News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Tesla FSD Beta Lunges Toward Bicyclist by colinmhayes on Tuesday February 08, 2022 @07:57PM (#30267181)
40,000 people die in car crashes every year in the US alone. If the lord farquad approach brings widespread autonomous car adoption which decreases that number substantially even a month sooner it's the right thing to do. Many of us are already dying.
Re:Tesla FSD Beta Lunges Toward Bicyclist by lolinder on Tuesday February 08, 2022 @09:45PM (#30268077)
The ethical problem with Lord Farquad's line isn't that "some of you will die". It's where he says "but that is a sacrifice that I am willing to make".

Tesla's self-driving beta is unethical because most of the participants in this "experiment" did not opt in. Most of the people killed by Tesla won't be their customers. It will be the cyclist or the pedestrian that gets killed because the driver thought "full self driving" meant the car was fully driving itself. They didn't even know they were part of an experiment that day, yet they were the sacrifice that Tesla was willing to make.

Re:Tesla FSD Beta Lunges Toward Bicyclist by colinmhayes on Tuesday February 08, 2022 @09:46PM (#30268088)
I'm sympathetic to that, but in the end don't trust people to make decisions that are in everyone's best interest. Americans especially have proven again and again that they are too blinded by the false ideals of rugged individualism to see what's right. What's unethical is allowing tens of thousands of people to die every year because some people have a (understandably)misguided view of right and wrong.
Re:Tesla FSD Beta Lunges Toward Bicyclist by lolinder on Tuesday February 08, 2022 @09:56PM (#30268152)
Can you clarify how those of us calling for the government to prevent Tesla from involuntarily enlisting drivers into their beta test are "blinded by the false ideals of rugged individualism"?

Just so we're talking about the same term:

> The belief that all individuals, or nearly all individuals, can succeed on their own and that government help for people should be minimal.

https://www.dictionary.com/browse/rugged-individualism

Typically, the rugged individualists are the ones who say that the government should stay out of all this and people can take care of themselves. Basically the opposite of what I'm saying.

Re:Tesla FSD Beta Lunges Toward Bicyclist by colinmhayes on Tuesday February 08, 2022 @10:03PM (#30268215)
Sometimes sacrifices need to be made so that we can all prosper. The American mythos is unfortunately allergic to this truism. The idea that society needs permission to better itself is misguided. Same reason America is lagging in vaccination rate even though we are the society with most access. I'd be extremely happy if people could come to the correct conclusion themselves. I don't want to allow their failure to harm the rest of us.
Re:Tesla FSD Beta Lunges Toward Bicyclist by lolinder on Tuesday February 08, 2022 @10:14PM (#30268302)
What you're arguing against, then, isn't "rugged individualism", it's "the sanctity of human life". The difference is that the one says "individual human freedom is paramount" while the other says "each individual human life is paramount".

Neither ethic would approve of systematically killing people for the greater good, but they're two very different ethics in most other respects. For example, I could arrive at "vaccination should be mandated" from a sanctity-of-life perspective, but I never could from a rugged individualism perspective.

Re:Tesla FSD Beta Lunges Toward Bicyclist by colinmhayes on Tuesday February 08, 2022 @10:22PM (#30268360)
Not quite. My thesis is "The idea that society needs permission to better itself is misguided." It's not limited to human life at all. It's about rejecting your thesis of "Tesla's self-driving beta is unethical because most of the participants in this "experiment" did not opt in." We don't need permission to save lives.
Re:Tesla FSD Beta Lunges Toward Bicyclist by lolinder on Tuesday February 08, 2022 @10:41PM (#30268494)
And your calculus isn't altered at all by the fact that Tesla isn't "society", it's a single for-profit corporation?
Re:Tesla FSD Beta Lunges Toward Bicyclist by colinmhayes on Tuesday February 08, 2022 @11:35PM (#30268862)
Of course, but that doesn't change the fact that the software would help everyone, even if Tesla profited.
Re:Tesla FSD Beta Lunges Toward Bicyclist by ModernMech on Tuesday February 08, 2022 @08:15PM (#30267327)
Sorry, but I don't see how a company that...

- Beta tests critical software in the public which has lead to actual customer deaths;

- Refuses to follow industry best practices when it comes to safety sensors;

- Refuses to seriously investigate safety incidents and implement technological and cultural fixes to prevent them from happening in the future;

...will lead us into a utopia of automotive safety. At best what they're liable to do is create a climate where mega corporations feel free to use public spaces as their own personal laboratories, because the ends justify the means after all (don't pay attention to the decapitations, we're doing it for the safety of us all). We will all pay the price for that.

Re:Tesla FSD Beta Lunges Toward Bicyclist by randoglando on Tuesday February 08, 2022 @08:28PM (#30267450)
Don't forget to add

- willfully misrepresents data to imply a better safety record than they actually do have

https://twitter.com/Tweetermeyer/status/1488673180403191808 (I've posted this elsewhere on this thread too)

Re:Tesla FSD Beta Lunges Toward Bicyclist by colinmhayes on Tuesday February 08, 2022 @08:21PM (#30267382)
I agree it would require an incredible amount of evidence to convince me that this actually would speed up the development of self driving. Just saying that I'm not opposed to the lord farquad method if it helps.
Re:Tesla FSD Beta Lunges Toward Bicyclist by 46756e on Tuesday February 08, 2022 @08:12PM (#30267298)
Many people die of HIV, it’s a plague on society. If we just killed everyone who has it, it would be gone.

Many of “us” are already dying, and it saves lives in the future.

/s