I don't know where things "go", but I know where I last put them!
> if they’re the only ones using that workspace then it doesn’t really matter
Yup, both methods have the exact same weakness - someone else moving something I need.
Of course, as you imply, everything should have it's place in a shared workspace.
I've pretty much always relied on full searches of my entire surroundings, or very long term plans with labels and everything, since remembering a new location takes active effort or weeks of time, I don't just see things and passively remember where they were.
The desktop completely rearranging itself randomly doesn't even bother me, as long as I can quickly scan the task bar, since I basically never use Windows any way other than maximized.
You’ll often find that some who work in organised chaos still know exactly where everything is.
Is their organisation worse than those who keep things tidy? From an outsiders perspective it might seem that way. But if they’re the only ones using that workspace then it doesn’t really matter.
For some people, remembering where stuff is creates no extra cognitive overhead. For others, it’s like trying to access their computer while it’s covered in bubble wrap.