News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Drastic DS Emulator Pulled from Google Play Store by josephcsible on Sunday February 20, 2022 @05:21PM (#30409813)
> I'm not really seeing how regulation would really fix the scenario in the OP. What regulations that are likely to pass would prevent Apple and Google from removing apps arbitrarily?

Regulate the markets by letting other stores compete, not by regulating the current monopolistic stores. Force OS developers to make it easy and practical to use alternative app stores, and able to compete fairly with the first-party ones. On iOS, you can't do so at all without jailbreaking, and on Android, there's tons of scary warnings, and there's some stuff like automatic background updates that are impossible for anything but the Play Store unless you root.

Re:Drastic DS Emulator Pulled from Google Play Store by endisneigh on Sunday February 20, 2022 @05:24PM (#30409835)
Why would regulation result in more permissiveness? From my reading most implemented regulation has resulted in more restrictiveness, and things like DRM.

If that happened I'd love it though, as the precedent would presumably allow for all stores, like game consoles, appliances, etc. to open up their operating systems to allow any arbitrary software to be installed.

Even if there were more app stores I bet it would result in all apps having to be signed by Google, in the same way anyone can purchase their own domain but are still limited in that DNS is centralized.

Re:Drastic DS Emulator Pulled from Google Play Store by twbarr on Sunday February 20, 2022 @07:28PM (#30410618)
This may be the case nowadays with the pretty severe regulatory capture we have going on, but in the 60s, the FCC decreed that any lawful device may be electronically connected to the telephone network, despite what AT&T wanted. (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Carterfone) Without it, we wouldn't have modems, fax machines, answering machines, etc. etc. etc.

Regulation can most certainly result in permissiveness.

Re:Drastic DS Emulator Pulled from Google Play Store by josephcsible on Sunday February 20, 2022 @05:30PM (#30409878)
> Even if there were more app stores I bet it would result in all apps having to be signed by Google

That's the kind of thing I'd want the regulation to ban.

Re:Drastic DS Emulator Pulled from Google Play Store by endisneigh on Sunday February 20, 2022 @05:33PM (#30409907)
I'm sure, but what I'm saying what proposals that are realistically going to pass do that? Look at the history of software regulation, it generally restricts things.
Re:Drastic DS Emulator Pulled from Google Play Store by Apocryphon on Sunday February 20, 2022 @06:49PM (#30410404)
The whole point of regulating app markets is so that monopolies aren't the only ones capable of doing regulating.
Re:Drastic DS Emulator Pulled from Google Play Store by car_analogy on Monday February 21, 2022 @07:59AM (#30415406)
I can see where the disagreement stems from. What you're attributing to regulation, is more accurately attributed to who is lobbying for that regulation. You are giving up on a useful tool, because you don't like how someone else is using it.
Re:Drastic DS Emulator Pulled from Google Play Store by smaudet on Sunday February 20, 2022 @11:52PM (#30412099)
So there is precedent, OFC it doesn't exist in a vacuum, but whem Microsoft was forced to provide browser alternatives, most people went with other browsers. Sure, some used IE or edge still, but it meant people knew it was even an option, which was arguably big.

Of course, we are currently in danger of Chrome being the monopoly, and seeing already all the awful things that brings. But this is in part directly related to the scam going on with device lockin - it's not just Android, but that plays a large part in Chrome takimg majority market share.

Demanding app stores are allowed, or better that devices can be repaired by anyone, would mean more alt OS installs, more aftermarket devices, healthier software ecosystem, more economic activity.

The Irony of these tools not being widely available, means in Western countries there is not much of a third party market, not much software support, whereas countries like China can have built up the infrastructure to manufacture novel phones almost overnight...

Re:Drastic DS Emulator Pulled from Google Play Store by bogwog on Sunday February 20, 2022 @06:26PM (#30410257)
> From my reading most implemented regulation has resulted in more restrictiveness, and things like DRM.

What reading is that?

Re:Drastic DS Emulator Pulled from Google Play Store by endisneigh on Sunday February 20, 2022 @06:59PM (#30410465)
DMCA for one
Re:Drastic DS Emulator Pulled from Google Play Store by akiselev on Sunday February 20, 2022 @07:27PM (#30410610)
The DMCA gave websites carte blanche to host user uploaded content with practically zero copyright liability as long as they responded to DMCA requests and let the third parties fight over it in court. I wouldn't call that restrictive.
Re:Drastic DS Emulator Pulled from Google Play Store by endisneigh on Sunday February 20, 2022 @07:28PM (#30410620)
That was already possible before DMCA. All it did was give power to corporations to remove content. The DMCA is restrictive by definition
Re:Drastic DS Emulator Pulled from Google Play Store by not2b on Sunday February 20, 2022 @08:22PM (#30410944)
That is incorrect. Without the DMCA, the company running a site is liable for everything on the site if it does any moderation at all, and they wouldn't just be ordered to remove content, the financial penalties would be massive. Yes, the DMCA is deeply flawed, but it was passed to solve real problems.
Re:Drastic DS Emulator Pulled from Google Play Store by endisneigh on Sunday February 20, 2022 @08:37PM (#30411022)
Even with the DMCA in practice the safe harbor provisions have proven ineffective and sites in practice are still liable for content, see YouTube v Viacom. The main benefit for DMCA is for the ISPs, mainly.

In practice DMCA simply made it easier to take down supposed infringers of copyright violations and spread the popularity of drm. In theory, yes it’s good, and it probably made companies like YouTube and Facebook more comfortable with user content. The other benefit is that because you can accept DMCA requests and assume they are correct as long as you respond promptly your liability should be limited

In any case you’re probably right but haven’t heard of any high profile lawsuits prior to DMCA regarding internet content so it’s hard to really say.

What the law says though is that DMCA criminalizing circumventing drm and other access control and related technologies, services or tools.

Re:Drastic DS Emulator Pulled from Google Play Store by rodgerd on Wednesday February 23, 2022 @05:11PM (#30447260)
> Why would regulation result in more permissiveness?

Why assume that people who have bought into devices with closed ecosystems want more permissiveness? Who does this benefit?

Most of this seems like question begging for ad-tech and similarly scummy business models.