News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Cancer Moonshot initiative restarted by NIH by bradleyjg on Sunday February 06, 2022 @07:15PM (#30238541)
It’s a worthy goal but I doubt the government could move the needle with any amount of money, much less with just $1.8 billion.

Culture is incredibly difficult to intentionally shift. People actively resist when they feel they are being manipulated even if it is supposed to be for their own good.

Re:Cancer Moonshot initiative restarted by NIH by wolverine876 on Sunday February 06, 2022 @08:57PM (#30239223)
> Culture is incredibly difficult to intentionally shift.

Look how much culture has changed in the last few years, in a direction that closely matches the intentions of some powerful people.

Look at changes around public health, smoking for example.

> People actively resist when they feel they are being manipulated

The only way to change things is to manipulate people?

> It’s a worthy goal but I doubt the government could move the needle with any amount of money

If you are talking about promoting exercise, here I agree: More money isn't always needed.

Re:Cancer Moonshot initiative restarted by NIH by WaitWaitWha on Sunday February 06, 2022 @07:32PM (#30238655)
I sedulously disagree.

https://www.globalissues.org/article/532/media-manipulation

https://spinwatch.org/

(note: this is not an endorsement of these sites, but took me 30 seconds to locate online, and verify at least glancingly.)

Re:Cancer Moonshot initiative restarted by NIH by deeviant on Sunday February 06, 2022 @08:13PM (#30238944)
Getting people to hate other people, that's easy, the us vs them is baked into human psychology.

Getting people to eat less, not so much.

Re:Cancer Moonshot initiative restarted by NIH by ethanbond on Sunday February 06, 2022 @08:37PM (#30239070)
People wanting to feel good, be more sexually appealing, sleep better, and so on? The desire to achieve higher fitness is pretty ubiquitous, but that is always up against how hard it is to achieve. There are certainly things an org like NIH could do to make it much easier. Better tools, better information, deep subsidization of healthy alternatives all come to mind.

The idea that we cannot make substantial improvements to people’s decision-making context and instead should spend all this money trying to hack the genome is obviously ridiculous.

Re:Cancer Moonshot initiative restarted by NIH by deeviant on Monday February 07, 2022 @01:29PM (#30248943)
> The idea that we cannot make substantial improvements to people’s decision-making context and instead should spend all this money trying to hack the genome is obviously ridiculous.

Except piles of cash per year ARE spend trying to change people's habits for the healthier, and it's obviously falling in the US.

You're idea of, "Don't throw a pile cash at medical research, that's stupid! No, spend it on advertising, but healthy stuff!" seems like the obviously ridiculous idea.

Re:Cancer Moonshot initiative restarted by NIH by ethanbond on Monday February 07, 2022 @04:39PM (#30251636)
Where did I advocate for advertising or PR campaigns?

There is very little funding of behavioral science research compared to pharmacological.

Re:Cancer Moonshot initiative restarted by NIH by manwe150 on Sunday February 06, 2022 @08:58PM (#30239232)
Are you honestly believing that fat people don’t enjoy life and food, have bad sex, and and stay awake at night worrying about it? I think you will find instead that overweight people are of typical happiness. I think someone has mislead you with false advertising, and done a better job at sharing information than the NIH could ever hope to manage.
Re:Cancer Moonshot initiative restarted by NIH by ethanbond on Monday February 07, 2022 @10:57AM (#30246537)
What a remarkable straw man argument you’ve defeated! My actual claim is that all other things held equal, people in general prefer to have higher fitness levels over lower fitness levels.
Re:Cancer Moonshot initiative restarted by NIH by manwe150 on Tuesday February 08, 2022 @08:41PM (#30267537)
I think you underestimate my laziness. All else being equal, I would likely binge watch TaskMaster.
Re:Cancer Moonshot initiative restarted by NIH by bradleyjg on Sunday February 06, 2022 @07:39PM (#30238700)
Same question (hopefully not the same answer): https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30238626
Re:Cancer Moonshot initiative restarted by NIH by mdorazio on Sunday February 06, 2022 @08:13PM (#30238934)
I disagree. The government could easily move the needle if it had the guts to implement nationwide financial changes that would actually make a difference on food contents - tax sugary foods & drinks, implement a sugar daily % value, end corn and dairy subsidies, etc.
Re:Cancer Moonshot initiative restarted by NIH by bradleyjg on Sunday February 06, 2022 @08:18PM (#30238972)
I remember when Bloomberg put in some sugary food taxes in NYC. Do you know if there’s any data on whether those policies worked?
Re:Cancer Moonshot initiative restarted by NIH by mdorazio on Sunday February 06, 2022 @11:51PM (#30240577)
I remember it being unpopular, but haven't seen results on the NYC one specifically. Wikipedia has a roundup of results on a few similar implementations, though, and they seem to somewhat work: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sugary_drink_tax#Consumption
Re:Cancer Moonshot initiative restarted by NIH by cjbgkagh on Sunday February 06, 2022 @07:24PM (#30238604)
Culture is easy to shift, Madison Avenue style ad companies specialize in it. The Frankfurt School is a positive theory that focuses on changing society. Modern nudge initiatives are continuations of this. I would say that the majority of modern culture was at some point the product of some campaign.
Re:Cancer Moonshot initiative restarted by NIH by sometimeshuman on Sunday February 06, 2022 @07:53PM (#30238798)
The ad was written in my early childhood. "Can you pinch an inch ?", was the tag-line in a Kellogg's commercial decades ago.

In part thanks to that advert, my entire life whenever I can pinch an inch I simply stop drinking my calories. Admittedly it is harder to eat healthy when you are time constrained and poor. But could there be anything faster and cheaper than pouring a glass of filtered tap water ? Can we advise that first before developing more PSAs about nutrition, exercise routines, etc.

Re:Cancer Moonshot initiative restarted by NIH by petra on Sunday February 06, 2022 @07:41PM (#30238708)
Some parts of culture are easier to create than others.

But losing weight? Endless amounts of effort is already spent towards this goal, it is deeply embedded in our culture(for ex. Fat shaming).

I don't some large ad campaign would change that much.

Re:Cancer Moonshot initiative restarted by NIH by cjbgkagh on Sunday February 06, 2022 @07:47PM (#30238748)
I think there is a rather powerful fat acceptance movement paid for by food lobbyists. Being fat is only socially unacceptable among my upper class friends, I think the middle class has leaned into it.

I think being able to have healthcare discriminate based on smoking has been hugely impactful in cutting US smoking rates, I think the same should be done for being overweight.

Re:Cancer Moonshot initiative restarted by NIH by dragonwriter on Sunday February 06, 2022 @07:58PM (#30238821)
> I think there is a rather powerful fat acceptance movement paid for by food lobbyists.

Fat anxiety is driven by food industry propagandists (more marketers than lobbyists.) Most weight-loss companies are basically high-priced subscription food services with add-on food marketing and a hook that gets people to pay for that as a service. While they've become a big enough business too often be standalone, it's not telling that Weight Watches spent a couple decades as a subsidiary of HJ Heinz.

> I think being able to have healthcare discriminate based on smoking has been hugely impactful in cutting US smoking rates

Health insurance was never prevented from discriminating on that basis, even while smoking rates went through the roof. There's plenty of policies for which there is evidence of utility in cutting smoking rates, health insurance price discrimination isn't one of them.

Re:Cancer Moonshot initiative restarted by NIH by cjbgkagh on Sunday February 06, 2022 @08:44PM (#30239124)
That’s a fair point, they can already discriminate. I think the insurance plans being tied to jobs led to non-smoking workplaces, and a non smoking workforce, so I think it put employment options for smokers at risk. I think the stats may have been tied to if employers could discriminate based on weight. I forgot the name of the study but I was compelled by the evidence when I saw it. It did speak to my biases so I’ve left the door open to being wrong.
Re:Cancer Moonshot initiative restarted by NIH by acchow on Sunday February 06, 2022 @07:53PM (#30238797)
They've flipped "fat shaming" into "fat pride", which is the latest territory of "wokeness"
Re:Cancer Moonshot initiative restarted by NIH by acchow on Sunday February 06, 2022 @07:52PM (#30238780)
> But losing weight? Endless amounts of effort is already spent towards this goal

The government can educate on and encourage healthy eating and fitness. The goal is not weight loss. Weight loss is just a side effect.

Re:Cancer Moonshot initiative restarted by NIH by bradleyjg on Sunday February 06, 2022 @07:27PM (#30238626)
Why did the US gov lose the war on drugs? Did the this your brain on drugs commercial series use the wrong ad agency?
Re:Cancer Moonshot initiative restarted by NIH by cjbgkagh on Sunday February 06, 2022 @07:30PM (#30238644)
The US never intended to win the war on drugs.
Re:Cancer Moonshot initiative restarted by NIH by verisimi on Sunday February 06, 2022 @08:02PM (#30238862)
No, they didn't.

Don't forget that in the US they named their anti-drugs policy in schools: DARE!! lol!

That's some twisted reverse psychology stuff..

Re:Cancer Moonshot initiative restarted by NIH by jpgvm on Sunday February 06, 2022 @07:37PM (#30238684)
More specifically the war on drugs was never about drugs. US is great at manufacturing proxy reasons for biased punitive punishment.
Re:Cancer Moonshot initiative restarted by NIH by bradleyjg on Sunday February 06, 2022 @07:39PM (#30238693)
It was probably aliens.
Re:Cancer Moonshot initiative restarted by NIH by cjbgkagh on Sunday February 06, 2022 @07:52PM (#30238784)
It was Nixon undermining the civil rights and anti-war movements. The CIA probably did more than just turn a blind eye to the heroin importation from the Golden Triangle in Asia.
Re:Cancer Moonshot initiative restarted by NIH by bradleyjg on Sunday February 06, 2022 @08:30PM (#30239035)
I heard Nixon was a Freemason.
Re:Cancer Moonshot initiative restarted by NIH by nradov on Sunday February 06, 2022 @07:42PM (#30238713)
The war on drugs was never about drugs per se, and winning was never the goal. It was always primarily a political tool to marginalize certain communities and minority groups.
Re:Cancer Moonshot initiative restarted by NIH by bradleyjg on Sunday February 06, 2022 @07:52PM (#30238787)
Why did my 99% white, upper middle class school district have a DARE program? How did that serve to advance the cause of marginalizing minority groups?
Re:Cancer Moonshot initiative restarted by NIH by dragonwriter on Sunday February 06, 2022 @08:18PM (#30238974)
> Why did my 99% white, upper middle class school district have a DARE program? How did that serve to advance the cause of marginalizing minority groups

DARE is a program to increase public positive image of, deference to, and political support for the arbitrary action of police. (And t it's only demonstrated effect is on attitudes toward police; it doesn't have any effect on drug use.)

How that advances the cause of marginalizing minority groups is left as an exercise for the reader.

Re:Cancer Moonshot initiative restarted by NIH by bradleyjg on Sunday February 06, 2022 @08:25PM (#30239013)
So the claim is it was deliberately ineffective at getting kids not to take drugs because …?
Re:Cancer Moonshot initiative restarted by NIH by dragonwriter on Monday February 07, 2022 @10:32AM (#30246187)
> So the claim is it was deliberately ineffective at getting kids not to take drugs because …?

The claim is keeping kids off drugs was probably never the real goal, and even if it was the program continued to expand to new places and be funded in existing places long after it was proven ineffective as anything but pro-police propaganda, which wasn't an accident by decision-makers.

Which reveals that even if keeping kids off drugs was once part of the motivation, it wasn't what sustained the program.

Re:Cancer Moonshot initiative restarted by NIH by reaperducer on Sunday February 06, 2022 @08:09PM (#30238904)
How did that serve to advance the cause of marginalizing minority groups?

Don't bother pointing out facts or using logic. Any time someone mentions drugs on HN, the usual group of addicts-in-denial show up parroting the same tired and disproven talking points that High Times magazine has been flogging for the last 40 years.

Re:Cancer Moonshot initiative restarted by NIH by acchow on Sunday February 06, 2022 @08:13PM (#30238936)
The overall war on drugs waged by the government was about power and control, but that doesn't mean individual persons and communities couldn't decide for themselves what they were fighting for.
Re:Cancer Moonshot initiative restarted by NIH by cjbgkagh on Sunday February 06, 2022 @08:00PM (#30238842)
Interesting logic; maybe they didn’t want to marginalize the non minorities....

Also, it makes sense to publicly do one thing and privately do another.

DARE campaign was Reagan era, when they were importing cocaine by the plane load.

Re:Cancer Moonshot initiative restarted by NIH by ohyeshedid on Sunday February 06, 2022 @08:11PM (#30238925)
Indoctrination.
Re:Cancer Moonshot initiative restarted by NIH by bradleyjg on Sunday February 06, 2022 @08:20PM (#30238984)
Well, exactly. They tried to indoctrinate kids not to take drugs and it failed miserably. So the claim that it’s super easy for the government to shift culture seems wrong, no?
Re:Cancer Moonshot initiative restarted by NIH by ohyeshedid on Sunday February 06, 2022 @08:42PM (#30239101)
Rather than making a bigger picture point out of a single example, I'm thinking;

In the US, dependent on location, a person may be living under several different governments.

Governments recognize and/or create holidays, and holidays can go on to be cultural events.

Governments organize and finance festivals and events, which can and do become culture of a place or people.

They built statues, museums, parks, libraries, theatres, etc; all with several different levels and layers of culture.

You'd need to start defining parameters of what is a government, what is a culture shift, etc.

Re:Cancer Moonshot initiative restarted by NIH by bradleyjg on Sunday February 06, 2022 @08:46PM (#30239145)
Okay. If the US government, in the form of the NIH, spent 1.8 billion dollars trying to get people to exercise more do you think we’d see substantially more exercise happening than we would have otherwise?
Re:Cancer Moonshot initiative restarted by NIH by ohyeshedid on Sunday February 06, 2022 @08:56PM (#30239217)
Personally, I would doubt "substantial" increases, but that would depend on how you'd want to define that and such.

That doesn't mean they can't, won't, and don't, shift cultures in many other ways.