That said, feel free to substitute Bartz with anyone else you consider an incompetent CEO. Doesn't affect my post much. My curiosity is about what the hiring of CEOs at great cost then firing them (also at great cost), and replacing them with even more dubious people, reveals about the system and the forces at play.
For eg: if Apotheker was let go at SAP then what made him a good choice for HP?If he couldn't be an effective CEO at SAP which is an enterprise software company, then how is he a good choice for turning HP into an enterprise software company? I just don't get the logic there.
Why aren't the people who made that decision now being fired along with Apotheker? How are such decisions taken, and more importantly how do such poor decisions survive the scrutiny of investors etc?
I don't have any knowledge of Bartz's experience at Yahoo, but I can definitely say that it's very hard to make systemic changes when you're not given the tools to do so.