News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Awesome Critique of Crypto/Web3 by tromp on Saturday February 19, 2022 @01:23PM (#30399214)
Even as a cryptocurrency developer myself, I concur with most of the criticism. I detest all the cash grabbing, speculation, hype, and scams. Where I diverge from most criticism is in PoW. In its early years, when Bitcoin was used as currency rather than for speculation, mining only consumed moderate amounts of energy, in line with the lower prices of a few dozen dollar per bitcoin at most. My hope is for Tether to crash, leading to a downward price spiral for Bitcoin, an end to rampant speculation, and a huge scaling down of mining. There should be no expectation of financial gain in cryptocurrency. It should just serve its original purpose of making convenient limited value purchases online. I don't support PoS as it leads to huge wealth concentration with the founders owning 100% of all initial coins.
Re:Awesome Critique of Crypto/Web3 by yulaow on Saturday February 19, 2022 @01:42PM (#30399371)
PoW already brought us to huge wealth concentration so it is not the solution either. This is one of the hard-not-so-talked problems of cryptos at the moment, and I can't see how to solve it.
Re:Awesome Critique of Crypto/Web3 by tromp on Saturday February 19, 2022 @02:17PM (#30399664)
PoW tries to minimizes wealth concentration by imposing a competitive cost on obtaining coins. Of course it cannot reduce the wealth concentration already present in fiat. It can at best not make it much worse (as PoS does). PoW still suffers from wealth concentration due to varying block subsidies over time, which is why I'm a strong supporter of uncapped emissions like 1 coin per second forever, which gives no advantage to early miners.
Re:Awesome Critique of Crypto/Web3 by lottin on Saturday February 19, 2022 @03:16PM (#30400125)
How does PoW minimise wealth concentration? Minimising wealth concentration would imply distributing the coins evenly among the network participants. That's not what PoW does.
Re:Awesome Critique of Crypto/Web3 by garren on Sunday February 20, 2022 @02:07AM (#30403850)
Doesn’t “minimiz[ing] wealth concentration by imposing a competitive cost on obtaining coins”, basically translate to “only the wealthy can afford the compute resources needed to mine”? So, not really minimizing wealth concentration as practically gauranteeing that only those with a tremendous amount of resources to waste on PoW will see any return? In fact, the first link in the post [0] touches on this point very well in the first 30 min or so.

[0] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YQ_xWvX1n9g

Re:Awesome Critique of Crypto/Web3 by tenuousemphasis on Saturday February 19, 2022 @04:51PM (#30400871)
The problem is capitalism, but at least with Bitcoin there is no central authority to unilaterally alter monetary policy to benefit one specific group (those closest to supply of new money i.e. Gresham's Law).
Re:Awesome Critique of Crypto/Web3 by yifanl on Saturday February 19, 2022 @10:11PM (#30402882)
Isn't there? If there are incentives in place that grant some group of people disproportionate power over others (early miners having essentially irrational amounts of coin to work with, or large pool operators owning a substantial amount of the hash rate), then it will trend towards centralization, because they end up being the main stakeholders.

Bitcoin has _mostly_ avoided it, but not fully, as evidenced by the coins claiming to be the One True Bitcoin, forks driven largely by a small group of people who want to force some policy onto the blockchain, and not entirely unsuccessfully.

Re:Awesome Critique of Crypto/Web3 by tenuousemphasis on Tuesday February 22, 2022 @04:53AM (#30425937)
>Isn't there?

There isn't.

Early miners have long since sold off their coins. Pool operators don't own any hashrate. Yes there is some fuckery they can engage in, but it would be obvious and miners can trivially switch pools.

Forks are evidence that there is no central authority in Bitcoin! They cannot change the rules for others so they go do their own thing. How can you not see this as an incredible feature?

Re:Awesome Critique of Crypto/Web3 by newacc9 on Saturday February 19, 2022 @08:55PM (#30402499)
cantillion effect rather
Re:Awesome Critique of Crypto/Web3 by tenuousemphasis on Tuesday February 22, 2022 @04:50AM (#30425912)
Yes, that was a dumb mistake on my part
Re:Awesome Critique of Crypto/Web3 by user-the-name on Saturday February 19, 2022 @01:52PM (#30399461)
There is no safe way to wind down mining. As mining becomes unprofitable, mining equipment will be shut down. But it will still exist, and it will be in the hands of people desperate for cash.

This means that the price of 51% attack will drop massively, and that completely undermines the safety that PoW provides.

A large drop in price followed by a large drop in mining completely destroys the security of bitcoin.

Re:Awesome Critique of Crypto/Web3 by tromp on Saturday February 19, 2022 @02:11PM (#30399616)
The price of a 51% relative to the total marketcap won't change drastically (only moderately due to wider availability of hardware), and that's what security is based on, not the absolute cost of a 51% attack.
Re:Awesome Critique of Crypto/Web3 by lottin on Saturday February 19, 2022 @03:19PM (#30400146)
No... security depends on the cost mounting an attack, and that's the absolute cost.
Re:Awesome Critique of Crypto/Web3 by tromp on Saturday February 19, 2022 @05:41PM (#30401220)
No... a chain that costs $1M to attack with a mktcap of $100K is more secure than a chain that costs $10M to attack with a mktcap of $100B, as the latter has huge financial incentives for doublespending (after depositing say $100M at an exchange), while the former has none.

It's like how much you spend on a bike lock. A $100 lock on a $20 bike is probably quote secure, while a $200 lock on a $5000 bike is probably quite insecure.

Re:Awesome Critique of Crypto/Web3 by lottin on Saturday February 19, 2022 @05:57PM (#30401325)
No... an attacker that is able to successfully execute a 51% attack can crash the token price and make enormous profits in the derivatives market, so the market cap is irrelevant. Moreover, and attacker may have motivations other than financial gains, which again makes market cap irrelevant. If your security model only protects against financially motivated attackers it means it's basically rubbish.
Re:Awesome Critique of Crypto/Web3 by user-the-name on Sunday February 20, 2022 @12:53PM (#30407563)
The "total market cap" is a completely fictional number that represents nothing real whatsoever. It makes no sense to compare anything to this number.
Re:Awesome Critique of Crypto/Web3 by vl on Saturday February 19, 2022 @01:30PM (#30399272)
With settlement time of 60 minutes Bitcoin was never designed as true currency, but more as a holdable asset.

While some of the critiques are valid, as system matures, there will be less and less of it. Crypto is here to stay.

Re:Awesome Critique of Crypto/Web3 by user-the-name on Saturday February 19, 2022 @01:54PM (#30399472)
The first line of the Bitcoin white paper:

> A purely peer-to-peer version of electronic cash would allow online payments to be sent directly from one party to another without going through a financial institution.

Now, if you want to say that it was badly designed for its purpose, that is a different matter.

Re:Awesome Critique of Crypto/Web3 by vl on Saturday February 19, 2022 @02:53PM (#30399941)
"would allow online payments to be sent directly from one party to another without going through a financial institution"

And it successfully achieved this specific goal, however it never claimed it is a good solution for micro/small payments, which is a requirement for "normal currency". Payments of small amounts require small fees and quick settlement time, neither of which Bitcoin has by design.

Re:Awesome Critique of Crypto/Web3 by deanCommie on Saturday February 19, 2022 @04:38PM (#30400777)
Well this is where, as any good developer, you have to look at the requirement and ask "why?"

> ... without going through a financial institution.

Why? Why don't we want to go through a financial institution?

Well, honestly, the only REAL reasons are fees on large transactions, and the desire/preference to be able to conduct activities that are illegal by regulated financial institutions.

And that, if we all remember, was the only usecase for bitcoin before speculation - buying drugs and even more illegal things on TOR marketplaces.

Well, that and money laundering.

Re:Awesome Critique of Crypto/Web3 by can16358p on Saturday February 19, 2022 @05:16PM (#30401049)
I live in a corrupted country with a corrupted government and don't trust my government a single bit.

I'd happily use and adopt crypto. I don't do anything illegal, I just don't want corrupted and evil people having control over my assets.

Re:Awesome Critique of Crypto/Web3 by deanCommie on Monday February 21, 2022 @07:04PM (#30422434)
> I just don't want corrupted and evil people having control over my assets.

Have I got some news for you about the 51% of people who control all the most popular blockchains :(

Re:Awesome Critique of Crypto/Web3 by user-the-name on Saturday February 19, 2022 @05:16PM (#30401045)
Here are the words of Satoshi himself:

> Once it gets bootstrapped, there are so many applications if you could effortlessly pay a few cents to a website as easily as dropping coins in a vending machine.

This claim that Bitcoin was never meant to be a payment system for small payments is 100% historical revisionism.

Re:Awesome Critique of Crypto/Web3 by aaaaaaaaata on Saturday February 19, 2022 @02:14PM (#30399643)
It will allow it — just not fast, and if you want that, it still allows it, via Layer 2 solutions,

many of which guarantee the same security as their Layer 1.

Re:Awesome Critique of Crypto/Web3 by user-the-name on Saturday February 19, 2022 @05:17PM (#30401055)
There is no known functional and scalable layer 2 solution. Lightning, as designed, can not scale.