Re:Raid-Z Expansion Feature for ZFS Goes Live
by namibj on Tuesday February 08, 2022 @06:50PM
(#30266559)
But that's more because no one dared to try and actually fix Btrfs parity raid.
Misaligned incentives causing lack of funding for something as flexible and generally resilient as Btrfs.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Raid-Z Expansion Feature for ZFS Goes Live
by guipsp on Tuesday February 08, 2022 @07:09PM
(#30266701)
My data doesn't really care if the reason for brtfs losing data is lack of funding
Re:Raid-Z Expansion Feature for ZFS Goes Live
by matheusmoreira on Tuesday February 08, 2022 @10:58PM
(#30268614)
Can you elaborate on this? I see NAS companies like Synology using btrfs in their products. I don't understand why btrfs RAID 5/6 is still not stable.
Re:Raid-Z Expansion Feature for ZFS Goes Live
by genghizkhan on Tuesday February 08, 2022 @11:57PM
(#30269011)
Synology deploys btrfs on top of md-raid. They do not trust btrfs's raid layer.
Re:Raid-Z Expansion Feature for ZFS Goes Live
by namibj on Wednesday February 09, 2022 @12:35AM
(#30269267)
Because there are some write holes around iirc power failures and, more importantly, restore basically doesn't work (the code just doesn't exist in a working variant).
This isn't easy code to write, and it's Linux-Kernel-C, far from "comfy" code to write. I assume it's that kind of effect that continues to keep all competent people from fixing Btrfs's RAID 5/6 code. (If I could gather the motivation, I could probably do it, but that's far from fun to do and I'm already dire for motivation-to-code... it needs to be someone who likes that work, ideally sponsored so they don't loose money from working on that project.)