News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Is Printing a Gun the Same as Buying a Gun? by Jun8 on Tuesday September 20, 2011 @03:38PM (#3019243)
"The fact that we are now able to manufacture usable weapon parts is an important step..."

It's not clear to me if a rifle part printed from plastic at home is usable.

I wonder how the manufacturing of these thing are regulated normally: Can you have a professional place make 2-3 of these for you without telling them what it is?

Re:Is Printing a Gun the Same as Buying a Gun? by hvs on Tuesday September 20, 2011 @03:52PM (#3019290)
The law is pretty clear cut in the U.S. about gun manufacturing. If you want to build the lower receiver of an AR-15, go ahead, but if you plan on selling it you need either a Type 7 or Type 10 Federal Firearms License. The rest of the AR-15 is just parts. If a "professional" makes them for you, whether or not he knows what they are, he better have a license or he could be committing a felony.
Re:Is Printing a Gun the Same as Buying a Gun? by koenigdavidmj on Tuesday September 20, 2011 @04:01PM (#3019321)
But in the hypothetical future where 3D printers are ubiquitous, if you sell a script to build the lower receiver, then does that count as selling one?

Reminds me of the case where Phil Zimmerman noticed that exporting crypto was a form of arms export, but exporting books was protected by the First Amendment. So he published the source code to PGP and shipped it.

Re:Is Printing a Gun the Same as Buying a Gun? by anelson on Tuesday September 20, 2011 @05:31PM (#3019683)
IANAL but I know my way around US federal firearms law. I am not aware of any law or rulemaking which would classify, for example, CAD files describing a lower receiver as an item subject to firearms regulations. There exist books sold openly and without restriction detailing how one can make improvised firearms, some of which if constructed would be illegal for possession by American civilians. I'm sure this information has by now made it to the Internet as well. Up to this point, such materials are treated as speech and thus strongly protected by the First Amendment. I see no reason why 3D printer instruction files would be treated any differently, under current law.

It's not hard to imagine a Congresscritter raising a fuss over concerns of "children printing machine guns" or some such nonsense, and thereby introducing legislation to regulate such materials, including executable scripts for 3D printing machines. It's even possible to imagine such legislation passing the House and Senate. Our current president would likely sign any such legislation he was given. However, it is very difficult to imagine the legislation surviving a Supreme Court challenge on First Amendment grounds.

Then again, I said the same thing about the McCain-Feingold Campaign Finance Reform Act, and SCOTUS upheld that 5-4, so what do I know.

Re:Is Printing a Gun the Same as Buying a Gun? by sneak on Wednesday September 21, 2011 @06:04AM (#3021376)
> However, it is very difficult to imagine the legislation surviving a Supreme Court challenge on First Amendment grounds.

Next month is the TEN YEAR anniversary of the USA PATRIOT act, the legislation that abolished the fourth amendment. Checks and balances only work when they, well, balance.

Unfortunately that isn't the case any longer.

Re:Is Printing a Gun the Same as Buying a Gun? by ConstantineXVI on Tuesday September 20, 2011 @04:35PM (#3019459)
Legally, the only difference between a CAD file of the AR-15 and an AR-15 repair manual should be that one is actionable by a machine. They're both a description of the operation of the object (and thus speech).

And let's go even further into the hypothetical future where we've made great advances in AI. Also, for whatever reason, a court has found weapons CAD files to be illegal. What will the law say when a machine is intelligent enough to decipher the same human-targeted AR-15 repair manual and reconstruct one from that information?

Re:Is Printing a Gun the Same as Buying a Gun? by bradly on Tuesday September 20, 2011 @04:04PM (#3019341)
It isn't really clear cut. Is there a difference in selling a firearm and selling a printer that can print firearms?
Re:Is Printing a Gun the Same as Buying a Gun? by bradleyland on Tuesday September 20, 2011 @04:19PM (#3019395)
The machinery that makes firearms isn't unique or special. Some of the tooling may be, but I can't imagine all the CNC mills an lathes are purpose specific at firearms manufacturers' plants.

As with most things firearms related, the offense occurs with the action. In this case, the transaction. You can manufacture a firearm with standard machinery and suffer no penalty. The same applies for a printer capable of printing a firearm (or parts). It is when you sell those firearms (or parts) that you have broken the law.

If it is against the law to possess a firearm in your location, then it doesn't matter how you made it. Possession remains illegal.

Re:Is Printing a Gun the Same as Buying a Gun? by bradly on Tuesday September 20, 2011 @04:45PM (#3019495)
I see your point, but I am more thinking if 3D printers became household item then the cost, time, and specialized knowledge prerequisites that exist currently to make your own gun are all gone.
Re:Is Printing a Gun the Same as Buying a Gun? by hvs on Tuesday September 20, 2011 @04:56PM (#3019529)
Much like using a high-quality printer to counterfeit money, it's not the technology that makes it illegal, it's the act.
Re:Is Printing a Gun the Same as Buying a Gun? by 0x12 on Tuesday September 20, 2011 @04:13PM (#3019367)
A cornucopia machine will create a few social problems as well as some legal issues.
Re:Is Printing a Gun the Same as Buying a Gun? by commandar on Tuesday September 20, 2011 @06:20PM (#3019851)
>It's not clear to me if a rifle part printed from plastic at home is usable.

It wouldn't surprise me if it were perfectly functional. The lower receiver on an AR houses the trigger group, buffer tube, magazine, and grip. Not really a lot of high-stress parts there. The barrel, bolt, gas tube, etc that have to withstand 60k+ PSI of pressure are all part of the upper receiver.

Legally, only the lower is classified as a firearm in the United States (meaning they have to be transferred through a licensed firearms dealer if shipped); the upper and the rest of the gun are simply parts and can be shipped directly by UPS/FedEX/USPS.

Re:Is Printing a Gun the Same as Buying a Gun? by mooism2 on Tuesday September 20, 2011 @03:52PM (#3019287)
Even if a plastic part printed at home today isn't usable, a metal part printed at home in a few years time will be.
Re:Is Printing a Gun the Same as Buying a Gun? by 0x12 on Tuesday September 20, 2011 @04:09PM (#3019354)
You can't just print a metal part without some serious post processing to reach the desired strength, and even then you'll be hard pressed to come up with a part that is the same size and just as strong.

Printing full metal parts is possible but there are some penalties, relatively low tensile strength is one of those.

Re:Is Printing a Gun the Same as Buying a Gun? by gonzo on Tuesday September 20, 2011 @05:33PM (#3019689)
AR15 lowers don't really need that much strength. The upper does, but you can buy those without a FFL transfer.