Do you think there is an argument that I should not be responsible?
If “random” is too independent, or you want it to be systematic, we could do something else:
* the person with the highest “red hat” score according to a 20 year old copy of opencv
Or we could do something modern and “AI” and give it a completely random neural net that’s super deep and has three outputs: angle, pitch, and whether to pull the trigger.
Or we could go all out and just replace this hypothetical machine that acts like an independent person with the next best thing: a regular human.
If a government, or a terrorist group, gives a group of people (or soldiers) a bunch of weapons and drops them off in a city, and they start shooting, do you think that the government would be responsible?
This discussion mistakes existing policies as some objective base, but it’s the other way round.
Those caveats apply to machines as well: if I tell a toaster to kill someone, and then the toaster electrocutes them, I would not be guilty.