News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Sci-Hub statistics and database by periheli0n on Sunday February 13, 2022 @08:18AM (#30321573)
Sci-hub is sometimes the last resort to obtain a resource that is otherwise unobtainable. But what has become of the old way of obtaining unaccessible papers: Ask the authors for a copy?

Sites like ResearchGate make this very easy. And often a simple email does the job, too.

Advantages:

* It is legal

* The author gets feedback that someone out there reads their research

* Making direct contact to your peers is a good thing.

Re:Sci-Hub statistics and database by abcc8 on Sunday February 13, 2022 @10:10AM (#30322151)
It's too time consuming and has an undefined likelihood of success. People will naturally flock to alternative methods, such as sci-hub, that are faster and until recently were near guaranteed to have the desired content.
Re:Sci-Hub statistics and database by periheli0n on Sunday February 13, 2022 @01:22PM (#30324099)
Agreed, sci-hub is so much more convenient. But when the publishers finally shut it down for good, we'll have to find another solution.

A community of scientists sharing their papers would be a good thing already now.

I personally know active scientists who don't even try anymore to look up the paper, but rather go directly to sci-hub for any doi they need. I can understand why, but I also think that this doesn't lead to a sustainable publishing culture.

Re:Sci-Hub statistics and database by yellowcake0 on Sunday February 13, 2022 @11:46AM (#30323065)
Except a researcher could easily need to skim 30+ papers in a day, this is not a solution.
Re:Sci-Hub statistics and database by periheli0n on Sunday February 13, 2022 @01:13PM (#30324004)
Agreed, in that case that wouldn't work.

But honestly, how often does one have to skim that many papers in a day, to a level where the freely available abstract is not sufficient?

Perhaps every once in a while when one compiles a survey of a new field they enter. Once the project is set on the rails, one rarely has to read that much.

Re:Sci-Hub statistics and database by yellowcake0 on Sunday February 13, 2022 @01:40PM (#30324281)
> how often does one have to skim that many papers in a day, to a level where the freely available abstract is not sufficient?

More often than you might think.

To take an example from my own work, I was doing assay design a while back, and needed to collect all existing primer sets in the literature. I probably went through a hundred papers over a several day period.

Re:Sci-Hub statistics and database by nottorp on Sunday February 13, 2022 @11:34AM (#30322938)
> It is legal

Are you sure that the usual suspects don't make authors assign copyright or at least distribution rights? I wouldn't put it past them...

Re:Sci-Hub statistics and database by periheli0n on Sunday February 13, 2022 @01:08PM (#30323942)
I have signed quite a few of those copyright transfer forms, and there are always a clause that would allow sharing on a personal basis.