News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Have we been thinking about inflation all wrong? by uses on Thursday February 10, 2022 @04:40PM (#30293044)
Inflation doesn't exist as a policy to stiff wage earners. Inflation exists as a reality of a growing economy (more goods and services needs more money to cover them). The alternative is deflation, which would be extremely bad. So what we aim for, is low inflation. Which we've had for ~40 years. Low, controlled inflation is the vastly preferable alternative to any amount of deflation, so it's the side of the scale we target, giving a ~2% margin of error (~2% is the inflation level usually targeted by modern central banks).

What Krugman is talking about is that cutting wages is extremely hard for employers to do. Nobody wants to take a paycut. So what employers do instead, being put in the situation of needing to cut payroll, is eliminate entire positions. Which on the whole is worse than a paycut because of the destabilizing effect to the individual and society. So a positive side effect of inflation (not the main effect, a side effect), is that in the absence of pay raises, low inflation creates a constant mild paycut unless there is specifically a pay raise. It makes the economy more resilient.

Re:Have we been thinking about inflation all wrong? by friedturkey on Thursday February 10, 2022 @05:29PM (#30293629)
Yeah, deflation is awful. Imagine our continuously increased production and efficiency resulting in goods becoming cheaper and the value of the working person’s dollar going farther.

Horrifying.

Re:Have we been thinking about inflation all wrong? by BitwiseFool on Thursday February 10, 2022 @05:39PM (#30293740)
There's this really weird dichotomy where whats "good for the economy" is often bad for you as an individual, and vice versa.
Re:Have we been thinking about inflation all wrong? by dnautics on Thursday February 10, 2022 @06:41PM (#30294489)
Sure because the people who decide what is "good for the economy" have different interests than pretty much every other individual in it.
Re:Have we been thinking about inflation all wrong? by pashamur on Thursday February 10, 2022 @08:10PM (#30295453)
It’s a real thing:

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Paradox_of_thrift

You get ahead by saving, but everyone can’t do that all together or the economy collapses.

Re:Have we been thinking about inflation all wrong? by dnautics on Friday February 11, 2022 @12:51AM (#30297568)
It's a model that makes behavioral assumptions that are provably wrong. The fact that people buy computers despite prices going down contradicts the underlying assumption. There is nothing particularly special about computers among all goods.
Re:Have we been thinking about inflation all wrong? by fuzzfactor on Friday February 11, 2022 @08:49AM (#30301434)
Only collapse of the consumer economy, which in the first place should never be allowed to rise to enough significance to be much of a show-stopping collapse when it happens.
Re:Have we been thinking about inflation all wrong? by jokethrowaway on Thursday February 10, 2022 @05:35PM (#30293701)
With deflation there would be no reason to invest your money, paralysing the economy.

Some inflation is needed; what we don't need is https://brrr.money/

Re:Have we been thinking about inflation all wrong? by dnautics on Thursday February 10, 2022 @05:54PM (#30293914)
"no reason to invest your money"

You mean with deflation people will suddenly no longer want for more money? Sign us up!

Re:Have we been thinking about inflation all wrong? by imtringued on Thursday February 10, 2022 @06:21PM (#30294236)
If there is no reason to invest they will want more money. Once the interest rate drops below liquidity preference the desire to hold money approaches infinity. This is known as the keynesian liquidity trap. The only solution is to implement negative interest rates on cash to neutralize the liquidity preference.

Even if you have negative interest rates on money, people will flock to the next basic human need that has its own liquidity preference. Once the yield on land or property falls below liquidity preference people will hold onto empty property. The solution to the problem is to neutralize ground rent via land value taxation.

Thus you have both a money cycle and a real estate cycle.

Re:Have we been thinking about inflation all wrong? by ska on Thursday February 10, 2022 @06:10PM (#30294123)
> You mean with deflation people will suddenly no longer want for more money? Sign us up!

No, they mean that people will want jobs and not find them. [addition: this is at least the orthodox view behind small inflation targets as policy, that on the whole it's the best trade off]

Re:Have we been thinking about inflation all wrong? by friedturkey on Thursday February 10, 2022 @06:44PM (#30294528)
Japan is said to be deflationary (until covid at least) and lacks an unemployment problem.
Re:Have we been thinking about inflation all wrong? by ska on Thursday February 10, 2022 @06:48PM (#30294573)
Is japan deflationary in real terms? Even if so I suspect the economists would argue endlessly about "other factors".

Either way, I'm not saying I believe the analysis, but when economists talk about the problems of deflation they aren't afraid that people will have "enough" money.

Re:Have we been thinking about inflation all wrong? by notahacker on Thursday February 10, 2022 @06:23PM (#30294266)
People who already have lots of money will no longer want for more money.

That's not so great for the people who need to borrow it, or want a job

Re:Have we been thinking about inflation all wrong? by colinmhayes on Thursday February 10, 2022 @07:13PM (#30294879)
There will not be many working people if the economy is deflationary. Please read a macro book so you at least understand what you're arguing against before spouting nonsense.
Re:Have we been thinking about inflation all wrong? by friedturkey on Thursday February 10, 2022 @07:48PM (#30295265)
Japan says its economy has been in deflation since the 90s.[1] Everybody is working. Sure, the numbers aren't going up and there aren't constant booms of new companies being valued at 100 billion and exploding (which draws ire from economists and billionaire investors), but quality of life has been consistently high for normal people. Homelessness is barely present and people who want a job can find one quickly.

If the books say it's wrong, maybe it's time they get updated.

[1] https://www5.cao.go.jp/zenbun/wp-e/wp-je03/03-00102.html

Re:Have we been thinking about inflation all wrong? by runako on Thursday February 10, 2022 @09:53PM (#30296287)
> Homelessness is barely present

Can be vulgar to point this out, but the homelessness in America is a policy choice. If America had the same economy as Japan, we would still have lots of homelessness, because that is how we choose to organize our society.

This sounds facile, but then again consider how we choose to organize our healthcare system.

Re:Have we been thinking about inflation all wrong? by colinmhayes on Thursday February 10, 2022 @07:55PM (#30295326)
Japan isn't a very good example because their economy has absolutely tanked because of their horrible monetary policy. Japan was in a liquidity trap caused by their low inflation for literally decades which caused their economy to grow barely 1% annually. The reason their unemployment rate is low is because they've been stuck in this rut for literally 30 years, so people have adjusted. That doesn't mean it isn't causing immense harm though. Real wages are literally lower than they were in the early 90s. https://www.economist.com/finance-and-economics/2013/03/09/w...
Re:Have we been thinking about inflation all wrong? by friedturkey on Thursday February 10, 2022 @11:39PM (#30297052)
“Tanked” according to economists.

If the news weren’t telling us the economy tanked, nobody would be worried. Houses are affordable, jobs are everywhere, people aren’t going into lifelong debt because of medical issues.

In countries with inflation, the wealth divide is massive and growing. Wages might be up sometimes. But house prices and health insurance far outstrip any gains there. I guess milk is a little cheaper though. Maybe that tips the scales.

Re:Have we been thinking about inflation all wrong? by djohnston on Thursday February 10, 2022 @08:05PM (#30295401)
Real wages for Americans also haven't grown in decades: https://www.pewresearch.org/fact-tank/2018/08/07/for-most-us...

What's the harm?

Re:Have we been thinking about inflation all wrong? by colinmhayes on Thursday February 10, 2022 @08:08PM (#30295436)
Your chart shows that real wages are up 10% over the last 2 decades. Japan's are down. This doesn't even account for benefits, which have grown at an incredible rate due to health insurance costs. And that's not inflation, health care has gotten better, maybe unnecessarily so.
Re:Have we been thinking about inflation all wrong? by kriskrunch on Thursday February 10, 2022 @11:55PM (#30297168)
The total benefits chart they provide is more accurate than just looking at cash compensation.

Non-monetary compensation, like health insurance, still costs the business a lot of money.

Would you be in favor of getting rid of mandatory health insurance and passing that money to employees instead?

Re:Have we been thinking about inflation all wrong? by yed on Friday February 11, 2022 @01:39AM (#30297836)
The article you cited is from 2002. Japan has been mildly inflationary on average since the late 2000s. Unemployment spiked significantly during the deflationary period and has been dropping since.[1] You can see a similar pattern in the US deflationary periods during the 1800s. Every instance of deflation coincides with recessions or depressions and large scale job loss.

[1] https://www.macrotrends.net/countries/JPN/japan/unemployment...

Re:Have we been thinking about inflation all wrong? by dnautics on Friday February 11, 2022 @01:03AM (#30297634)
> There will not be many working people if the economy is deflationary.

The us had deflation between 1860 and 1910. I guess at the end of fifty years of that we had, like, no laborers, or something.

Please read a history book before provably wrong macro dogma rots your brain and all you do is spout nonsense that could actually harm people.

Re:Have we been thinking about inflation all wrong? by yed on Friday February 11, 2022 @01:50AM (#30297918)
That time period featured the longest depressionary period in US history with large spikes in unemployment [1]

[1] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Long_Depression#:~:text=In%2....

Re:Have we been thinking about inflation all wrong? by dnautics on Saturday February 12, 2022 @11:59PM (#30319357)
And yet the economy grew and the country rose out of the ashes of an incredibly destructive civil war and became a world power, and brought a LOT of people out of poverty. So, maybe don't sweat the little stuff?
Re:Have we been thinking about inflation all wrong? by megablast on Friday February 11, 2022 @02:36AM (#30298236)
Tell so Some to read a book because you can’t articulate the issue.
Re:Have we been thinking about inflation all wrong? by batshit_beaver on Friday February 11, 2022 @04:10AM (#30299090)
Deflation is horrific for any economy because it makes debt more expensive to service. Like it or not, modern economies are largely able to function thanks to prolific use of credit. If you think about it, it makes a ton of sense - if a rich person or company is sitting on a bunch of money, in an inflationary environment they are encouraged to invest this money in r&d, businesses (esp risky ones, like innovative startups), better employees or benefits for existing ones, etc. In a deflationary economy the best use of money is NO use of money. It's a death trap.
Re:Have we been thinking about inflation all wrong? by imtringued on Thursday February 10, 2022 @06:19PM (#30294184)
Imagine money capitalists abandoning physical capital and laying off workers because their grocery bill turns the yield on employment negative while the yield on money itself is positive.

You'd be foolish to sell products for lower prices, you don't get a discount on debt for example (negative interest rates).

Re:Have we been thinking about inflation all wrong? by int_19h on Friday February 11, 2022 @06:15PM (#30308160)
Do we actually have a growing economy in practice at this point? Or do we pretend that it's growing by inventing value out of thin air (as is the case with e.g. stocks)?
Re:Have we been thinking about inflation all wrong? by prichino on Thursday February 10, 2022 @05:47PM (#30293836)
This deflation is bad meme comes straight from the big international bankers of the early 20th century (JPM et al.). They cared mostly about liquidity and stable exchange rates. Unless you are one of them, please stop parroting "would be extremely bad". Would it be different from now? Probably. Extremely bad? For whom?
Re:Have we been thinking about inflation all wrong? by prewett on Thursday February 10, 2022 @06:25PM (#30294283)
People who have debt is the canonical set for whom deflation would be bad Including everyone who has a mortgage: your payments stay the same, but you earn less, so they take up a larger portion of your income. Naturally this can lead people who have debts that they could have serviced without deflation now cannot service them, so they go bankrupt. This also happens with any company that has debt (which is pretty much all of them).

The Great Depression is frequently seen as having been an ordinary depression made worse by a deflationary spiral. So for whom would it be bad for? Everyone.

Re:Have we been thinking about inflation all wrong? by NumberWangMan on Thursday February 10, 2022 @11:30PM (#30296982)
Ok, so full disclosure -- Austrian monetary theory makes sense to me in a way that no other form of macroeconomic theory has since. I'm open to being convinced that monetary inflation is a necessary or good thing, but I haven't yet.

Most of the arguments I've heard seem to take the form of -- we've been doing this thing (increasing the money supply) and if we stop, everyone who has debt is suddenly going to be in a lot of pain. I get that, and I agree, it makes sense.

Maybe you or someone can help me out here -- what I don't get is why we need to keep increasing the supply of money in the first place. Forgetting the situation that we're in at this point (where we don't want to stop increasing the money supply), what bad thing would happen if we had said from the start: here's the number of dollars, that's it? If we have more people, those dollars will get more valuable, because more people will want dollars. If we have more goods, those dollars will get more valuable, because they'll be scarcer relative to the goods.

I've heard and understand the argument that people don't like having their salaries cut, and that's something that would have to happen sometimes if money kept getting more valuable. But I don't see how that's really a big issue. Companies that paid their employees too much, and ran out of profits, would simply go out of business, no? The employees would then look for jobs elsewhere, and the market would be paying a bit lower. After a certain amount of time, I expect business owners and employees would get used to the reverse of the current situation -- you get a pay cut every year, unless you're increasing your value to the company, in which case you keep the same salary (or maybe get a small raise). It feels like the whole sticky wages argument is kind of based on claiming that the average citizen is like a child that thinks that water in a taller, thinner glass is more, which, while I'm sure is true for a few folks out there, doesn't seem to me like a good enough reason to do something as drastic as deciding that we need to continuously increase the money supply. People very clearly understand that with inflation, you may get a raise and still be poorer.

If "sticky wages" were the only consideration, maybe it would make sense to increase the money supply, sure. But I think the Austrian economists have a good argument that doing so adds an external factor into economic calculation that makes planning for the future harder -- you now not only have to try to predict how the prices of goods and services and so on will change due to supply and demand, you also have to factor into your prediction any distortions due to the central bank's changing monetary policy. Keeping the money supply static turns one big variable into a constant.

Re:Have we been thinking about inflation all wrong? by prewett on Friday February 11, 2022 @02:30PM (#30305966)
I think the usual argument for expanding the money supply is that you want to target for a small amount of inflation (I think the Fed targets 2%) to avoid deflation, since the deflationary spiral is a huge problem. Also, historically populations have been increasing, so you'd need more money just to keep the same amount per person. I'm not financier, but an (ideally) constant 2% inflation seems low enough to not be a problem for wages, but also predictable and plannable. Most investing calculations take into account inflation, and a constant 2% is a easy to include in the calculations.
Re:Have we been thinking about inflation all wrong? by dnautics on Thursday February 10, 2022 @06:43PM (#30294517)
"People who have debt" is dominated by financialized instruments: shorts, options, forex, margin trading, etc. all exist due to easy access to debt at low interest rates.
Re:Have we been thinking about inflation all wrong? by notahacker on Thursday February 10, 2022 @07:33PM (#30295104)
"People who have debt" is dominated, surprisingly enough, by people with debt. There are a lot more people with mortgages than people making leveraged trades.

For the rich loss of an opportunity to cheaply leverage their wealth is the gain of opportunities to lend their wealth at usurious rates instead, or to profit at the expense of the productive from simply selling off their assets and doing nothing with their cash but wait for the price to fall so they can buy stuff back for less.

For ordinary people whose net worth is mostly tied up in a property that's falling in value but not in mortgage repayments and whose wages are about to be reduced, the opportunities are less exciting. (Sucks for the rich trying to run companies rather than just letting their investment manager allocate their wealth to whatever grows it best in the current climate too)

Re:Have we been thinking about inflation all wrong? by dnautics on Friday February 11, 2022 @12:56AM (#30297601)
You're counting domination in number of people. I'm counting domination in number of dollars.
Re:Have we been thinking about inflation all wrong? by imtringued on Thursday February 10, 2022 @06:28PM (#30294329)
Deflation is bad enough that it collapsed every single implementation of the gold standard.