Remember, no pc's, no laptop's, no social media and the constant inability of (geeky) college males to score. Gotta do something other than schoolwork.
My brothers and I bought Axis & Allies about 25 years ago. We spent a few hours trying to assimilate the rules.
Then we got bored and did something less mentally taxing.
We concluded that Axis and Allies was supposed to teach you the futility of war.
Me and my friends played Axis and Allies for probably close to 500 hours in the 80's (middle & high school)
A&A and Supremacy were our go-tos.
Air Superiority was also one of our favorites.
WOPR: "A strange game. The only winning move is not to play. How about a nice game of chess?"
I played a lot of A&A in the early 90s, as well as DnD.
The market for buying/selling them is still fine (especially with the internet now), they're enjoyable to read and collect. I've got a dozen myself.
For war games though, it was probably really hard to find someone to play against that wanted to put in the hours ...
I should’ve stuck with just the base set and looked for people to play it with, but I kept buying the expansion packs instead.
If I had to guess, I'd say 98% of all copies of hex+counter wargames are never played, just pored over and dreamed about.