News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Google's Competitors Falsely Claim Google Dominates Becau... by mbesto on Thursday September 22, 2011 @05:32AM (#3025448)
Not aggressive at all. Yes, I've started two actually (completely boot strapped mind you). One was a creative agency (huge market saturation) and one that is a niche social network (another huge market saturation). I haven't technically started my third, but I am essentially responsible for growing a consulting practice right now.

>There is a reason most YC companies are trying to disrupt markets rather than compete head-on-head with existing business models.

I also think the reason most YC companies disrupt markets is because they are generally younger and less experienced entrepreneurs who have little to no market network. And in many cases either sell B2C or sell to B2B to the same tech companies that sell B2C. Many small businesses (the one I worked for currently) are created by individuals who have massively entrenched business networks. The practice I currently am growing has gone from 3 people to 10 by the end of the year. We compete with IBM, Accenture, Capgemini, etc. in the professional services industry. We do ZERO SEO or generate word-of-mouth. Are we disrupting a massive services industry market? Yes.

Honestly I feel like you've gone off on a little tangent here about my original point. While you've raised many wonderful and valid points (that I don't have the time to give my answer) it doesn't negate the fact that being first really doesn't mean anything other than "I learned a lot". Ideally I want to be third or fourth, so that way I can just take all of the painful (read->expensive) learning experiences that the first guy did when trying to capture his product/market fit and just run off from there.

Categorically, let's look at some successful companies/products - Apple's iPad/iPod/iPhone - not first / Google's search - not first / Ford's Automobile - not first / Reddit - not first / Microsoft Office - not first

Being first as a qualifier for success is a myth. Doing it RIGHT first will make you successful.

Re:Google's Competitors Falsely Claim Google Dominates Becau... by Hyena on Thursday September 22, 2011 @10:43AM (#3026220)
Your experience is much more representative and more likely to succeed. Noting that there is a shortage of Italian restaurants or exploitation of a scaling problem in advertising and so on is how most successful companies get built.

More deeply, it is a strange incoherence: "only disruptive companies are successful" leaves you wondering what there'd be to dirupt, since everyone else went bankrupt years ago.

Re:Google's Competitors Falsely Claim Google Dominates Becau... by trevelyan on Thursday September 22, 2011 @05:06PM (#3027797)
I'm not saying only disruptive companies are successful. Nor am I saying first movers are. I'm saying that it is more difficult to be disruptive if you aren't among the first solving a particular problem.
Re:Google's Competitors Falsely Claim Google Dominates Becau... by mbesto on Friday September 23, 2011 @04:13AM (#3029245)
When then you're technically no longer disruptive because the market is already established.

http://steveblank.com/2009/09/10/customer-development-manife...