reproducing.

Of course, some eugenics practitioners didn't bother avoiding outright murder, e.g., the Nazis.

Re:First gene therapy for Tay-Sachs disease successfully giv... by Kye on Sunday February 20, 2022 @07:34PM (#30410661)
This is a bit of a tangent off me pointing out someone's suggestion was eugenics. I'm not sure what I'm supposed to take away from this comment. We obviously can't read the minds of eugenics pushers, and very few openly admit their True Aims, so there's not any point trying to litigate it here.
Re:First gene therapy for Tay-Sachs disease successfully giv... by DoreenMichele on Sunday February 20, 2022 @07:18PM (#30410568)
^ This.

In the United States today, approximately 1 in every 27 Jews is a Tay-Sachs carrier.

https://healthresearchfunding.org/17-good-statistics-tay-sac...

Re:First gene therapy for Tay-Sachs disease successfully giv... by dogma1138 on Sunday February 20, 2022 @08:00PM (#30410813)
Israel performs pre and post conception screenings for TS and a few other genetic diseases that are common within the Jewish population.

Just calling every genetic screening designed to prevent actual suffering eugenics is pretty nonsensical.

Re:First gene therapy for Tay-Sachs disease successfully giv... by ars on Sunday February 20, 2022 @09:10PM (#30411198)
Not just Israel - most Jews everywhere will use the screening. If two people are both carriers they suggest they don't marry, normally the screening is checked after the first date.

And regarding eugenics they only screen for diseases that require two carriers, because such a person can marry someone who is not a carrier. Diseases that manifest with a single copy of the gene are specifically not screened for because there's nothing the person can do in that case.

Re:First gene therapy for Tay-Sachs disease successfully giv... by DoreenMichele on Sunday February 20, 2022 @08:02PM (#30410832)
Just calling every genetic screening designed to prevent actual suffering eugenics is pretty nonsensical.

It's also putting words in my mouth since I said no such thing.

Re:First gene therapy for Tay-Sachs disease successfully giv... by dogma1138 on Sunday February 20, 2022 @08:07PM (#30410862)
Apologies then just your reply seemed to indicate that you were agreeing with these screenings and the termination that follows them being eugenics.

My litmus test for eugenics requires an ideological and social engineering component.

Simply telling parents well if you bring a child to the world they’ll die within 2 years and suffer greatly isn’t that. Neither is offering them other tools such as using a sperm or egg donor or adoption.

Re:First gene therapy for Tay-Sachs disease successfully giv... by DoreenMichele on Sunday February 20, 2022 @08:10PM (#30410870)
The OP to which I declined to reply says: No one should be born with Tay-Sachs, a genetic disease.

I agreed with a reply to that suggesting such an extreme and unnuanced statement amounted to eugenics since the only means to actually ensure that no child will ever be born with X genetic disease would require rather extreme measures that go far beyond providing testing and options.

Re:First gene therapy for Tay-Sachs disease successfully giv... by s1artibartfast on Monday February 21, 2022 @11:24AM (#30417561)
There is a difference between saying something shouldn't happen, and it should be prevented by any means necessary.

I really shouldn't smoke. I don't endorse SS officers killing me if I do.

Re:First gene therapy for Tay-Sachs disease successfully giv... by zionic on Sunday February 20, 2022 @10:16PM (#30411588)
> Just calling every genetic screening designed to prevent actual suffering eugenics is pretty nonsensical.

It’s also not wrong, if we’re being totally honest.

Things are either eu (beneficial) or dys (harmful) genic.

The bottom 75% of the IQ curve has been poisoned against the word “eugenics” to the point that they can’t even have a basic conversation about things as sane as “genetic screening for debilitating illness” without completely breaking down.

Re:First gene therapy for Tay-Sachs disease successfully giv... by DoreenMichele on Sunday February 20, 2022 @10:34PM (#30411688)
The bottom 75% of the IQ curve has been poisoned against the word “eugenics” to the point that they can’t even have a basic conversation about things as sane as “genetic screening for debilitating illness” without completely breaking down.

This is a really not good way to engage with this topic. I'm not happy seeing this kind of framing on HN of what is an extremely sensitive topic for many people and with good reason.

Re:First gene therapy for Tay-Sachs disease successfully giv... by Kye on Sunday February 20, 2022 @10:43PM (#30411736)
Agreed. I think some people in the pro-eugenics crowd mistake a broad anti-eugenics stance as an ignorant denial of possible benefits. I think it could be good and fine, but I don't trust humans to make those decisions. I don't trust myself to make that call.
Re:First gene therapy for Tay-Sachs disease successfully giv... by speleding on Monday February 21, 2022 @04:00AM (#30413451)
So, how would you frame it? I realise it's a sensitive discussion that can easily degenerate, but the subject should not be taboo on HN.
Re:First gene therapy for Tay-Sachs disease successfully giv... by dekhn on Monday February 21, 2022 @09:14PM (#30423318)
I don't think there's any real venue in which a discussion of permanent germline modification of humanity (or in-utero modification that affects all cells) can be rationally discussed. I've never seen any productive discussion of this in any context. It's one of the few issues that dives so deeply to the core of the human value system that it's truly challenging to come up even with the terms of the debate.

That said I expect that in the future, for many genetically inherited diseases, parents will be given the option to address the problem without termination, so long as the solution seems to be exceptionally safe and highly effective (IE, 99.999% confidence the outcome will be positive). I don't think people will see that as "eugenics", although there have been a few press campaigns that have done so.

Re:First gene therapy for Tay-Sachs disease successfully giv... by Kye on Sunday February 20, 2022 @07:22PM (#30410589)
I had no idea. I just used my "wait, no, that's eugenics" heuristic. Now I know!

One day it's "we should save these kids from a difficult life," the next it's "we need symbols to tell undesirables apart," the next it's "we have too many people in camps and nowhere to send them." People like me ended up in those camps next to the Jews, so I'm not keen on the noise that starts the landslide.

Re:First gene therapy for Tay-Sachs disease successfully giv... by ethbr0 on Sunday February 20, 2022 @08:54PM (#30411109)
There's an unfortunate truth that proponents of equality are going to have to deal with at some point: we are biologically different, to greater or lesser degrees.

That's a fact. And it's only going to be more of a fact the deeper we dig into our genetic code.

But it's how we respond to and deal with that that determines whether we commit good or evil.

Re:First gene therapy for Tay-Sachs disease successfully giv... by zionic on Sunday February 20, 2022 @10:18PM (#30411601)
> that proponents of equality are going to have to deal with

We both know that will never happen. They’ll never “deal with” the flaws in their religion, they’ll just ignore it like all the others do.

Re:First gene therapy for Tay-Sachs disease successfully giv... by ethbr0 on Sunday February 20, 2022 @10:40PM (#30411722)
I have more optimism. Dogmas are hard to cast aside, but gradually things progress forward.
Re:First gene therapy for Tay-Sachs disease successfully giv... by seo-speedwagon on Sunday February 20, 2022 @08:21PM (#30410936)
1. Tay-Sachs is not limited to a single ethnicity. Carriers exist in the population in general.

2. Assuming you’re referring to the fact that being a carrier is more common in Ashkenazi Jews, you’re aware that there are a number of genetic screening programs run by Jewish organizations, right?

Re:First gene therapy for Tay-Sachs disease successfully giv... by disabled on Sunday February 20, 2022 @07:34PM (#30410659)
Dude, there are people who have children with Tay-Sachs, who are NOT ethnically Jewish at all. 1 in 250 people in the general population is a carrier for Tay-Sachs.

Also, literally everyone is a carrier of mutations for extremely devastating diseases. You just do not know which ones.

This is from a US government website covering Tay-Sachs (https://www.genome.gov/Genetic-Disorders/Tay-Sachs-Disease):

“While anyone can be a carrier of Tay-Sachs, the incidence of the disease is significantly higher among people of eastern European (Ashkenazi) Jewish descent. Approximately one in every 27 Jews in the United States is a carrier of the Tay-Sachs disease gene. Non-Jewish French Canadians living near the St. Lawrence River and in the Cajun community of Louisiana also have a higher incidence of Tay-Sachs. For the general population, about one in 250 people are carriers.”

Re:First gene therapy for Tay-Sachs disease successfully giv... by stefan_ on Sunday February 20, 2022 @09:03PM (#30411150)
I don't understand, the parent said nothing about Jews at all. Nonetheless, given the incidence among them, they also happen to be pioneers in prescreening for this very genetic defect.
Re:First gene therapy for Tay-Sachs disease successfully giv... by tasha0663 on Sunday February 20, 2022 @10:46PM (#30411757)
Yeah, that's weird. Either the association is so strong with some people that they can't see Tay-Sachs without immediately thinking Ashkenazi, or there was a stealth edit to the comment.
Re:First gene therapy for Tay-Sachs disease successfully giv... by DaveExeter on Sunday February 20, 2022 @11:23PM (#30411966)
No stealth edit!

Genetic testing can identify carriers, so if Tay-Sachs has been (mostly) 'vanquished' from the Ashkenazi community, it can be 'vanquished' completely.

https://www.nytimes.com/2003/02/18/science/using-genetic-tes...

Re:First gene therapy for Tay-Sachs disease successfully giv... by disabled on Monday February 21, 2022 @08:59AM (#30415930)
You are not being realistic here.

Not all cases are detected. Unfortunately, rare mutations are missed by panels used in the United States.

This person, who has no Jewish ancestry whatsoever, has a Jewish husband. They got tested for Tay-Sachs using a standard panel in the United States. Their rare mutation for Tay-Sachs got missed and their child had it. :-(

See: https://www.huffpost.com/entry/dragon-mothers-and-grieving-p...

"Rapp was shocked. During her pregnancy she had been tested twice for Tay-Sachs, and both times the test came back negative. She later learned that a standard Tay-Sachs screening covers only the nine most common mutations. Rapp, who is not Jewish, and her husband, who is, were carriers of a rare mutation. To put this in perspective, fewer than 20 children in the United States are born each year with Tay-Sachs to parents who, like Rapp, tested negative and thought they could cross that worry off their lists."

They did everything right.

As I said before, there are also other cases where parents are NOT Jewish at all, and end up having a kid with Tay-Sachs.

Not all parents have the resources to do these genetic tests, and insurance, in the generally speaking, does not cover such testing for genetic diseases such as Tay-Sachs in the United States.

Here is some information from the major Tay-Sachs organization in the United States (https://www.ntsad.org/index.php/insurance):

"Despite position statements from the American College of Obstetricians and Gynecologists (ACOG) stating it is a basic standard of care to screen persons of French-Canadian, Louisiana-Cajun and Ashkenazi Jewish descent for Tay-Sachs, some may have issues with getting coverage for carrier screening. NTSAD can help you appeal for coverage and at the same time educate the healthcare industry about the importance of genetic testing prior to conception.

If you are having problems with insurance covering your carrier test, please contact the office at (617) 277-4463 or [email protected] for assistance with the appeal. We will need your name, address and plan number. The office will provide a letter of support to your insurance company as well as educational materials to present to their medical review team.

It is important to note that while the appeal process and potential out-of-pocket cost of genetic testing may seem daunting, it is a drop in the bucket compared to caring for a child affected by Tay-Sachs, Canavan or another allied disease."

Re:First gene therapy for Tay-Sachs disease successfully giv... by s1artibartfast on Monday February 21, 2022 @11:38AM (#30417712)
>You are not being realistic here.

I'm not sure what you are objecting to here and your parent post.

Are you opposed to genetic testing or counseling? Are you opposed to developing better tests?

Re:First gene therapy for Tay-Sachs disease successfully giv... by bradleyjg on Sunday February 20, 2022 @08:23PM (#30410949)
Non-Jewish French Canadians living near the St. Lawrence River and in the Cajun community of Louisiana also have a higher incidence of Tay-Sachs.

Traced back to a single particularly fecund Jewish ancestor I believe.

Re:First gene therapy for Tay-Sachs disease successfully giv... by zionic on Sunday February 20, 2022 @10:13PM (#30411566)
Um I’m sorry but what the fuck is this comment?

The OP’s point was clearly (to me) that genetic diseases like this should be eliminated at the embryo stage.

What does you going all “Jews” have to do with anything?

Re:First gene therapy for Tay-Sachs disease successfully giv... by pyuser583 on Monday February 21, 2022 @12:14AM (#30412192)
> The OP’s point was clearly (to me) that genetic diseases like this should be eliminated at the embryo stage.

That’s not clear. In the past Tay-Sachs was prevented mostly by pre-marriage genetic counseling.

Re:First gene therapy for Tay-Sachs disease successfully giv... by nootropicat on Sunday February 20, 2022 @10:40PM (#30411724)
You're right, but socially and organizationally it's more practical to fix the problem via gene therapy rather than institute compulsory abortions after a genetic test. Unfortunately due to the barbarity of Nazi Germany even rational eugenics programs are taboo in the West, and trying to fight that is a losing battle.
Re:First gene therapy for Tay-Sachs disease successfully giv... by dekhn on Monday February 21, 2022 @09:22PM (#30423368)
Um, US has its own sad history of eugenics (predating Nazi germany) that was unfortunately tied very closely to the mainstream scientific establishment. https://www.cshl.edu/archives/institutional-collections/euge... This included advocating for "sterilization of defectives".

And of course we mustn't forget the reaction to He Jiankui, who claims to have created the first permanently modified humans, and the response in China was to jail him and fine him. It's not just the West.

Gene therapy done in a medical setting where society has had a chance to understand what's going on isn't really eugenics, or is a form that isn't "bad". It's different from "sterilize the defectives" and "X people are Yer then Z people", especially because the people doing this have consulted extensively with bioethical experts and have also subjected their plans to scrutiny by the larger society.

Re:First gene therapy for Tay-Sachs disease successfully giv... by tasha0663 on Sunday February 20, 2022 @10:56PM (#30411814)
> Unfortunately... rational eugenics programs are taboo in the West

Fortunate! That's very fortunate!

> rational eugenics

No such thing unless your basis for it is incomplete or corrupted.

Re:First gene therapy for Tay-Sachs disease successfully giv... by BuyMyBitcoins on Monday February 21, 2022 @12:53AM (#30412383)
Voluntary screening of prospective parents for genetic disorders doesn’t seem malicious to me. Especially if they already know they are at high risk. If my partner and I realized we would have a child with an inherited burden, we’d probably adopt instead.

You could say this counts as Eugenics, but maybe people just need a different word since Eugenics is so tainted.

Re:First gene therapy for Tay-Sachs disease successfully giv... by tsol on Monday February 21, 2022 @08:40PM (#30423108)
Then you get into more difficult discussions. Like what constitutes a "inherited burden? Down syndrome? Is it okay to develop policies where few to no people with down syndrome will exist? How about autism? Can we get rid of people who might be liable to get depression, or just be really short? There is so much to screening for genetics, and not simply because the word eugenics is tainted.
Re:First gene therapy for Tay-Sachs disease successfully giv... by dekhn on Monday February 21, 2022 @09:24PM (#30423381)
I'd leave these questions to the biomedical community, as they have the ability to deal with nuanced questions like this. Given the amount of different behavior covered by autism, it doesn't seem useful to use that as an example.

I think if there was a test for Down's syndrome and a gene therapy cure, that would almost certainly be deployed, and advocates for people with Down's aren't going to have a big problem with that. People learned from the autism speaks debacle.