Using only a fraction of your assigned IP address space is good and normal.
What is bad is ipv4 doesn't have enough space for everyone. Time to move onto ipv6. I don't know how to make that happen.
Over at a University we run, we like to run like a ISP and only have a /16 to work with, its very tight even now, we have thousands of students using the Wifi, Dorm Networks and such. I do wish we had more.
Shouldn't many of those be on NATs?
No, ISPs shouldn't force users behind NATs.
During a shortage, push comes to shove.
> "shouldn't"s are not very useful during shortages.
There is an important difference between "it might be necessary to put them behind NATs" and "shouldn't they be on NATs?".
Hence the word "many." It's interesting because econ deniers are common at university, haha.
In any case, /16 should be enough room to prioritize.
Incorrect. ISPs should use NAT. Users should pay for their own address if they desire.
I'd rather the ISP pushed for IPv6.
Re:Who is squatting IPv4 addresses?
by birdman914 on Thursday February 17, 2022 @02:48PM
(#30377753)
We are at least at the ISP I work for. That is a major project for us this year, but any network engineer can tell you that deploying IPv6 is not straight forward at the ISP level. Getting everyone together on how to have some standard form of addressing from different entities is the toughest lift. Get Juniper, Cisco, and Arista on the phone and you will get three different ways on how to deploy it. You don't want to be the odd duck once the dust settles.
Re:Who is squatting IPv4 addresses?
by Karrot_Kream on Thursday February 17, 2022 @03:54PM
(#30378514)
Interesting. What are the big differences if you're allowed to talk about it? I have no doubt that the IPv6 rollout is difficult, I helped move some simply cloud stuff to IPv6 and even that had a few issues. I'm much happier without the heavy layers of NAT though.
Re:Who is squatting IPv4 addresses?
by AviationAtom on Friday February 18, 2022 @07:46AM
(#30385055)
T-Mobile is actually one of the largest users of IPv6
dorms and wifi should definitely be NAT. you can always give a public address if someone specifically requests it.
Re:Who is squatting IPv4 addresses?
by erik_seaberg on Thursday February 17, 2022 @05:14PM
(#30379396)
Do dorms have IPv6? If students can’t run servers, where does the next generation of developers come from?
I tried running a Pi in my college dorm. First, it was NAT, and when I requested a public IP, IT said they didn't give IPs to students. :/
IPv6 would be cool.
Back the 90's, all the dorms gave students static IPs. The Internet was unfiltered, no firewalls. It was a different time.
I worked for a couple of small and mid-sized companies that had /16's and larger. And we barely used a fraction of that space.
I have a /24, personally, registered back in 1993. It's routed to my home network. I know several other folks who were on the early internet, and had the same.