Re:Show HN: An AI program to check videos for NSFW content
by hotpotamus on Tuesday February 08, 2022 @08:37AM
(#30258191)
Indeed, I worked in a photo lab back in the day when NSFW images were still on film and we had to think about these kinds of rules, but basically anything was permitted for medical purposes - I once scanned slides for a doctor doing a lecture on pelvic inflammatory disease. She did not say what they were when dropping them off and amusedly asked about it when she picked them up. But it was the very opposite of sexy and quite clearly for genuine medical purposes.
This reminds me of a question I've long had about this sort of thing you reminded me of - in the US at least, we seem to draw the line for showing off breasts at the nipple, but only female nipples. Setting aside any merit or logic to that, can AI actually determine female vs male nipples? I assume not through the nipple itself, but the breast it's attached to or the face of the person?
Re:Show HN: An AI program to check videos for NSFW content
by hutzlibu on Tuesday February 08, 2022 @08:48AM
(#30258293)
"can AI actually determine female vs male nipples?"
Not with 100% accuracy, but on average yes, as a female breast is indeed quite different from a male breast. Shape, hair, size, ...
But there are of course exeptions. Muscular women, with small breast who did not breast feed yet, are probably quite hard to detect.
I would suppose that depends on the workplace and area(and time) where you live. It is definitely "somewhat" sexualised content in my opinion (close up of a womens body stripping down), even though there is no nipple to see. But sure, lots of normal advertisement sells more sex. So is the red line, when a nipple is shown? That would classify biological and medical content as nsfw.
My point is, human morals are very different. Humans fight about, what content is NSFW. A computer model can never be "acurate" in that sense.