News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Ask HN: Recent computer hacking convictions and employabi... by notch656a on Monday February 14, 2022 @11:02AM (#30333601)
Sounds like place he was at accepted him just fine until dumb bitch ratted him out for something that happened outside of work. Dude got a good run at least. Not lying about convictions sounds great from the pious ivory tower or from seasoned professionals who may have enough experience that others are able to look beyond their past.

Dude already did his time, in my book the conviction doesn't exist anymore. My honest advice for ex-crims is to find small shops that don't run BG check (yes these places do exist) and never mention their crimes. After a 3-5 years in industry your past will be far enough behind you can get into most small businesses positions you are qualified for.

Re:Ask HN: Recent computer hacking convictions and employabi... by d4mi3n on Monday February 14, 2022 @11:13AM (#30333740)
> Not lying about convictions sounds great from the pious ivory tower or from seasoned professionals who may have enough experience that others are able to look beyond their past.

Sadly--and I do mean this, I agree with your sentiment--what we believe and what is required by an organization in a sensitive industry (finance, education, defense) are different things. For example, if you want to operate as a public company in finance with industry-standard certifications, you must perform background checks and reject candidates with a criminal history involving financial crimes.

Schools and other educational institutions likewise are require to reject candidates with a criminal record that includes charges of violent crime, sexual offenses, or similar.

Lying about charges that aren't relevant to the filtering criteria will be noticed in such industries and be a big red flag to any HR rep or hiring manager reviewing an application. This also shields you from a situation where some other employee learns and disseminates unflattering information--if one's manager and HR has cleared that info, it's nobody else's business and you have avenues and support available to you to prevent discrimination due to a criminal history.

Re:Ask HN: Recent computer hacking convictions and employabi... by syshum on Monday February 14, 2022 @12:05PM (#30334458)
>>what is required by an organization in a sensitive industry

That really is not a factor, I have worked for a number of organizations that would never higher anyone convicted of a felony who did not have any sensitive requirements, were not dealing with money, or personal info, or anything important really

There is just a huge stigma when it comes to criminal records, which is doubly painful in a over criminalized society like we have in the US.

Re:Ask HN: Recent computer hacking convictions and employabi... by notch656a on Monday February 14, 2022 @12:11PM (#30334566)
I'm a huge believer that if people can't be trusted in society, they should be in jail, executed, or banished to someplace like Namibian desert / Siberia. A free man (after prison/probation) should be free; their conviction behind them and essentially erased. A free man can easily rape/murder/steal regardless of any BG check you put in place. If you're free, you have the full rights and priveleges of a free man including bearing guns or taking care of children or being CFO of a finance firm.

Fuck any half-way system where you're released of all judicial punishment but you can't work, vote, or own a gun. THAT is cruel and unusual punishment.

Re:Ask HN: Recent computer hacking convictions and employabi... by kuhewa on Monday February 14, 2022 @02:40PM (#30337156)
Why is it important that a convicted child abuser be free to take care of children once their punishment is over? There are plenty of other fields in which they could find employment.
Re:Ask HN: Recent computer hacking convictions and employabi... by notch656a on Monday February 14, 2022 @02:54PM (#30337364)
I don't believe in having multiple classes of free citizens. If a free person wants to, they could easily abduct a child, barring them from taking care of kids is a laughable feel-good policy that insults the notion that there should be no free second class citizen.

If someone can't be trusted to not abuse children, they need to be jailed or on probation until they can be trusted. Those people can't be trusted in public. If they've abused children through rape of small children or serious violence against the weak, just execute the low life. Children are everywhere, the idea an abuser is just fine being tempted with children everywhere, from the street to playground, except they'll be nice and honest and use their real SSN and identity when applying to work with children is a hilarious notion.

And frankly, unless proven otherwise, I assume sex convictions are something like pissing by the side of the road or a 19 year old banged their 16 y/o girlfriend. The government loves to imprison people for insane reasons and sex offender registry is a poor guide as to whether someone can be trusted with children.

Re:Ask HN: Recent computer hacking convictions and employabi... by Tepix on Monday February 14, 2022 @03:07PM (#30337546)
There is a huge grey area. Statistically, people who have committed a crime are more likely to commit crimes again than those who haven't.

That makes for a good argument not to trust them as much, generally speaking.

On the other hand, integrating them back into society (something that's lacking in the US) works well for most.

Re:Ask HN: Recent computer hacking convictions and employabi... by notch656a on Monday February 14, 2022 @03:20PM (#30337708)
Which do you think is harder though, adbucting some kid into a stolen untrackable vehicle and go out into the wilderness where there's no chance in hell you'll be caught, or going to the trouble and length of becoming a childcare worker where your face and likely other details are exposed? Someone who is free can easily do the former, and with a stolen SSN and identity (this is laughably easy to get if you've ever worked in many factories you'll see tons of illegal immigrants with stolen SSN) can also easily do the latter.

The whole premise is just laughable at face.

This think of the children trope is just bait IMO to try and get us to accept that there are second class citizens, and allow us to put restrictions and loss of freedoms on people who have completed their judicial punishment. If we can accept this we might accept ending their constitutional rights such as the right to vote, bear arms, or speak freely.

I understand the desire to protect children in this manner, I just think it's misguided and philosophically inconsistent.

Re:Ask HN: Recent computer hacking convictions and employabi... by syshum on Monday February 14, 2022 @04:17PM (#30338476)
Well that depends on the crime, and a whole host of other factors including the fact that it is ciruclar logic.

We cant trust them because they re offend, but they re offend because of lack of opportunities created by society not trusting them....

It is certainly true for property crimes, drug crimes, and other such actions.

Violent crimes may be an exception to this, but then to the OP's point, if they are violent why are they out in the population to begin with?

Re:Ask HN: Recent computer hacking convictions and employabi... by thatcat on Tuesday February 15, 2022 @08:15AM (#30345965)
That's a terrible analysis. I would bet that even the innocent people convicted of a crime are more liKely to commit a crime after and this speaks more to our poorly functioning justice system than the person convicted. Besides, statistically everyone is a criminal because the number of laws are uncountable and unknowable.
Re:Ask HN: Recent computer hacking convictions and employabi... by vodoohooo on Tuesday February 15, 2022 @05:07AM (#30344647)
would you rather have a criminal who has not been caught work that job or someone who paid for what they have done and is working to improve?
Re:Ask HN: Recent computer hacking convictions and employabi... by hackerfromthefu on Wednesday February 16, 2022 @02:48AM (#30357364)
option c
Re:Ask HN: Recent computer hacking convictions and employabi... by vodoohooo on Wednesday February 16, 2022 @07:13AM (#30359015)
and how do you know option c is not option a? lol
Re:Ask HN: Recent computer hacking convictions and employabi... by hackerfromthefu on Thursday February 17, 2022 @11:04PM (#30382017)
Its not possible to be sure!

It just seemed the question was phrased in terms of those being the only options, when in fact they are the very rare options. It seems that mostly people you hire are not going to do serious criminal things, either before or after you hire them.

Re:Ask HN: Recent computer hacking convictions and employabi... by tcgv on Monday February 14, 2022 @11:12AM (#30333729)
I see your point, and I'm in favor of inclusion in the workplace, but it's not all black and white.

Would you allow a convicted sexual offender who did his time in jail take care of your child in a day care facility to which he got employed and didn't disclose his past conviction?

Things need to be put into perspective, and evaluated carefully.

With that said I don't think immediate termination was the right decision to make in that situation the parent comment described. Inclusion requires consideration and empathy, the company didn't demonstrate that.

Re:Ask HN: Recent computer hacking convictions and employabi... by btilly on Monday February 14, 2022 @01:10PM (#30335615)
Are you aware that an estimated 1/4 of all registered sex offenders were themselves minors when they committed their offense? And age 14 is the single year that you're most likely to become a registered sex offender?

I fully understand and appreciate the purpose of our laws. The practice, however, is a different story. And unless we stop including as crimes things that I'm not willing to consider crimes, I can't support the way that "registered sex offender" is routinely used to destroy lives over childhood mistakes.

Re:Ask HN: Recent computer hacking convictions and employabi... by withinboredom on Monday February 14, 2022 @02:45PM (#30337216)
Or the number of registered sex offenders for peeing on the side of the interstate.
Re:Ask HN: Recent computer hacking convictions and employabi... by tcgv on Monday February 14, 2022 @01:15PM (#30335709)
I wasn't aware of that, it's suprising and sad. Thanks for pointing that out.
Re:Ask HN: Recent computer hacking convictions and employabi... by btilly on Monday February 14, 2022 @01:23PM (#30335862)
It is not so surprising when you consider how many laws have fixed age limits. For example a 13 year old sends an intimate picture to a 14 year old friend, the 14 year old has just committed a crime by having that picture.

The law is intended to target adult pedophiles. But when the people involved are basically the same age, it isn't pedophilia!

Re:Ask HN: Recent computer hacking convictions and employabi... by notch656a on Monday February 14, 2022 @01:31PM (#30336027)
Yeah not to mention no mens rea is needed for statutory rape. That is a 17 y/o could show you a passport and DL with her age as 18, and tell you and look like she is 18, yet you would still be convicted. Hardly any other crime has this kind of strict liability where honest and thorough due diligence doesn't absolve you of the crime.
Re:Ask HN: Recent computer hacking convictions and employabi... by notch656a on Monday February 14, 2022 @11:19AM (#30333809)
I've not run a BG check on anyone who takes care of my kids. Sometimes we also hire babysitters to come take care of my child, I don't run BG check either.

I probably wouldn't like it if I found out they raped a (actual, not like statutory w/ a lying 17 y/o with fake ID like happened to Cody Wilson) child, because I believe the appropriate solution for that is the death penalty, and thus I don't see them as having completed their sentence. But if someone is out in society, I treat them based on the way I have observed them to treat myself and others, rather than what the government says. A lot of sex offenses are total BS such as someone urinated in public (which is socially acceptable in many places of the world).

Re:Ask HN: Recent computer hacking convictions and employabi... by syshum on Monday February 14, 2022 @12:07PM (#30334503)
>>>Things need to be put into perspective, and evaluated carefully.

And leading with hyperbolic "Think of the children" hand waving pearl clutching does nothing to put "things into perspective"

In the context of this thread we are talking about someone convicted of hacking wanting to work in IT again, not a child molester wanting to babysit your child.

So yes lets keep things in perspective shall we?

Re:Ask HN: Recent computer hacking convictions and employabi... by tcgv on Monday February 14, 2022 @01:10PM (#30335609)
You're right. I'm sorry if I was disrespectful with the participants in the discussion and the OP, that wasn't my intetion. It's indeed a completely different situation.
Re:Ask HN: Recent computer hacking convictions and employabi... by noasaservice on Monday February 14, 2022 @01:53PM (#30336437)
Vouched because of the good conversations going on downthread. Parent is pretty crude. I can live with crudeneess and bring the quality of the conversation up.

Anyways, I've wholeheartedly recommended lying in certain situations on employment. (Don't lie about certified/licensed/bonded jobs, dont like to the state/feds, dont lie about stuff you cant do.)

A while back (2009), I was in a very bad run. Got laid off. Didn't have a job for 1.5y . And it's hard to get back in work without already having a job... You get the side-eyes of "why werent you working this time???" crap.

So, I started lying on my resumes. I found a company that went bankrupt 2 towns over, and put them as employed in a role I'm easily capable of. Am I lying? Absolutely. Can I do the role? Absolutely.

I got the job, unsurprisingly enough. And I was there for 1y, enough to get a better work history to get out of the rut I was in. And I hopped from there to a better position, all the while slowly cleaning up the fakeness from my resume all the while generating a valid work history.

It sucks, sure, that there's no good way to break in the work-world if you've been ejected. (Que entry-level jobs that require 5y experience...) Frankly, vs starvation, homelessness, destitution - you damn straight I'll lie. And if I have to, I will definitely do it again. Capitalism is stone-cold and heartless. And if that's what I have to be to survive in the work-world to make money, so be it.

Re:Ask HN: Recent computer hacking convictions and employabi... by notch656a on Monday February 14, 2022 @02:03PM (#30336602)
Yeah when I wound up homeless, I started applying for lots of wage labor. I quickly found out they had no interest in hiring a college educated white-collar worker. I may or may not have discovered* that if I were to have changed my resume to all shit / labor jobs (while keeping everything else the same so I could remember the companies well), they would employ me. I would have been able to dig myself out of my rut and get stable employment in a factory until I could get back into tech.

After working in factory few months, I was able to get apartment. With apartment, I was able to get myself nice looking and clean and tech job.

My process from day labor/ homeless (save up enough for airbnb/hotel) -> wage job (save up for apartment) -> professional job at this point is pretty much a well oiled machine. Sadly the first two steps basically require dishonesty. I've only been through this a couple times in my life and hope not to again.

*This is all fiction, of course.