Re:Did HAL Commit Murder?
by wongarsu on Wednesday February 09, 2022 @07:35PM
(#30280899)
That "judgement" is a design decision. A ML algorithm misidentifying a person as a car door isn't that different from an elevator cable snapping. That happens more or less randomly too. It could be bad design, bad maintenance (e.g. real world data drifted away from training data but no retraining took place), or just bad luck (an element in almost any accident). Depending on the fault someone or nobody is at fault. And even if nobody is at fault we can still decide to advance the state of the art, and that in the future no single elevator cable snapping should cause more than a minor inconvenience (due to multiple cables, breaks etc).
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Eh, this.
It all depends on if 'robots', however one defines them are 'conscious', however one defines that.
But until that gets settled, it's always a human pulling the trigger.
No difference from when someone's pitbull chews off someone else's head.
It might be the owner's fault, it might be not. But the dog in question can not be blamed.