News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Did HAL Commit Murder? by olliej on Wednesday February 09, 2022 @11:08PM (#30282361)
If I build a gun mount, that uses a basic computer vision algorithm to identify people out a window. It then randomly select a target - “true” random so no claims I set a seed - and then shoots them.

Do you think there is an argument that I should not be responsible?

If “random” is too independent, or you want it to be systematic, we could do something else:

* the person with the highest “red hat” score according to a 20 year old copy of opencv

Or we could do something modern and “AI” and give it a completely random neural net that’s super deep and has three outputs: angle, pitch, and whether to pull the trigger.

Or we could go all out and just replace this hypothetical machine that acts like an independent person with the next best thing: a regular human.

If a government, or a terrorist group, gives a group of people (or soldiers) a bunch of weapons and drops them off in a city, and they start shooting, do you think that the government would be responsible?

Re:Did HAL Commit Murder? by wruza on Thursday February 10, 2022 @05:22AM (#30284399)
That’s easy. Your intent was for it to maybe shoot someone, and that is a criminal intent. If you had no such intent, it’s either accidental murder or no guilt (e.g. you built a robot that takes a heap of non-classy trash and throws it into a grinder; an intruder was grabbed by it accidentally because they weren’t well-dressed).

This discussion mistakes existing policies as some objective base, but it’s the other way round.