What Krugman is talking about is that cutting wages is extremely hard for employers to do. Nobody wants to take a paycut. So what employers do instead, being put in the situation of needing to cut payroll, is eliminate entire positions. Which on the whole is worse than a paycut because of the destabilizing effect to the individual and society. So a positive side effect of inflation (not the main effect, a side effect), is that in the absence of pay raises, low inflation creates a constant mild paycut unless there is specifically a pay raise. It makes the economy more resilient.
Horrifying.
https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Paradox_of_thrift
You get ahead by saving, but everyone can’t do that all together or the economy collapses.
Some inflation is needed; what we don't need is https://brrr.money/
You mean with deflation people will suddenly no longer want for more money? Sign us up!
Even if you have negative interest rates on money, people will flock to the next basic human need that has its own liquidity preference. Once the yield on land or property falls below liquidity preference people will hold onto empty property. The solution to the problem is to neutralize ground rent via land value taxation.
Thus you have both a money cycle and a real estate cycle.
No, they mean that people will want jobs and not find them. [addition: this is at least the orthodox view behind small inflation targets as policy, that on the whole it's the best trade off]
Either way, I'm not saying I believe the analysis, but when economists talk about the problems of deflation they aren't afraid that people will have "enough" money.
That's not so great for the people who need to borrow it, or want a job
If the books say it's wrong, maybe it's time they get updated.
[1] https://www5.cao.go.jp/zenbun/wp-e/wp-je03/03-00102.html
Can be vulgar to point this out, but the homelessness in America is a policy choice. If America had the same economy as Japan, we would still have lots of homelessness, because that is how we choose to organize our society.
This sounds facile, but then again consider how we choose to organize our healthcare system.
If the news weren’t telling us the economy tanked, nobody would be worried. Houses are affordable, jobs are everywhere, people aren’t going into lifelong debt because of medical issues.
In countries with inflation, the wealth divide is massive and growing. Wages might be up sometimes. But house prices and health insurance far outstrip any gains there. I guess milk is a little cheaper though. Maybe that tips the scales.
What's the harm?
Non-monetary compensation, like health insurance, still costs the business a lot of money.
Would you be in favor of getting rid of mandatory health insurance and passing that money to employees instead?
[1] https://www.macrotrends.net/countries/JPN/japan/unemployment...
The us had deflation between 1860 and 1910. I guess at the end of fifty years of that we had, like, no laborers, or something.
Please read a history book before provably wrong macro dogma rots your brain and all you do is spout nonsense that could actually harm people.
[1] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Long_Depression#:~:text=In%2....
You'd be foolish to sell products for lower prices, you don't get a discount on debt for example (negative interest rates).
The Great Depression is frequently seen as having been an ordinary depression made worse by a deflationary spiral. So for whom would it be bad for? Everyone.
Most of the arguments I've heard seem to take the form of -- we've been doing this thing (increasing the money supply) and if we stop, everyone who has debt is suddenly going to be in a lot of pain. I get that, and I agree, it makes sense.
Maybe you or someone can help me out here -- what I don't get is why we need to keep increasing the supply of money in the first place. Forgetting the situation that we're in at this point (where we don't want to stop increasing the money supply), what bad thing would happen if we had said from the start: here's the number of dollars, that's it? If we have more people, those dollars will get more valuable, because more people will want dollars. If we have more goods, those dollars will get more valuable, because they'll be scarcer relative to the goods.
I've heard and understand the argument that people don't like having their salaries cut, and that's something that would have to happen sometimes if money kept getting more valuable. But I don't see how that's really a big issue. Companies that paid their employees too much, and ran out of profits, would simply go out of business, no? The employees would then look for jobs elsewhere, and the market would be paying a bit lower. After a certain amount of time, I expect business owners and employees would get used to the reverse of the current situation -- you get a pay cut every year, unless you're increasing your value to the company, in which case you keep the same salary (or maybe get a small raise). It feels like the whole sticky wages argument is kind of based on claiming that the average citizen is like a child that thinks that water in a taller, thinner glass is more, which, while I'm sure is true for a few folks out there, doesn't seem to me like a good enough reason to do something as drastic as deciding that we need to continuously increase the money supply. People very clearly understand that with inflation, you may get a raise and still be poorer.
If "sticky wages" were the only consideration, maybe it would make sense to increase the money supply, sure. But I think the Austrian economists have a good argument that doing so adds an external factor into economic calculation that makes planning for the future harder -- you now not only have to try to predict how the prices of goods and services and so on will change due to supply and demand, you also have to factor into your prediction any distortions due to the central bank's changing monetary policy. Keeping the money supply static turns one big variable into a constant.
For the rich loss of an opportunity to cheaply leverage their wealth is the gain of opportunities to lend their wealth at usurious rates instead, or to profit at the expense of the productive from simply selling off their assets and doing nothing with their cash but wait for the price to fall so they can buy stuff back for less.
For ordinary people whose net worth is mostly tied up in a property that's falling in value but not in mortgage repayments and whose wages are about to be reduced, the opportunities are less exciting. (Sucks for the rich trying to run companies rather than just letting their investment manager allocate their wealth to whatever grows it best in the current climate too)
If interest rates rise, then you have one or two problems.
If your loan isn't at a fixed rate, then you'd better hope you can still afford your mortgage. Say you paid a 20% downpayment on a home worth $375K. A $300K note at 3% is a $1,250 per month expense, but at 8% it's $2,200 a month. People forget, but mortgage rates were 8% as recently as 2000.
Even if your rate is fixed, new buyers have affordability problems due to the same phenomenon, which hits valuations. If you can afford $1,250 a month, maybe you can afford $1,500 after some inflation pads out your pay check.
But, with rates at 8%, that's only a $200K mortgage, so maybe a $375K home is only a $250K home in the new rate environment and you're in negative equity all of a sudden. If you need to sell, then you're losing the initial downpayment and you may still end up owing the bank. If you can't cover it, say goodbye to your creditworthiness.
1) <10% of the US mortgage market is ARMs.
2) Treasury rates are still super low, even with high CPI inflation. It's not at all obvious interest rates will go up by much even with sustained 5-10% inflation, since society's ratio of capital to productivity is at an unprecedented level.
Except for the fact that they're getting a pay cut year after year. This is why the general public gets so mad about inflation. Like another commenter mentioned, inflation screws over anyone who works for a wage.
It can, but inflation affects current assets and liabilities immediately and only depresses wages over time. If inflation was 7% over the course of the year, you now owe 7% less on your outstanding loans (in real terms), while any real wage decrease would be amortized over the course of the year. Assuming inflation occurred at a fixed rate and that your nominal wage didn't change at all, you only actually lost 3.5% of your real wage.
You're also now a worker in a "hot" economy, so you can look for a new job with a higher wage (or ask for a raise, citing inflation) and limit your real wage loss to 3.5% of one year's earnings.
> This is why the general public gets so mad about inflation.
I know this is uncharitable of me, but I think the general public gets so mad about inflation because people with large capital holdings try to get the public riled up, and then the average person just doesn't sit down and do the math for their own situation. The median member of the general public is a debtor, not a creditor, so modest inflation (or high inflation over a short period) is usually good for them, financially speaking. Deflation, on the other hand, could destroy them.
For the bottom and top of the economic ladder, though, inflation is usually a bad deal, since minimum wages and safety net programs aren't normally indexed to inflation, and inflation erodes the value of savings and other current assets. Elevating the middle class at the expense of the poor is morally questionable, even if the rich get soaked along the way, too.
Suppose you are poor and are spending 90% of your income on day-to-day expenses. We get 5% inflation and now you are spending 94% of your income on day-to-day expenses. That is a 40% loss of survival margin. Suppose you're really poor, and you are spending 96% of your income on day-to-day expenses. Under 5% inflation, you are now underwater.
Suppose you are rich and are spending 20% of your income on day-to-day expenses. With 5% inflation, you are lose ~8% of your survival margin.
> The median member of the general public is a debtor
Yes, but the poorest don't even have access to credit at all. The guy hanging out in the TL is not in debt. Plus median member of society isn't getting an ultra-low interest rate that is covered by inflation. That is the domain of financialized assets (like forex etc) which mostly benefits the wealthy
> so modest inflation (or high inflation over a short period) is usually good for them
IF their wages catch up. If their wages don't, do the math.
> Deflation, on the other hand, could destroy them.
Why? Because they will have a wider margin of survival? Do the math.
> IF their wages catch up. If their wages don't, do the math.
It depends on your situation. If you have $20K in remaining student debt and make $40K a year, then, yes, assuming a fixed wage, any real decrease in the value of your outstanding debt would be wiped out by the decrease in your real wages over that time period. But if you owe $300K on a house and make $60K a year, the math is different.
> Why? Because they will have a wider margin of survival? Do the math.
No, because their debts will become larger in real terms. It sounds like you're fixated on the case of someone with no debt and very low wages. That's an important case, but it's not the only one.
Let's think for a second here. You don't think that's a particularly important case? There is a reason why being indebted is viewed with a tinge of moral disgust -- debthood makes it so that when you fail, someone else also is at a risk of failure. Now, there is a sense in which having some of this is good because it creates shared social interest; but goosing it and making that risk systemic pushes it beyond the organically healthy state for the economy. A person who has no debt (low wages or otherwise) is, actually, a force for stability in the economy. Not of course, the type of stability that the fed cares about.
At worst, anyone who works for a fixed wage (and even then, the demand dynamics that create a fixed wage with inflation mean instead people just lose their jobs without inflation, because of the stickiness of nominal wages.)
This includes anyone who works for minimum wage (assuming it's not indexed to inflation), and they are not likely to be able to handle a cut in real pay as easily as, say, middle class homeowners.
No, it doesn't, unless they have a contract fixing their pay at minimum wage; being currently paid minimum wage doesn't mean you don't get raises.
Does deflation mean suddenly that once people "lose their jobs" they will never find another one?
Hell, no.
You have exceeded the wisdom normally allocated to economists.
Do not pass GO, do not collect $200.
More than ever it seems there should be a prize for this.
It didn't used to be that way.
Fewer and fewer workers will be able to pass GO and there will not be as many $200 bills in your pocket even if there are more in "circulation" overall.
Much less likely to afford any houses on your property, or very much property at all.
Odds are not looking good when there are so many decision makers and advisers who don't appear to have been paying any attention at all during the Nixon Recession and the still-lingering incomplete recovery in the USA.
what the hell? Inflation exists as a policy to stiff wage-earners. This is arguably more likely to go exactly the other way than the author expects. Take it from a nobel laureate:
https://krugman.blogs.nytimes.com/2010/02/13/the-case-for-hi...
> it’s really, really hard to cut nominal wages. Yet when you have very low inflation, getting relative wages right would require that a significant number of workers take wage cuts [...but when you have inflation, their wages get cut without anyone being the wiser!!].