News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Awesome Critique of Crypto/Web3 by hunterb123 on Saturday February 19, 2022 @01:56PM (#30399501)
Yeah, no thank you, I don't come to Hacker News for crypto talk, the bias is comical and the talking points are recycled as a new article every week (scams!, speculation!, hype!, wasted electricity!, tether!)

All of those have rebuttals, but I don't want to get into the politics of it, there's plenty of that already. Can we please talk about the fucking tech here? I'm talking about what's made with it, not some sort of philosophical debate about how authoritarian we should be to protect people we deem gullible, or who can spend electricity on what, or who is allowed to speculate.

For those who actually are interested in the tech and not some faux moral crusade, here's better "awesome" lists, that are actually awesome, not toxic.

https://github.com/OffcierCia/DeFi-Developer-Road-Map

https://github.com/bkrem/awesome-solidity

https://github.com/btomashvili/awesome-ethereum

https://github.com/bkrem/awesome-solidity

https://github.com/vinsgo/awesome-ethereum

https://github.com/toadkicker/awesome-ethereum

https://github.com/void4/awesome-ethereum

https://github.com/JoinColony/awesome-web3

Re:Awesome Critique of Crypto/Web3 by sagarm on Saturday February 19, 2022 @04:04PM (#30400516)
I am genuinely curious on useful applications for a decentralized ledger, so I skimmed this linkdump.

> https://github.com/OffcierCia/DeFi-Developer-Road-Map

Background and development information, no applications. This link, by itself, has a massive number of links.

> https://github.com/bkrem/awesome-solidity

This links is later duplicated, but is also mostly background and developer information. There is one section titled "deployed on Ethereum mainnet" which seems to be mostly dev tools again

- rarity, an MMO (example UI: https://raritymmo.com/). That's kind of cool, if unlikely to be monetizable.

- ronin, a sidechain implementation to support another game called "Axie Infinity".

> https://github.com/bekatom/awesome-ethereum

Another giant linkfarm. Has a "DAPPS" section. Again mostly dev tools or tools for interacting with Ethereum itself, but a few things that look like applications:

- a decentralized crowdfunding platform: err, doesn't the money eventually go to a particular endpoint? What's the point of decentralizing this.

- zeronet decentralized websites: bitcoin doesn't provide compute infrastructure or a high-bandwidth distribution mechanism (bittorrent is used for this), so...what does this actually _do_? auth can be handled by TLS.

- augur: platform for prediction markets. interesting idea, but ... ultimately the actual result has to be certified?

I'm out of time but in general I haven't seen a simple example of what problems a decentralized ledger solves, ignoring all the technical issues like energy use and 51% attacks.

Re:Awesome Critique of Crypto/Web3 by hunterb123 on Saturday February 19, 2022 @05:12PM (#30401016)
> That's kind of cool, if unlikely to be monetizable.

That's not a bad thing, but it isn't true anyway, you literally login with your wallet.

Virtual currencies are banned on Stripe, PayPal etc. MMOs are how I got into crypto in the first place.

> I am genuinely curious on useful applications.

I was sharing "awesome" lists related to "web3", not a list of apps to support some argument you want to have about "energy use" or "51% attacks". Since this is a forum that has developers on it, a list of resources and roadmap for developers interested in getting started in web3 is useful, is it not? And yes, awesome lists are "link dumps", nice connotation twist.

Here's more geared towards your "genuine curiosity" of web3 apps:

https://github.com/gdamdam/awesome-decentralized-web

https://github.com/redecentralize/alternative-internet

https://github.com/jasonwalsh/awesome-dapps

Re:Awesome Critique of Crypto/Web3 by 9dev on Saturday February 19, 2022 @07:27PM (#30401936)
No, sorry, GP has a point. I think we have all seen lots of developer tools and concepts by now, but I’m also still waiting for actual applications we actually need ledgers for. Even in the additional three links you’ve posted, there’s nothing that isn’t a developer tool or demo and wouldn’t work with traditional technology.

Im genuinely curious, do you have any examples that do exist now, are remotely useful, and wouldn’t work without web3 tech?

Re:Awesome Critique of Crypto/Web3 by hunterb123 on Saturday February 19, 2022 @07:36PM (#30401997)
I already linked apps directly above. The links above that were mainly dev tools.

If you're genuinely curious, explore the lists.

What you want is for me to list a small amount of apps so you can shit on them and we can have a subjective argument about whether they are useful, which can't be determined as it's an opinion.

Web3 doesn't do things Web2 can't, it does the same things differently that gives users more power over operators.

Re:Awesome Critique of Crypto/Web3 by sagarm on Sunday February 20, 2022 @10:44PM (#30411742)
> That's not a bad thing, but it isn't true anyway, you literally login with your wallet.

> Here's more geared towards your "genuine curiosity" of web3 apps

I get that you weren't addressing my particular interest in your original post. I've put in a decent amount of time digging through the links you've shared; I'd appreciate if you accepted my curiosity in good faith.

Thanks for sharing more links, though they are not terribly digestible. The first link in particular seems to have many decentralized applications that don't use a blockchain (see below).

> https://github.com/gdamdam/awesome-decentralized-web

These are all cool decentralized web applications (many with real value, including bittorrent, mastodon, etc) -- but how many are built on a decentralized ledger / blockchain? Eight include "blockchain" in their description, and only three I would consider "apps":

- BigchainDB [dev tool] - a 'database'

- storj [dev tool] - blockchain-based object storage

- dtube [application]- decentralized video platform built on a blockchain ("STEEM")

- opentimestamps [dev tool?] - blockhain timestamping (not sure what this is for?)

- namecoin [application] - dns on blockchain

- steemit [application] - blogging/social networking on top of a blockchain db

- arcblock [dev tool] - tool for building "dapps, blockchains and websites"

I'm specifically curious about useful applications for decentralized ledgers, if that wasn't clear. The web/internet already runs on many decentralized protocols.

## STEEM

Both dtube and steemit are built on "STEEM", which seems to function as a form of social credit. Basically, whuffie (for the Doctorow fans out there). That's kinda cool[1].

IIUC:

- new users get 15 STEEM (where does this come from? is this not a spam vector?)

- posting costs STEEM

- upvoting content yields STEEM for the producer (content creation)

- early upvoters earn STEEM (curation)

The crypto part is mostly managing relationships and influence, not attempting to decentralize the actual shuffling of bits. Reasonable. Influence being portable across social networks is a cool idea too.

But how does the _business_ of this work, and is it an improvement over centralized social networks? Steemit, Inc, funds itself via the STEEM digital currency. The STEEM digital currency can be bought -- i.e., influence on the networks can be bought. Is this better than buying likes/comments/subscribers? Abstractly, it might keep the actual social signals cleaner -- except that IIUC you have to like/comment/etc to actually have your STEEM influence people! It's not clear to me that having the network funded by selling influence is an improvement. In ahttps://www.coindesk.com/markets/2020/05/20/steem-hard-fork-..., off-platform deals to leverage other people's influence will still be a reality.

So what are the benefits? Theoretically influence becomes decentralized, though the role that Steemit Inc plays is unclear to me. How are new participants funded? Who actually runs and pays for the social network infrastructure? And of course there are the usual risks like 51% attacks.

In practice: according to reddit.com/r/steemit, Steem has been forked because Steemit was acquired and the community didn't trust the new owners who had a majority share (STEEM used proof-of-stake, not proof-of-work). This was because of some drama involving "witnesses", presumably having to do with implementing the actual STEEM rewards/rate limiting. This happened in Apr 2020. The sticked post on r/steemit is from only six months ago (Aug 2021) for some reason. This explains why steemit.com seemed dead. https://hive.blog is apparently where all the action is now. Tthere are other UIs (or could be), so this is not centralized (does this mean the actual content is on the chain? Seems expensive and unscalable).

Detangling just this one "dapp" took >30 minutes. All the crypto stuff aside, hive.blog looks basically like a multireddit made of small subreddits (DTube shows up as the equivalent of a subreddit[2], btw).

## Namecoin

Once you have decentralized DNS the others can already rely on other decentralized parts of the internet (IP, etc).

DNS is not really centralized IMO, which the existence of Namecoin itself attests to. You can choose your nameservers; arbitrary levels of subdomains are supported; etc. If you are capable of opting into Namecoin, why not another root DNS?

Practically Namecoin acts like another root of trust. How well does it perform this function?

https://www.namecoin.org/docs/faq/#is-squatting-a-problem--w... https://www.namecoin.org/docs/faq/#what-is-the-threat-posed-...

Maybe there's a way to better execute this idea; however Namecoin seems to be dominant implementation.

[1] "Down and Out in the Magic Kingdom" was written in the early 00s, so "cyber" is almost appropriate. [2] https://hive.blog/trending/hive-196037

Re:Awesome Critique of Crypto/Web3 by lawtalkinghuman on Sunday February 20, 2022 @06:25AM (#30404916)
I took a look at "awesome-dapps" to see if there were indeed any awesome dapps that I could try.

OpenBazaar - Closed Jan 4, 2021. https://twitter.com/openbazaar/status/1346104369566121986

SafeMarket - the getting started link says it's alpha, tells you to go to the subreddit, which is closed. The GitHub repo last had a commit in 2016.

Livepeer - a video streaming service that has no actual evidence on the website of anyone actually using it to stream any content. All the videos they have up on the Livepeer website about Livepeer... are hosted on YouTube. All the discussion I see of it on Twitter and their subreddit is about which exchanges the coin is listed on and the likelihood of it going to the moon etc. The actual utility in transcoding seems secondary to the speculative value of the token.

CryptoPunks - I hope the person who paid $23 million is happy with their purchase.

Thousand Ether Homepage - old school web nostalgia. Okay that's nice I guess.

"An open source sample iOS dApp that demonstrates a practical use-case in biomedical research: sharing location data by interacting with a smart contract deployed on the Oasis Devnet." Trusting a smart contract with your location data sure sounds like one of those ideas that'll end perfectly. Again, not an actual app, just some demoware.

Everything else on the awesome-dapps list are educational resources—books, tutorials, blog posts—not actual examples of functioning dapps.

If these are the awesome dapps, one dare not ask what the bad ones are like.

Re:Awesome Critique of Crypto/Web3 by hunterb123 on Sunday February 20, 2022 @03:04PM (#30408835)
Wow, you have some really selective reading if those are the only apps you saw.

awesome-dapps is the smallest list, check out the ones below since you seemed to miss them:

https://github.com/gdamdam/awesome-decentralized-web

https://github.com/redecentralize/alternative-internet

Re:Awesome Critique of Crypto/Web3 by ewired on Saturday February 19, 2022 @02:46PM (#30399889)
I wish I could be this positive and resourceful on this topic. It just gives me the urge to write a passive-aggressive tirade against the unfounded (almost manufactured) hate against this powerful technology. Nobody is putting it back in the box, no matter how many years they spend whining on their ironically named "dunning-kruger" blogs. Dammit, there I go again. I could go on for 12 more paragraphs but I'll cut it short here.
Re:Awesome Critique of Crypto/Web3 by user-the-name on Sunday February 20, 2022 @04:38AM (#30404476)
None of it is unfounded or manufactured. If you think it is, you are blinding yourself to some pretty obvious truth that you do not want to believe in.
Re:Awesome Critique of Crypto/Web3 by user-the-name on Saturday February 19, 2022 @05:11PM (#30401009)
> the bias is comical and the talking points are recycled as a new article every week (scams!, speculation!, hype!, wasted electricity!, tether!)

There is a very strong bias towards the truth, yes.

Re:Awesome Critique of Crypto/Web3 by hunterb123 on Saturday February 19, 2022 @05:40PM (#30401212)
That's the equivalent of "yes-huh". Your truth is not reality.

If you really want to argue this, please at least have something of substance.

Re:Awesome Critique of Crypto/Web3 by user-the-name on Sunday February 20, 2022 @04:43AM (#30404501)
Unfortunately, my truth is reality. It is not really my problem that you have yet to realise this.
Re:Awesome Critique of Crypto/Web3 by hunterb123 on Sunday February 20, 2022 @04:47AM (#30404523)
Okay, when you have a reality you can put into words please feel free bring it to the table.
Re:Awesome Critique of Crypto/Web3 by user-the-name on Sunday February 20, 2022 @04:51AM (#30404536)
Why? People are doing it all the time, and you are rejecting them outright. Why should I bother to do the same when the last hundred times, you would not listen?
Re:Awesome Critique of Crypto/Web3 by hunterb123 on Sunday February 20, 2022 @05:14AM (#30404642)
Simply asking you to pick your favorite critique and defend it. Unless you're just parroting others and you don't have a view?

I cannot prove a negative, or in this case an undefined, you need to present an issue to debate.

Re:Awesome Critique of Crypto/Web3 by user-the-name on Sunday February 20, 2022 @12:47PM (#30407502)
I have plenty of views. But you declared right from the start that you have chosen to blind yourself from the truth, and I know exactly how pointless it is to try to argue with someone in that position, so I simply will not.
Re:Awesome Critique of Crypto/Web3 by hunterb123 on Sunday February 20, 2022 @03:00PM (#30408802)
Yeah I guess that's why I'm asking you for one of your plenty views, I'm choosing to blind myself, lol.

Clearly you don't want to share it so I guess we're done here.