No, it isn't "by definition racist"
/ˈrāˌsizəm/
noun
prejudice, discrimination, or antagonism directed against a person or people on the basis of their membership in a particular racial or ethnic group, typically one that is a minority or marginalized.
Dictionaries are political speech. Spanish ones under Franco didn't have the words "huelga" or "sindicato" which mean "strike" or "union."
Except when it’s not. Why not just say “I want to fill this seat with someone who has had experiences in line with many poor black individuals.”
You cannot solve discrimination with discrimination. Democrats have been trying the lazy route for 40 years with no progress. Perhaps we would have been better off trying to solve the root causes instead of uselessly chasing quick fixes?
All races of people are equal in there inherent value as individuals, but they are not equal in their experiences, situations, or needs. To deny the common experience of racial groups in order to optimize for “discrimination” is naive. Discrimination is not inherently unjust, it is a consequence of a universe which has finite resources in time, money, attention, and power.
Appointing a black woman at the conclusion of a thorough candidate evaluation is not racist. Stating outright that you will appoint a black woman before candidates have been evaluated is racist.
I feel sorry for all the asian judges of any sex, women of any other race, men of any race, Muslims of any sex, Hispanics of any sex, and anyone else not “black woman.” Apparently none of them are eligible for this prestigious appointment. Too bad for being born the way they were, I guess.
“Equality”
That should expose what the problem is. The referee should not be one of the players, on either side. "Progressive progress" is the opposite of how we should judge the Supreme Court, just as "conservative progress" would be.
And that should tell us the answer. We measure how well the Supreme Court does by how well it impartially judges based on the cases and the law, not based on any agenda.
Now, judging that is obviously hard. Everyone is inclined to think the Supreme Court is biased against their position whenever it judges in a way they don't like. And maybe that's the only way to really measure it: If both sides think it's biased against them, then it might be doing rather well.
I mean it as: making progress toward better conditions; employing or advocating more enlightened or liberal ideas, new or experimental methods, etc.:
https://www.dictionary.com/browse/progressive
So in the light that Brown vs Board of Education was progressive progress.
So he thinks racism is ok. And contrary to what he says in his linked article I don't think his choice will necessarily be unqualified but to use race as the primary metric is by definition racist. If Trump said said he would only choose a white man, that policy would aptly be decried as racist.