News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Nike.com's robots.txt by npteljes on Friday February 11, 2022 @10:24AM (#30302467)
Well, why not? We also talk to each other for free, giving advice, information, lots of things of some kind of value, and mostly it's free. People organize on platforms to help each other with info, for free, for example you can ask people on Reddit to identify a bug or stone for you. Now I know hosting Reddit isn't free, but this is for another time I think. Now I just want to say that what you pointed out is not really something that's purely illogical or entitled.
Re:Nike.com's robots.txt by paulcole on Friday February 11, 2022 @03:27PM (#30306602)
> Now I know hosting Reddit isn't free, but this is for another time I think.

You can't just pretend like the key fact isn't relevant.

Platforms don't grow on trees.

Somebody has bills to pay and its up to them how to decide how to pay them. If you don't like their decision, find another platform or moan incessantly about it.

Re:Nike.com's robots.txt by npteljes on Saturday February 12, 2022 @08:36AM (#30312703)
I know the realities and I don't think this factor is irrelevant - hosting can cost a lot. I bemoan ads specifically, because I think as they are and were, they are a net negative for humanity. Having an addiction fueling platform in exchange for it doubles down on this negativity. I'm thinking where ads are the answer, or the main enabler of content, then the content itself is questionable, is what I'm trying to get at.
Re:Nike.com's robots.txt by motoxpro on Friday February 11, 2022 @03:25PM (#30306572)
Hosting Reddit is not free, maintaining reddit is not free, moderators time is not free
Re:Nike.com's robots.txt by npteljes on Saturday February 12, 2022 @08:29AM (#30312660)
Moderators' time is free, and maintaining reddit could be free. Hosting uses electricity, hardware and internet connection, and neither of those are given away currently.
Re:Nike.com's robots.txt by motoxpro on Monday February 14, 2022 @12:12AM (#30328608)
Ah, agree to disagree on that one. That view seems exploitive to me. Moderation, OSS maintainers, etc are all doing those jobs for free and providing them to us for free but there is a large opportunity cost.

That's where the saying "it's not worth my time" comes from. If I asked you why you don't maintain and moderate reddit for free (I'm sure they would be happy to have you there and pay you nothing) I would assume your answer would be I have better things to do with my time or I don't have enough time. i.e. I need to be paid for that to be worth it.

Re:Nike.com's robots.txt by npteljes on Monday February 14, 2022 @04:00AM (#30329846)
Well, yeah, ideally I'd like an UBI-like system, so that one can moderate Reddit full time, and still pay rent and groceries. But letting that aside, do you think that all volunteers are in fact exploited? Or just these examples, because effectively they help someone else make money for free?
Re:Nike.com's robots.txt by motoxpro on Wednesday February 16, 2022 @02:29AM (#30357265)
I mentioned exploitive in response to "Moderators' time is free". Which I feel like is an exploitive view. I don't think being a volunteer means you are exploited, but I think someone not valuing their time is almost the definition of it to me.

I think moderators time is extremely expensive. They could be doing one million other things with that time and getting paid for it. They could actually be doing the EXACT SAME thing and getting paid for it if they worked for a Reddit/Facebook/StackOverflow or were a community manager for a brand.