News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Starship Update [video] by sfblah on Thursday February 10, 2022 @11:01PM (#30296782)
I completely agree with this line of reasoning, which is why I called the fixation with Mars Quixotic elsewhere in the thread. I was discussing this with some friends. Why not just pick some other totally inhospitable environment and try to live there instead? I mentioned inside a volcano lower in the thread. It seems to me you'd get all the same side-benefits of technological development.
Re:Starship Update [video] by fastball on Thursday February 10, 2022 @11:15PM (#30296888)
Because if an asteroid destroys earth, your volcano base ain't gonna save life as we know it.

Because any such project is going to require herculean effort on the part of many humans, and many humans are interested in colonizing Mars but not so many are interested in colonizing volcanoes.

Your question is basically: why do people care about this thing I don't care about and instead care about this thing that neither I nor they care about.

Re:Starship Update [video] by sangnoir on Friday February 11, 2022 @03:46AM (#30298870)
> Because if an asteroid destroys earth, your volcano base ain't gonna save life as we know it

If an asteroid destroys earth, your Mars base won't save life as we know it either. There's a lot of handwaving in this thread on the technologies required to bridge the gap between Starship existing and self-sustaining life on Mars. Paradoxically, self-sustaining space manufacture/Mars colony will obviate the need for frequent heavy-lift rocket launches.

Re:Starship Update [video] by fastball on Friday February 11, 2022 @10:12AM (#30302330)
How is that paradoxical? Bootstrapping a self-sustaining colony on Mars will require getting a massive amount of payload to the red planet. Once bootstrapped, yes that will no longer be required.

Nobody is arguing that Starship is sufficient, just that it is necessary.

Re:Starship Update [video] by sangnoir on Friday February 11, 2022 @03:23PM (#30306553)
> Nobody is arguing that Starship is sufficient, just that it is necessary.

No, it's the yet-to-be-invented tech that is necessary. Your unstated prior is that this non-existent tech will in turn require heavy-lift capacity, and there is no evidence for that. Maybe we can bootstrap space manufacturing off 2 Arianne 5 launches, or 50 starship launches, nobody knows because it's all make-believe atm.

What Starship is good for, is frequent supply runs to a dependant Mars base, with today's technology - but that's nor what people are saying because that's not sexy.

Re:Starship Update [video] by sfblah on Friday February 11, 2022 @12:50AM (#30297558)
I guess you’ve never read about Xenu. Some people believe volcanoes are pretty important.
Re:Starship Update [video] by elkos on Friday February 11, 2022 @01:52AM (#30297932)
And DC-9s if I remember correctly
Re:Starship Update [video] by ralfd on Friday February 11, 2022 @06:52AM (#30300320)
But the utopian end goal is to make Mars hospitable. For Musk a Mars city is not the end goal but the first step. For example one could make a magnetic shield in L1 Mars Orbit. There was a speculative Nasa study (Wikipedia):

> If constructed, the shield may allow the planet to restore its atmosphere. Simulations indicate that within years, the planet would be able to achieve half the atmospheric pressure of Earth. Without solar winds stripping away at the planet, frozen carbon dioxide at the ice caps on either pole would begin to sublimate (change from a solid into a gas) and warm the equator. Ice caps would begin to melt to form an ocean. T

Of course there is much difficulty and unkown unknowns. Maybe this is truly impossible. Maybe this will take a million years. Maybe Mars soil is too toxic for plant growth.

But the upshoot of terraforming Mars is so fantastical, that it is at least worth dreaming about.