Theoretically, some companies are better able to keep bench warmers happy waiting for their time to shine. Obviously Apple has done a very good job at maintaining their top people. I think Microsoft has done a decent job as well, though loosing Ray Ozzie I think was a tough one.
Of course, not everybody has the capability of being a great CEO either. Particularly of coming in and operating somebody else's company. So some of the people who are sitting on the bench hoping to get called up have unrealistic expectations.
Bartz was far from genius, but nobody else has come up with a brilliant strategy for the troubled Yahoo! either. Apotheker had a strategy in mind, did a VERY poor job of selling it to the public. We'll never know if it was a flawed strategy or not, though it definitely seems so at this point. I think he is partially being made a scapegoat here as well. The board was sold on the vision and gave him the go-ahead, and now that Wall Street is showing its doubts, the board is getting rid of the CEO. The board needs to take some responsibility here, and from the history, it is obvious the HP board has some serious issues.
HP is in a slightly better position that Yahoo!, but they desperately need to find their next growth opportunity. They thought they'd rule the world with WebOS, but their execution was so flawed that they blew it. I have a touchpad (got the $99 deal), and you'd have to be incompetent to think that device could compete with the iPad at the same price.
So the problem is two-fold. First off, there doesn't seem to be capable internal leadership to pull from, and external expectations are high for a new leader who will drive change similar to the return of Steve Jobs to Apple. But there was nothing to loose at Apple. The company was almost gone if I recall correctly. Either it would completely fail anyway, or it could come back a success. HP doesn't have the luxury of throwing everything out. They are a successful company, but investors want to see new growth in a very competitive market (both hardware and IT services). So the job isn't a simple one.
Do these CEOs earn their huge salaries? I don't think so. I'd like to see more CEOs put their money where their mouth is and take the majority of their salary in options, and I think the board should require that.
Please don't refer to yourself as 'a dumb developer'. I think your question is completely valid, and I wish I could provide a better answer. Hopefully this gets you part way there.
That simply incentivizes CEOs to pump stock prices and not create long term shareholder value; moreover, the market can be unpredictable and if the stock price gets manipulated by dear Mr. Bernanke, why should the CEO be punished?
That said, feel free to substitute Bartz with anyone else you consider an incompetent CEO. Doesn't affect my post much. My curiosity is about what the hiring of CEOs at great cost then firing them (also at great cost), and replacing them with even more dubious people, reveals about the system and the forces at play.
For eg: if Apotheker was let go at SAP then what made him a good choice for HP?If he couldn't be an effective CEO at SAP which is an enterprise software company, then how is he a good choice for turning HP into an enterprise software company? I just don't get the logic there.
Why aren't the people who made that decision now being fired along with Apotheker? How are such decisions taken, and more importantly how do such poor decisions survive the scrutiny of investors etc?
I don't have any knowledge of Bartz's experience at Yahoo, but I can definitely say that it's very hard to make systemic changes when you're not given the tools to do so.
> ... what's with random incompetents ...?
I think at least part of the answer is that research shows groups are, in some instances, shown to make worse decisions than individuals. In groups, individual biases are magnified, and the group process introduces a whole host of potential decision flaws (e.g., information hiding, social loafing) while not consistently compensating for individual decision weaknesses. Groups often make less optimal decisions than individuals, especially in subjective cases.Is that true? here's your chance to get a data point.
Show me which people on HP's board hold MBA's
Andreesen - no mba (http://www.nndb.com/people/442/000022376/)
Apotheker - no mba (http://www.nndb.com/people/417/000253655/)
Babbio - MBA (http://www.nndb.com/people/159/000124784/)
Baldauf - masters in econ (http://www.nndb.com/people/177/000124802/)
Banerji - MBA (http://bx.businessweek.com/kellogg-school-of-management/shum...)
Gupta - MBA (http://www.nndb.com/people/889/000168385/)
Hammergreen - MBA (http://www.nndb.com/people/169/000124794/)
Lane - No MBA (http://www.be.wvu.edu/hall_fame/lane.htm)
Livermore - MBA (http://www.nndb.com/people/763/000128379/)
Renier - MBA (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gary_M._Reiner)
Russo - No MBA (http://www.nndb.com/people/753/000126375/)
Senequier - No MBA (http://www.hp.com/hpinfo/newsroom/press/2011/110120xa.html)
Thompson - MBA (http://www.nndb.com/people/187/000118830/)
Whitman - MBA (http://www.hp.com/hpinfo/newsroom/press/2011/110120xa.html)
so, eight of fourteen.
There is no rule that an MBA can't 'get' technology.
It isn't about building technology either, it's about proving something people need and want, and getting them to pay for it. Technology is only a component of that.
HP sells more stuff that people want than almost any other company (printers, desktops, etc.). Yet they're failing.
Successful technology companies (Apple, Amazon, Facebook, Google, Dell, Oracle) have business and technology interwoven like yin and yang. Business fuels technology, technology drives the business. You get there by building your business and your technology hand in hand. If you stop building, you'll fail on both. That's what you don't learn in an MBA.
I read the comment as "an MBA is their only qualification", not "MBAs are inherently incapable of understanding technology".
On that note aren't the legions of VPs that infest such companies supposed to be a "bench" for selecting a CEO from in an emergency? If you have half a hundred (or more!) VPs and none of them can step up and be CEO in troubled times, why pay them millions of dollars?
Also, why exactly Meg Whitman? Just because she happened to be available and doesn't have another job? (Isn't that telling about her desirability as a CEO?) How long before they look far yet another saviour on a white horse?