> so no, plus or minus a year does not matter even for a 3 year old kid.
Anyone who has kids is going to disagree with this.
that would require that all children develop at exactly the same pace which is simply not happening like that.
see my other comment.
i do agree with the socialization.
the age difference matters for the development of each individual kid, but it us rather useless as a measure to compare the development of different kids.
in the first few years, the development of each kid is so different that no two kids of the same age are alike. you can have a four year old with the maturity of a two year old, or a three year old going on five. a wider age range allows children with the same level of maturity to play together regardless of the individual age.
also younger kids learn from older kids with allows them to mature faster.
this difference in maturity continues, but as the kids are older it just matters less, because the material being taught in school does not depend on the level of maturity but only on what they already learned regardless of how mature they are.
At the moment I have a kid who is asking me about chemistry, and I can't just wait 5 years for him to get to that age where they teach people specifically chemistry (as opposed to general science). There's no reason I can't tell a 9 year old about valencies and that kind of thing, so why does school wait with it?
Not enough staff (teachers) to differentiate instruction that finely.
A lot of stuff sounds like a great idea until you're looking at a classroom of 18-28 students and everyone else around you is trying to deal with a similar-sized class of their own. Special-ed kids might get help down to having one entire adult just to help and follow around that single kid all day (!) but there's no stomach for spending that kind of money to help kids who are ahead, or to reduce class sizes so regular classroom teachers can realistically do a better job of differentiation. Best most places get are very-part-time gifted programs.