The whole premise is just laughable at face.
This think of the children trope is just bait IMO to try and get us to accept that there are second class citizens, and allow us to put restrictions and loss of freedoms on people who have completed their judicial punishment. If we can accept this we might accept ending their constitutional rights such as the right to vote, bear arms, or speak freely.
I understand the desire to protect children in this manner, I just think it's misguided and philosophically inconsistent.
We cant trust them because they re offend, but they re offend because of lack of opportunities created by society not trusting them....
It is certainly true for property crimes, drug crimes, and other such actions.
Violent crimes may be an exception to this, but then to the OP's point, if they are violent why are they out in the population to begin with?
It just seemed the question was phrased in terms of those being the only options, when in fact they are the very rare options. It seems that mostly people you hire are not going to do serious criminal things, either before or after you hire them.
That makes for a good argument not to trust them as much, generally speaking.
On the other hand, integrating them back into society (something that's lacking in the US) works well for most.