Re:Tesla FSD Beta Lunges Toward Bicyclist
by colinmhayes on Tuesday February 08, 2022 @10:03PM
(#30268215)
Sometimes sacrifices need to be made so that we can all prosper. The American mythos is unfortunately allergic to this truism. The idea that society needs permission to better itself is misguided. Same reason America is lagging in vaccination rate even though we are the society with most access. I'd be extremely happy if people could come to the correct conclusion themselves. I don't want to allow their failure to harm the rest of us.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Tesla FSD Beta Lunges Toward Bicyclist
by lolinder on Tuesday February 08, 2022 @10:14PM
(#30268302)
What you're arguing against, then, isn't "rugged individualism", it's "the sanctity of human life". The difference is that the one says "individual human freedom is paramount" while the other says "each individual human life is paramount".
Neither ethic would approve of systematically killing people for the greater good, but they're two very different ethics in most other respects. For example, I could arrive at "vaccination should be mandated" from a sanctity-of-life perspective, but I never could from a rugged individualism perspective.
Re:Tesla FSD Beta Lunges Toward Bicyclist
by colinmhayes on Tuesday February 08, 2022 @10:22PM
(#30268360)
Not quite. My thesis is "The idea that society needs permission to better itself is misguided." It's not limited to human life at all. It's about rejecting your thesis of "Tesla's self-driving beta is unethical because most of the participants in this "experiment" did not opt in." We don't need permission to save lives.
Re:Tesla FSD Beta Lunges Toward Bicyclist
by lolinder on Tuesday February 08, 2022 @10:41PM
(#30268494)
And your calculus isn't altered at all by the fact that Tesla isn't "society", it's a single for-profit corporation?
Re:Tesla FSD Beta Lunges Toward Bicyclist
by colinmhayes on Tuesday February 08, 2022 @11:35PM
(#30268862)
Of course, but that doesn't change the fact that the software would help everyone, even if Tesla profited.