Forked it and spent the day upgrade to Aesara (the maintained Theano fork) and python3.
Haven't fully trained/tested the model, but feel free to take a look: https://github.com/kpister/biaxial-rnn-music-composition
Also, the old version could use a special incantation:
theano.config.experimental.unpickle_gpu_on_cpu = True
to run CPU-based inference on a GPU-trained model, even without a supported hardware GPU. It would be nice to check how this stuff works with the newer packages, and document it properly. Most likely nothing much has changed.Any prior information about the domain can be encoded in a way you prepare the input samples, and this would be equally useful and relevant regardless of the DL architecture you decide to use (RNNs, autoencoders, GANs, transformers).
Using raw audio samples has two advantages: First, you provide all available training data to a model, and trust that it will learn to extract what it needs from it. Second, unlike any other music representation formats, you have huge amounts of training data. So essentially all you need is a huge transformer and many thousands of GPUs to train it on, using all mp3s you can get your hands on, and you can reasonably expect a similar level of quality as the quality of text generated by GPT-3. What do you think?
Adding features to provide further information about the input data can be helpful, but not nearly as much as ensuring that strong priors are reflected in the actual model architecture, whenever relevant to the domain. Johnson's paper about biaxial RNN provides one example of how to do this in the context of music.
As for deep learning models which create good contrapuntal music, see e.g. 'Biaxial RNN' https://github.com/danieldjohnson/biaxial-rnn-music-composit... by Daniel D. Johnson, who is now at Google Brain but wrote this as an independent(!) researcher. (Note that the existing code requires Python 2.x It would be interesting to forward-port it so it can work with Python 3.x and a maintained version of Theano. Replicating the model using Tensorflow would also be quite worthwhile.)
If you're interested in Bach's work specifically, the "BachBot" and "DeepBach" projects are also interesting but less accessible.
Example output for all of these models can be found on the Internet, just look around for it. The proprietary system AIVA is also worth mentioning because even though it's so proprietary and secretive, the compelling and "serendipitous" music it manages to come up with is a tell-tale sign that it's actually doing well-founded deep learning stuff behind the scenes, much like the aforementioned open systems. Note that much of the released output has been orchestrated (AFAICT) manually by humans, but at some point I was able to find some piano-format reductions that are most likely very close to what the AI actually created, somewhere on the official site.