News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Shoplifting reaches crisis proportions by TedShiller on Saturday February 12, 2022 @03:32PM (#30316095)
Let the market handle this. Simply close stores with high theft rates, which will happen anyway since they’re unprofitable.
Re:Shoplifting reaches crisis proportions by e4e78a06 on Saturday February 12, 2022 @03:39PM (#30316164)
Already happening in SF as we speak. And the remaining stores have super jacked up prices to the point that it's cheaper to order delivery from a store in the suburbs, pay a tip for a driver, and pay them to do the shopping for you (Instacart) than it is to buy locally.

It's clear that Prop 47 and the general mentality that property crimes don't matter and prosecuting them is racist has failed.

Re:Shoplifting reaches crisis proportions by notthemessiah on Saturday February 12, 2022 @03:45PM (#30316227)
I'm sure shoplifting is to blame, and not the price of rent and lack of new construction.
Re:Shoplifting reaches crisis proportions by e4e78a06 on Saturday February 12, 2022 @03:49PM (#30316285)
They're both problems that can be attacked independently. You can crack down hard on shoplifters and reselling rings but also build lots of new housing.

Price of rent is a function of housing supply and demand. Rent control just pushes the costs to less visible things like security deposit, maintenance, etc.

Re:Shoplifting reaches crisis proportions by notthemessiah on Saturday February 12, 2022 @04:05PM (#30316461)
They're more interconnected than at first glace. When ambitious people can't be stakeholders in the economy due to NIMBY gatekeepers, they resort to less socially-acceptable means of getting ahead and making it big.

I don't think "reselling rings" are that easy to crack down on, they probably are not rings at all rely on apps and services and operate on a more individual basis. The very framing of such is just used to justify greater police budgets, but this is something far harder than even the drug war to win. The only way to win it is to make sure entrepreneurial sorts find it more profitable to do things legitimately than it is to plunder goods, and ensure jobs and job training are more accessible than a life of crime.

Re:Shoplifting reaches crisis proportions by e4e78a06 on Sunday February 13, 2022 @02:52PM (#30324970)
> When ambitious people can't be stakeholders in the economy due to NIMBY gatekeepers, they resort to less socially-acceptable means of getting ahead and making it big

I don't ever remember thinking of drug dealers at any school I went to as "ambitious". Some drug _users_, yes, but they never stole stuff to fund their drug habit. It was more like recreational, responsible alcohol for them. And now that we all have careers it's pretty clear who was actually ambitious and who wasted their parents' money.

Re:Shoplifting reaches crisis proportions by nine_k on Saturday February 12, 2022 @04:25PM (#30316659)
I suppose you're not suggesting that people whose ambition to become business leaders is hindered by high rent turn to running criminal rings?
Re:Shoplifting reaches crisis proportions by notthemessiah on Saturday February 12, 2022 @04:42PM (#30316824)
If you grow up in a neighborhood where the only example of financial success around you is a drug dealer, and every honest person is losing, what would you want to be when you grow up?
Re:Shoplifting reaches crisis proportions by baryphonic on Saturday February 12, 2022 @03:48PM (#30316275)
> Let the market handle this.

Not sure I want that. When the state refuses to protect private property, the market solution tends to look more like Vito Corleone. That's especially true when it appears certain organized crime groups are perpetrating coordinated thefts like the one at Nordstrom. The big corporations can't afford to to have mafia payments on the books, but they can afford to pack up and leave or encase everything in cages. The local mom 'n' pop store will be willing to pay a bit for protection.

Re:Shoplifting reaches crisis proportions by nine_k on Saturday February 12, 2022 @04:33PM (#30316728)
I think that the OP is ironic, and suggests that the market will force everyone reasonable to leave, exposing California as a failed state.

While that would indeed he instructive, it also would be quite destructive. I hope California can return to protecting the liberties that were already well-understood 200 years ago without going to such extremes.

Re:Shoplifting reaches crisis proportions by night862 on Saturday February 12, 2022 @04:18PM (#30316593)
Kind of, though:

In the past stores had Loss Prevention departments which were tasked with this stuff. It's never been the case that nobody shop lifted, its just now that the economic race has led retailers to externalize and cut costs.

It's very, very annoying to have some mall cop following you around, so now its a camera, later it will be many more and much better cameras with a lower paid employee with much less engagement with their occupation. I reject that it is an impossible task for national retailers.

I suspect walmart has a workable model: They move stocking into the shopping hours and use all of their employees as a micro-scale surveillance network.

Why should society foot the bill for for police and such to watch private property like this and essentialy persecute the population because the national retailers don't want to invest in the cost of doing business?

Inside of a store, it's completely reasonable and totally possible to just have an employee around.

Policing organized crime is the job of the FBI, if my knowledge of this stuff is a little bit correct. All of this surveillance garbage we've been ignoring for decades was supposed to solve these problems, but it is clearly not capable of doing so.

Re:Shoplifting reaches crisis proportions by notthemessiah on Saturday February 12, 2022 @04:07PM (#30316475)
The market is also what provides demand for cheap goods at a time when prices are increasing, and corporate profits are skyrocketing. Retail theft is the correction.
Re:Shoplifting reaches crisis proportions by ardit33 on Saturday February 12, 2022 @03:39PM (#30316165)
Absolutely not. There are actually human costs to it. My parents are old (in their 70s), and they are lucky to have a CVS near by where they can walk and get their medicine and basic needs.

Pharmacies and grocery stores being forced to close due to unchecked theft inflict pain and major lowering of quality of life to people around the neighborhood, and especially to people that can't just drive to the next store.

Also "just use online", may not be a solution. Medicine (especially pain pills), are continuous target of thefts.

Once the stores are closed, then the organized criminals move into homes. Next you will have to start installing heavy iron bars in your home. If you walk in parts of brooklyn, you'd see older homes that had massive bars even in 2nd floor windows, just to keep the people safe.

The market just doesn't solve the collapse of society. Unchecked theft costs to all society.

Re:Shoplifting reaches crisis proportions by coryrc on Saturday February 12, 2022 @03:50PM (#30316286)
We live in a democracy, more or less, which allows the majority to dictate what is acceptable in society. The majority has decided that a subset of society is not beholden to the laws the rest of us are. Jim Crow laws were unjust and it was the victims who had to fight it. Elderly people have most of the wealth in this country, if they've got a problem then they should put that wealth to work convincing a majority of their views.
Re:Shoplifting reaches crisis proportions by zbentley on Saturday February 12, 2022 @03:59PM (#30316399)
> Elderly people have most of the wealth in this country

That's...so reductive as to be actively misleading. "Have", "most", and "wealth" all deserve several asterisks.

Re:Shoplifting reaches crisis proportions by GiorgioG on Saturday February 12, 2022 @03:56PM (#30316358)
> Elderly people have most of the wealth in this country, if they've got a problem then they should put that wealth to work convincing a majority of their views.

The elderly people with this wealth don't care - they can afford to live in places where this isn't a problem. Everyone else (young and old alike) can take a hike as far as these rich old folks are concerned.

Re:Shoplifting reaches crisis proportions by creamynebula on Saturday February 12, 2022 @03:44PM (#30316220)
I don't know what needs to start happening for society to reach a consensus that we need to address the problems of poverty and inequaliy in income and access to good education
Re:Shoplifting reaches crisis proportions by phendrenad2 on Saturday February 12, 2022 @04:05PM (#30316462)
Part of "let the market handle it" is your parents moving to a safer place.
Re:Shoplifting reaches crisis proportions by gpt5 on Saturday February 12, 2022 @03:38PM (#30316153)
Which seems like a bad deal for everyone (the stores, the people in the neighborhood, and even the shoplifters).
Re:Shoplifting reaches crisis proportions by ameminator on Saturday February 12, 2022 @03:39PM (#30316169)
The community gets the shopping options it asks for, apparently (or not, according to the article).
Re:Shoplifting reaches crisis proportions by qbasic_forever on Saturday February 12, 2022 @03:40PM (#30316176)
Why should my grocery store close because people are stealing things from it? What do I do, just starve?
Re:Shoplifting reaches crisis proportions by ejb999 on Saturday February 12, 2022 @03:43PM (#30316205)
...because they are losing money? stores aren't in business to feed you; they are in business to make money. Would you continue to own and run a store if it lost money for you? Better have deep pockets then.
Re:Shoplifting reaches crisis proportions by SllX on Saturday February 12, 2022 @03:46PM (#30316245)
You’re being downvoted for this, but you are right, and it’s why we have—or ought to have—a vested interest in enforcing our laws.
Re:Shoplifting reaches crisis proportions by qbasic_forever on Saturday February 12, 2022 @03:47PM (#30316259)
How does society function if no one is tasked with feeding the people?

Are we all supposed to own farms? How does that work with 330 million Americans? Who is going to have time to do things like design the hardware and software that power the devices you use to post on the internet--they don't have time to do that and work their personal farm for food...

Re:Shoplifting reaches crisis proportions by ameminator on Saturday February 12, 2022 @04:45PM (#30316848)
I understand your point, that we all need to come together to solve community problems, as a community.

However, let's put this in context - when was the last time you did something, purely altruisticly, without any expectation of recompense? I think the people who do that kind of work are exceptional and exceptionally rare (assuming you are such a person). Even in those cases, those exceptional people choose problems where they can do the most good - and even if it can be argued that a community grocery store is such a place, it "competes" with various other local and global issues.

I imagine you need to get paid yourself in order to support your lifestyle.

Imagine someone were to approach you and ask the fruits of your labor for free - "qbasic_forever's software is a community good, why won't he simply do it for free?" I'm sure you have a variety of reasons, but most people's answers would be: life requires resources, so I must acquire those resources so that I and my family can live.

The grocery store owner and employees are in a similar circumstance. Or perhaps, a worse circumstance: "why should we continue to provide for a community which constantly steals from us and makes it harder for us to live?"

I have a very hard time answering this question - so I sympathize dearly with the grocery store owner.

Re:Shoplifting reaches crisis proportions by SllX on Saturday February 12, 2022 @04:03PM (#30316446)
No one is actually tasked with feeding people. We benefit from the surplus of farms which sell their excess for profit, and you are then tasked with securing the means of purchasing food if you want to eat.

Or: farms task themselves with producing food in the same way programmers task themselves with producing software.

Re:Shoplifting reaches crisis proportions by qbasic_forever on Saturday February 12, 2022 @04:08PM (#30316488)
Why should the farmers stay in business of making food if they could make more money as programmers, bitcoin traders, etc?
Re:Shoplifting reaches crisis proportions by SllX on Saturday February 12, 2022 @04:13PM (#30316541)
Why do people go into Real Estate or hospitality or teaching if they could make more money as programmers, bitcoin traders, etc?

The answer is, I don’t know why people do everything they do, but the labor market sorts itself out according to incentives, ability, compensation, laws, education, the dispersal of information and any number of factors.

We have farms and they are really good at what they do because we have food that is readily and cheaply accessible in abundance.

Re:Shoplifting reaches crisis proportions by ameminator on Saturday February 12, 2022 @03:46PM (#30316242)
I mean, if the people running the store can't profitably operate (due to theft or other factors), why should they operate?

Why should the owners of that supermarket go into ruin just to give you another shopping option? Why is it their responsibility to keep you fed at all?

Re:Shoplifting reaches crisis proportions by notthemessiah on Saturday February 12, 2022 @04:32PM (#30316722)
My grandfather owned and operated an early contemporary grocery store, growing from his fruit stand. Before self-service shopping and the checkout line, you would just give the grocer a list of what you would need and they would get it from the inventory. This also made theft impractical. Now, with the skyrocketing cost of retail rent, and other costs affiliated with retail store operations, we see a return full-service shopping with apps and food service operating out of ghost kitchens, we're finding out we don't need grocery stores.
Re:Shoplifting reaches crisis proportions by ameminator on Saturday February 12, 2022 @04:49PM (#30316887)
It's a shame - however, I live in an area without this endemic shop-lifting. I enjoy my local community store and I'm sad that others in these high-crime areas cannot.
Re:Shoplifting reaches crisis proportions by qbasic_forever on Saturday February 12, 2022 @03:49PM (#30316280)
Why should firefighters put out fires? They make no money from it. It costs them money in equipment wear, water usage, etc.!
Re:Shoplifting reaches crisis proportions by zbentley on Saturday February 12, 2022 @03:56PM (#30316361)
I'm sympathetic to your grandparent statement (closing stores can really screw their patrons), but the comparison to firefighters is apples to oranges. Firefighting is a civic utility-everyone contributes a little bit for the service. Grocery stores are not, in most locales.
Re:Shoplifting reaches crisis proportions by qbasic_forever on Saturday February 12, 2022 @04:30PM (#30316698)
If no one fights fires, they burn uncontrollably and we all die. If no grocery stores operate, we all starve and die. Feeding the people is the same level of protection as fighting fires.
Re:Shoplifting reaches crisis proportions by nine_k on Saturday February 12, 2022 @04:38PM (#30316776)
Expenses of firefighting are paid from the state budget. When expenses of grocery stores (dispensaries?) will be paid from the state budget, the comparison would stand.

Also, shoplifting is like calling firefighters to water your lawn, because, see, it's free!

Re:Shoplifting reaches crisis proportions by ameminator on Saturday February 12, 2022 @04:00PM (#30316406)
Running a store is very different from firefighting - arguably there is a much higher moral good being done by literally saving people from imminent death by burning. Firefighters are also paid in many places, even if volunteer services are available.

Finally, they do have charitable "food delivery" places - they are called soup kitchens, but they are intended for people who can't afford food at all, not necessarily for people who have the money to buy what they need.

Re:Shoplifting reaches crisis proportions by foogazi on Saturday February 12, 2022 @04:25PM (#30316651)
Because they get paid to do it - they literally make money from fighting fires
Re:Shoplifting reaches crisis proportions by qbasic_forever on Saturday February 12, 2022 @04:29PM (#30316689)
How does this business of fire fighting make money? All they do is spend money on equipment, labor, etc. Where is their income coming from, and who is incentivized to keep paying them despite no profit and no return on investment ever?
Re:Shoplifting reaches crisis proportions by ameminator on Saturday February 12, 2022 @04:47PM (#30316863)
It doesn't, but the community decided that it was valuable, so chose to fund it using taxes, collectively. If you make the case to your community for a communal grocery store, it too can be funded with taxes. Be warned, it comes with its own set of problems that are hard to predict at the outset.
Re:Shoplifting reaches crisis proportions by TedShiller on Saturday February 12, 2022 @04:55PM (#30316926)
Actually, I have private fire insurance that I do pay for, and the insurance makes plenty of money on it. That's ok with me.
Re:Shoplifting reaches crisis proportions by missingrib on Saturday February 12, 2022 @04:00PM (#30316402)
People could pay for a service where firefighters would come and put out a potential fire at their house.
Re:Shoplifting reaches crisis proportions by qbasic_forever on Saturday February 12, 2022 @04:31PM (#30316703)
What if your neighbor decides not to pay their fire fighting bill? You going to be happy about living within feet of their uncontrolled blaze?
Re:Shoplifting reaches crisis proportions by MerelyMortal on Sunday February 13, 2022 @01:46AM (#30319820)
I believe those firefighting services will respond to every fire, they will just watch and prevent it from burning a neighboring house that does pay.
Re:Shoplifting reaches crisis proportions by hirundo on Saturday February 12, 2022 @03:48PM (#30316267)
The average grocery store profit margin is around 2.2%. If additional shoplifting amounts to a substantial fraction of that, then there's no reason to keep the business open. Grocery stores aren't pro bono.

https://thegrocerystoreguy.com/what-is-the-profit-margin-for...

Re:Shoplifting reaches crisis proportions by Ekaros on Saturday February 12, 2022 @05:14PM (#30317027)
They have massive revenue, but low margins. Also large chunk of their stock are perishable, meaning that inventory control and so on is critical. It really doesn't compare to many other industries. And not to forgot how harsh the competition is too.

Really many factors bring even some losses to be unacceptable.

Re:Shoplifting reaches crisis proportions by Ekaros on Sunday February 13, 2022 @05:32AM (#30320769)
Because you and other people in the community aren't filling the other side of social contract. That is ensuring that store can operate without unnecessary losses from you or your community members stealing from it. It is in the end your failing of making operation possible.
Re:Shoplifting reaches crisis proportions by zthrowaway on Saturday February 12, 2022 @06:17PM (#30317352)
Vote for DA’s and politicians that enforce the law.
Re:Shoplifting reaches crisis proportions by azth on Sunday February 13, 2022 @12:06AM (#30319400)
Talk to your government officials to fix the underlying problem.
Re:Shoplifting reaches crisis proportions by theduder99 on Saturday February 12, 2022 @03:45PM (#30316229)
no please don't starve, you should start stealing food like your neighbors do.
Re:Shoplifting reaches crisis proportions by yibg on Saturday February 12, 2022 @04:14PM (#30316549)
Yea I mean why have police at all? Just let the market sort out all out. If people keep getting shot, we’ll eventually the neighborhood will empty out and no more shootings!
Re:Shoplifting reaches crisis proportions by nine_k on Saturday February 12, 2022 @04:27PM (#30316675)
People would pool money and hire a private protection agency then.
Re:Shoplifting reaches crisis proportions by yibg on Saturday February 12, 2022 @04:40PM (#30316799)
Yea that sure works great in countries with ineffective law enforcement.
Re:Shoplifting reaches crisis proportions by oh_sigh on Saturday February 12, 2022 @03:33PM (#30316108)
That's literally the first sentence of the article.
Re:Shoplifting reaches crisis proportions by supernovae on Saturday February 12, 2022 @03:39PM (#30316167)
when has capitalism ever fixed crime?
Re:Shoplifting reaches crisis proportions by qbasic_forever on Saturday February 12, 2022 @03:43PM (#30316202)
2008 financial crash saw almost no bank executives prosecuted, so from their perspective banking crimes are fixed and not a problem anymore.