I think it's selling via ebay and not a regular domain/site selling marketplace as it would be sold for much less.
I don't see how it's worth nearly 10,000 when before Facebook ate their lunch it made $50 a month.
You might not see the value, but someone else will. Value is always determined by the market.
I'm sure that's part of it, but I know he put an unreasonable amount of time polishing each pixel of the interface for months before releasing it.
Edit: he says 400+ hours which is $25/hour for $10,000.
Or is this inexpensive?
I'm asking because we were thinking of selling one of our assets too and wanted to know what would be considered a fair price for a Rails app (which was once live and is now shuttered).