News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:We are closer to Bradbury’s dystopia than Orwell’s or Hux... by pizza234 on Monday February 14, 2022 @09:06AM (#30332121)
> Bradbury predicted that people, disturbed by confusing or challenging ideas, might one day demand censorship for themselves and protection from any information that pierced the veil of their own simplified reality.

> In a society now dominated by reassuringly reductive tweets and memes, where supposedly learned people choose to boycott long-form podcasts, encourage publishers to ditch books by controversial authors, or lean on streaming providers to severe ties with comedians and other artists, this prediction from 1953 sounds eerily familiar.

Assuming this is the underlying thesis of the article, this is a simplistic view of information.

In real world, it's not always obvious how to distinguish "controversial" with "crackpot". With today's ease of publishing, there's plenty of information on every crackpot theory, which requires a practically impossible amount of research from the individual to systematically falsify. Some of them are harmless (flat earth), some of them are potentially dangerous (e.g. ivermectin).

Spread of potentially dangerous information is a lose-lose situation. If let spread, it will cause (on large enough scale) harm, if not, the popoluation will scream at censhorship.

The related link to a Don’t Look Up screenshot in the article page is actually very telling - in that movie, the audience knows for certain that the asteroid/comet will destroy earth. In reality, it's not so black and white, and doomsday theories are a dime a dozen.

Articles like this don't help at all to shape a cognitive approach to modern excess of information.

Re:We are closer to Bradbury’s dystopia than Orwell’s or Hux... by chmod600 on Monday February 14, 2022 @01:34PM (#30336081)
Your best example of a dangerous theory is Ivermectin? How many deaths has that idea caused?

That's the problem with censorship/cancellation/deplatforming. The standards are very loose and selective. You say that a theory about Ivermectin is dangerous without a shred of evidence. Maybe it's wrong. Maybe people died. But I doubt it's of any significant scale. Probably it's just snake oil.

But how many morning TV hosts repeat the latest health food craze that's just as dubious? Why aren't those labeled "dangerous"?

The answer is that it's about politics, authority, and group identity; not health. You are really saying that JR has identified with the wrong tribe, and so it's time to expel him. And the fact that doctors (currently) agree with you is the justification to do so.

Life is complex and nuanced. Relying on authorities and groupthink works most of the time, but I'm glad not everyone does so or we would be in a dystopia.

Saying JR is a crackpot and ignoring him is fine, and that's probably where the smart money will be. But trying to ostracize him is not OK.

Re:We are closer to Bradbury’s dystopia than Orwell’s or Hux... by awb on Monday February 14, 2022 @02:42PM (#30337179)
> Your best example of a dangerous theory is Ivermectin? How many deaths has that idea caused?

I'm guessing that OP was referring to the idea of Ivermectin as a cure for COVID. For example, choosing not to get vaccinated or wear a mask but to have a plan to take Ivermectin if they contract COVID and then contracting COVID and spreading it to others and possibly succumbing to it.

Re:We are closer to Bradbury’s dystopia than Orwell’s or Hux... by chmod600 on Tuesday February 15, 2022 @04:56PM (#30353348)
But how dangerous is that idea, really? How many people heard the idea, and didn't get vaccinated because of it? If this idea weren't put out there, how many of those people would have just found some other reason to not get vaccinated?

It's just a scare tactic to get us to accept censorship/deplatforming/cancellation as a legitimate practice. Drugs are scary. Terrorists are scary. Now podcasters are scary.

Looks like we've already decided to give up our values, and we're just looking for any flimsy excuse to justify it.

Re:We are closer to Bradbury’s dystopia than Orwell’s or Hux... by inglor_cz on Monday February 14, 2022 @09:45AM (#30332582)
"With today's ease of publishing"

We seem to be replaying the Early Modern Age conversation about the printing press. The printing press was considered dangerous precisely because individuals and identities other than the Church could easily publish their heresies and the low-born could publish pamphlets attacking the Sovereign and Peers of the Realm.

In the Islamic world, the Caliph (who, at the time, was identical with the Ottoman Sultan) banned the use of the printing press by Muslims in 1485. (Unbelievers could print whatever they wanted in their languages and for their exclusive consumption.)

If you look at the entire history of suppressing misinformation, you will see that:

a) in the long run, freer societes did better,

b) the club of the censors seems to contain all the nastiest regimes and there seems to be a clear correlation between nastiness of a regime and its eagerness to control information; for that reason alone, I wouldn't want to be caught dead in the same company,

c) it was fairly common that the kind of information censored overlapped significantly with the kind of information that people in power didn't like.

Re:We are closer to Bradbury’s dystopia than Orwell’s or Hux... by cma on Monday February 14, 2022 @10:23AM (#30333071)
I think this is more akin to a king choosing to not be a patron of someone at the time (Spotify paying $100 million), not a king censoring criticism of himself, even if not becoming a patron of his ideological enemies has an arguably similar effect to censoring them.
Re:We are closer to Bradbury’s dystopia than Orwell’s or Hux... by pizza234 on Monday February 14, 2022 @10:00AM (#30332758)
To be clear, I don't take any position about how to handle "ease of publishing" (I may have used inappropriate terminology, as I was referring to publishing of ideas from individuals). To me, it's an open problem.
Re:We are closer to Bradbury’s dystopia than Orwell’s or Hux... by tanseydavid on Monday February 14, 2022 @10:13AM (#30332938)
>> We seem to be replaying the Early Modern Age conversation about the printing press.

Some people refer to this phenomenon as "The Internet Reformation." IMHO this is a very apt comparison.

Re:We are closer to Bradbury’s dystopia than Orwell’s or Hux... by clucas on Monday February 14, 2022 @11:19AM (#30333818)
I agree that it's useful to compare the public-information environments (1) shortly after the widespread adoption of the printing press and (2) shortly after the widespread adoption of the internet.

In the printing press example, what happened was that a hierarchy of trust developed. Publishing houses and periodicals in a wide variety of fields (science, news reporting, etc.) developed reputations for being trustworthy. Sometimes they abused that trust (or were simply mistaken), but as you note, in freer societies, these issues were corrected by other publications. At its best, this development of trust and accountability amounts to a society-wide conversation about what is true and what is useful.

With the internet, we're at an inflection point in our society where we can decide at what level we want these trust hierarchies to exist, and how the conversation should develop. Should social media platforms be allowed to be an active participant in this conversation? There is a contingent (well-represented on HN) that says "no, social media should be forced to carry whatever speech its users post." (Though generally very few people say they should be forced to leave up spam or pornography, if they want to remove it.)

I personally think that social media platforms should be allowed to participate in the society-level conversation by deciding what level of (what they deem to be) misinformation is allowed on their platform. When (not if) these platforms mess up, people will complain on other platforms (which still exist, despite protestrations to the contrary). To the extent that the largest platforms reject certain types of speech, it should be up to the proponents of those ideas to prove them out, and get society on board with their ideas. This is how things have worked in the past - small, upstart printing presses published pamphlets and try to disrupt the orthodoxy. If they can't, they fail.

But... if we're going to have social media platforms (and not just the internet at large) serve as the public square (and thus force them to bow out of the larger debate on what is and is not misinformation), then we need to start having some real conversations about what sort of stuff the platforms must carry, and how we make those decisions. Presumably a government body would have to make decisions about what the platforms can't remove. How should that body be set up, and how should it make its decisions?

Re:We are closer to Bradbury’s dystopia than Orwell’s or Hux... by TMWNN on Monday February 14, 2022 @07:21PM (#30340682)
>In the Islamic world, the Caliph (who, at the time, was identical with the Ottoman Sultan) banned the use of the printing press by Muslims in 1485. (Unbelievers could print whatever they wanted in their languages and for their exclusive consumption.)

[...]

>If you look at the entire history of suppressing misinformation, you will see that:

>a) in the long run, freer societes did better,

Quite.

As a result, 10,000 books have been translated into Arabic in the past 1,000 years. That is fewer than the number translated in Spain in one year. <https://www.reddit.com/r/todayilearned/comments/3e2xho/til_t...>

Re:We are closer to Bradbury’s dystopia than Orwell’s or Hux... by pinephoneguy on Monday February 14, 2022 @09:13AM (#30332204)
There are many people who argue that even having a discussion about side-loading apps is dangerous.

If you let some authority tell everyone what’s dangerous to talk about you give them absolute power. That’s far more dangerous than people taking some well understood medicine when they might not need it.

Re:We are closer to Bradbury’s dystopia than Orwell’s or Hux... by ehnto on Monday February 14, 2022 @09:53AM (#30332665)
> Some of them are harmless (flat earth)

There seems to be a non-trivial anti-semetic component to at least one version of the flat earth conspiracy. It seems there's not one coherent view that all flat-earther's follow, which is not surprising at all. But I would feel confident in saying that the part where the earth is flat is just a springboard for the more insidious conspiracies people conjure up.

Re:We are closer to Bradbury’s dystopia than Orwell’s or Hux... by MockObject on Monday February 14, 2022 @11:51AM (#30334244)
I wouldn't say it's a gateway drug, but rather a filter that selects for people willing to accept conspiracies that last hundreds of years and involve a million conspirators, across every advanced society, for unclear goals.
Re:We are closer to Bradbury’s dystopia than Orwell’s or Hux... by mannykannot on Monday February 14, 2022 @09:23AM (#30332332)
If I accept your argument I should reject it on account of the impossibility of adequately verifying its premises!
Re:We are closer to Bradbury’s dystopia than Orwell’s or Hux... by AlexDragusin on Monday February 14, 2022 @09:11AM (#30332180)
re flat earth, not as harmless I'd say https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hrAdayUh6-4
Re:We are closer to Bradbury’s dystopia than Orwell’s or Hux... by mannykannot on Monday February 14, 2022 @09:26AM (#30332367)
To be fair, this guy was almost certainly only adopting the flat-earth premise for publicity (and possibly funding.)
Re:We are closer to Bradbury’s dystopia than Orwell’s or Hux... by happytoexplain on Monday February 14, 2022 @09:39AM (#30332513)
This assertion is made about many "fringe" social/political sentiments (or alternatively, some version of "they're trolling you"), but I think people frequently misunderstand how many practical similarities there are between one promoting these things "ironically" vs sincerely, outside of one's own mind.
Re:We are closer to Bradbury’s dystopia than Orwell’s or Hux... by voakbasda on Monday February 14, 2022 @10:01AM (#30332775)
When done right, satire is indistinguishable from fundamentalism.