Even within economics it's treated as a rare market effect and not as a given eventuality
If overall resource consumption stays the same or increases, then boom: Jevon’s paradox. And experience shows me that’s the norm, not an exception.
I don't believe it for the same reasons. Though I agree that what we actually need for climate change is a seemingly-impossible amount of political coordination. A global pollution tax (not just on CO2) which no country or state can race to the bottom to escape.
So many people are categorically "anti-globalist" (I don't know what this means, but that's the sentiment I feel from them) that I have no idea if we can pull it off.
I’m not saying efficiency isn’t valuable. I like an efficient process as much as the next nerd. What I am saying is that we can’t consume our way out of global warming. The total carbon cost of a tesla over it’s lifespan is in the same order of magnitude as that of a regular car (i.e. about half). The only choice that has a significant impact on climate change is to “consume less” driving. I.e. bikes, public transit, etc. those are 10x or 100x choices.
But if there isn’t good bike or transit infrastructure where you live - i.e. it’s not an available choice - then an electric is better than nothing.
I'm not saying that if you write Rust you save the planet, but in certain scenarios, the energy you save by having some parts of your services written in Rust can be significant.
> There have been too many data center efficiency improvements to list
This seems consistent with jevon’s paradox. Efficiency improvements have not reduced the overall consumption.
Unless you believe that efficiency improvements have just randomly coincided with growth and they happen to cancel each-other out… but it seems more likely to me that cheap compute contributed to the huge uptick in machine learning / big data etc.
I wonder how much of that 200TWh is burnt trying to profile me, track me, and sell me stuff that has little or negative impact on my standard of living. I’d be willing to bet well over half. What’s facebook’s portion of that 200TWh?
The more efficient you make it the cheaper it is to use, the cheaper it is to use the more people use it. Efficiency just creates more consumption.
You can’t “efficiency” your way out of climate change. Sorry.