News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Cryptocurrencies – An Assessment by Reserve Bank of India by eric_cc on Wednesday February 16, 2022 @09:22AM (#30360286)
> the only point of it is to buy it low, and sell high, for USD

Until the point that nobody wants to be the USD bag holder.

Plenty of boomers still don’t think of saving USD as a terrible idea because they were trained their whole life to have faith in it. They are being robbed in plain sight, sadly. But younger generations won’t put up with it.

Re:Cryptocurrencies – An Assessment by Reserve Bank of India by AlexandrB on Wednesday February 16, 2022 @09:44AM (#30360567)
I think this comment completely misunderstands what most people's savings are. 401Ks and the like are usually invested in a bunch of equities, bonds, and mutual funds. The value of these is commonly denominated in USD (if you live in the US), but they are not USD!

Most people already don't "save" USD. They save equities and then trade them back into USD when it's time to retire. I don't see how BTC changes this other than adding another equity to the list of stuff you can invest in.

Re:Cryptocurrencies – An Assessment by Reserve Bank of India by eric_cc on Wednesday February 16, 2022 @10:22AM (#30361092)
Let’s assume BTC replaces fiat (USD). One way that it changes what you’ve described is that you wouldn’t be forced to gamble on equities or other assets to stay afloat. You’d have the option to simply hang on to your currency until another asset class enticed you enough to invest. It affords you some time to simply do nothing. Currently, you can’t afford to sit and wait and research assets. You need to stay out of fiat to stay afloat, constantly restructure your portfolio, etc. if you don’t do these things, you bleed buying power over time.

With sound money, people could work and save without needing to constantly gamble just to maintain buying power.

Re:Cryptocurrencies – An Assessment by Reserve Bank of India by __MatrixMan__ on Wednesday February 16, 2022 @07:54PM (#30368188)
Do you think that soundness is enough to convince the people being born now to pursue BTC when they're older?

They'll see it as this thing that the old people are all hoarding, and they'll have none of it... Why sign on for an uphill battle for BTC over any other token?

Seems to me that crypto projects should have tangible side effects, so that future generations can value them (or not) based on whether they want to see more of those effects. Compared to that, a fat BTC wallet in cold storage looks like somebody who sucked value out of their community rather than reinvesting it to make positive changes. Why reward such a person by valuing their tokens?

Re:Cryptocurrencies – An Assessment by Reserve Bank of India by guelo on Wednesday February 16, 2022 @12:58PM (#30363271)
If Bitcoin were to always increase in value (deflationary) there is a strong disincentive to ever buy anything with it. This makes it useless as a currency which means it can't replace USD. Why buy something now when you can buy it for less in the future? You could buy the famous pizza for a tiny fraction of a Bitcoin today
Re:Cryptocurrencies – An Assessment by Reserve Bank of India by eric_cc on Wednesday February 16, 2022 @03:43PM (#30365423)
As long as we have fiat, bitcoin WILL always increase in value. Because bitcoin supply is capped and fiat will continue to lose buying power year after year. At this stage, there is no incentive to hold fiat and huge incentive to hold as much bitcoin as possible.

If bitcoin replaces fiat, bitcoin becomes the main representation of value. It no longer goes up against a trading pair of fiat. I speculate that its buying power would stabilize and become fairly static.

Re:Cryptocurrencies – An Assessment by Reserve Bank of India by johnrgrace on Wednesday February 16, 2022 @01:59PM (#30364159)
I don't think you've thought this through, if holding bitcoin accelerates in value more than say companies actually doing things then we're going to transfer a substantial portion of today's current wealth to the people who currently own bitcoin.
Re:Cryptocurrencies – An Assessment by Reserve Bank of India by eric_cc on Wednesday February 16, 2022 @03:40PM (#30365384)
I opened with:

> Let’s assume BTC replaces fiat (USD)

If BTC replaces fiat, I don't believe it would increase in buying power at a rapid rate. I think it would gradually increase in buying power over time only because the total supply will gradually shrink due to lost coins / dust /etc.

Re:Cryptocurrencies – An Assessment by Reserve Bank of India by guelo on Wednesday February 16, 2022 @03:51PM (#30365508)
Imagine what would happen in this imaginary world when GDP increases. More things are being produced which means there are more things that need to be sold. But there is a fixed number of coins to buy things with. Each coin has to be able to buy more things.
Re:Cryptocurrencies – An Assessment by Reserve Bank of India by dale_glass on Wednesday February 16, 2022 @09:43AM (#30360552)
BTC is completely unsuitable to be used as a currency, since it's deflationary. Would you buy a car if waiting meant you could have it at half price? Of course not, that'd be stupid. So you'll sit on your hoard, while the economy implodes.
Re:Cryptocurrencies – An Assessment by Reserve Bank of India by harambae on Wednesday February 16, 2022 @11:40AM (#30362186)
>Would you buy a car if waiting meant you could have it at half price?

Apparently yes, a bunch of people are buying cars now at temporarily inflated prices when prices are expected to tank

https://autos.yahoo.com/analysts-warn-possible-used-car-1510...

Re:Cryptocurrencies – An Assessment by Reserve Bank of India by knocte on Thursday February 17, 2022 @02:20AM (#30370399)
>Would you buy a car if waiting meant you could have it at half price?

That's exactly what happens with computers and, last I heard, computers are still being purchased.

Re:Cryptocurrencies – An Assessment by Reserve Bank of India by eric_cc on Wednesday February 16, 2022 @10:23AM (#30361116)
How sad would it be if Americans consumed less? Mindless consumption is the whole point of living!
Re:Cryptocurrencies – An Assessment by Reserve Bank of India by dwg465 on Wednesday February 16, 2022 @06:43PM (#30367454)
It's not deflationary though.
Re:Cryptocurrencies – An Assessment by Reserve Bank of India by dale_glass on Thursday February 17, 2022 @06:07AM (#30371830)
It is, by design.

If you mean to say it's not deflationary because there's a limited amount of it that doesn't technically decrease, that doesn't help.

First, Bitcoin does lose coins over time. When wallet keys are lost, or "dust" happens, that means that money can't ever be spent again. This is independent of the USD value.

Second, the economy can grow. Eg, if the population grows, or a factory starts producing more goods, then there's now more stuff per unit of currency. That's still deflation.

Re:Cryptocurrencies – An Assessment by Reserve Bank of India by smaryjerry on Wednesday February 16, 2022 @11:54PM (#30369637)
However, if everything else is inflationary then simply not inflating would be deflationary on a relative scale. It is a near zero chance that countries don’t keep inflation strong.
Re:Cryptocurrencies – An Assessment by Reserve Bank of India by user_7832 on Wednesday February 16, 2022 @09:43AM (#30360558)
> Until the point that nobody wants to be the USD bag holder. Plenty of boomers still don’t think of saving USD as a terrible idea because they were trained their whole life to have faith in it. They are being robbed in plain sight, sadly. But younger generations won’t put up with it.

I'm not sure whether you're opposed to the USD compared to other currencies, or cash in general opposed to stocks/bonds etc. For the former point, the US military's strength* ensures that the dollar is likely to stay the strongest of currencies even in a medium-term environment (say 50-100 years in my estimate), with only the Euro coming close.

For the latter, I don't think that was what the earlier posters were talking about.

* I'm not saying spending so much on the military is necessarily a good idea, neither am I a US citizen

Re:Cryptocurrencies – An Assessment by Reserve Bank of India by Traster on Wednesday February 16, 2022 @04:55PM (#30366310)
The obvious point is that anyone who wants to pay their taxes is going to be a "USD bagholder". Boomers generally don't save in USD. They save in USD denominated assets (like bitcoin). Interest rates being lower than inflation does rebalance the economy from wealth to income, but I actually think that's something we should encourage right now.