Re:Did HAL Commit Murder?
by mongol on Wednesday February 09, 2022 @07:22PM
(#30280811)
I think we should treat it as if an animal killed a human. We don't call that murder. If a dog kills a human, I think it is usually put down? Not sure if a whale does it. So it may depend. But in any case, murder I think is reserved for conscious killing of a human by another human.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Did HAL Commit Murder?
by oceanplexian on Wednesday February 09, 2022 @07:48PM
(#30281018)
I'm not sure about an animal killing a human, but certain animals, like primates, definitely commit murder (i.e. the conscious killing of another member of its tribe for territory, social status, or whatever).
Everything living kills everything in sight for resources. From viruses to civilizations. To some extent this can be moderated, or for a time some optimizations might result in even less destruction, but this is the way this world is.
Killing is rational in a sense - for some subset of purposes, in context of some subset of environmental pressures, both of which change constantly, and often faster than adaptation to kill does.
Accept this. It will not ever change.
I agree they do but I don't think the word murder is applicable
If we could "fix" the animal, rather than killing it, wouldn't we?
People are self-reproducing robots that are made of meat. Robots made of meat are very hard to fix.