Re:Senate introduces bill to allow farmers to fix their own ...
by busterarm on Wednesday February 02, 2022 @01:26PM
(#30181693)
Worse still, you can't get schematics for John Deere in the US, but John Deere provided full schematics as a condition of access to the Chinese market.
Re:Senate introduces bill to allow farmers to fix their own ...
by TheRealDunkirk on Wednesday February 02, 2022 @03:54PM
(#30183937)
My company makes products that have computer controllers, and lots and lots of code to run them. They are bending over backward to make them impossible to hack here in the States, but (so I am told) giving the source and the encryption keys directly to the Chinese government as a requirement of selling products into that market.
Re:Senate introduces bill to allow farmers to fix their own ...
by rootsudo on Wednesday February 02, 2022 @02:40PM
(#30182875)
Ironic. Makes you think which country cares more about their people and industry.
Re:Senate introduces bill to allow farmers to fix their own ...
by lp0_on_fire on Wednesday February 02, 2022 @02:44PM
(#30182936)
China didn't demand the schematics out of altruism - they did it so they can copy the product and release their own. It's standard operating procedure for doing business in that country.
Re:Senate introduces bill to allow farmers to fix their own ...
by notch656a on Wednesday February 02, 2022 @02:52PM
(#30183055)
I don't doubt it; but schematics, while incredibly useful for repair, are only a sliver of the piece of the puzzle to manufacturing something.
Re:Senate introduces bill to allow farmers to fix their own ...
by andrei_says_ on Wednesday February 02, 2022 @03:37PM
(#30183675)
Could you point to China’s version of said product? This sounds a bit like FUD to me.
Schematics do not always 100% lead to stolen and reproduced IP.
Re:Senate introduces bill to allow farmers to fix their own ...
by jahewson on Wednesday February 02, 2022 @04:49PM
(#30184539)
More style than substance but the blazon disregard for IP is clear:
https://www.agriland.ie/farming-news/fancy-a-chinese-interpr...
Re:Senate introduces bill to allow farmers to fix their own ...
by andrei_says_ on Thursday February 03, 2022 @01:20AM
(#30189323)
Yes, in general. I was asking specifically about the tractor clones.
Re:Senate introduces bill to allow farmers to fix their own ...
by vosper on Wednesday February 02, 2022 @03:47PM
(#30183827)
Does it really make you think China might care more about it's people? A brief Google should relieve you of that notion :)
Re:Senate introduces bill to allow farmers to fix their own ...
by zardo on Wednesday February 02, 2022 @04:28PM
(#30184298)
The Chinese government is a large beurocracy, it contains many competing factions and interests.
Re:Senate introduces bill to allow farmers to fix their own ...
by raxxorrax on Thursday February 03, 2022 @10:17AM
(#30193495)
The Chinese government has its own interst in forcing such concessions. Still, politics today doesn't really favor consumer rights at all. This bill is the minimum that should be done on the topic of copyright. Otherwise representatives feel very comfortable in the bowels of the industry in general, especially regarding to intellectual property. It makes strategic sense to defend it with a player like China, but it also has become about milking consumers.
Re:Senate introduces bill to allow farmers to fix their own ...
by dijonman2 on Wednesday February 02, 2022 @03:34PM
(#30183637)
Exactly the same situation with Apple, but it’s much more than bumps and ridges. It’s DRM for screens, digitizers, batteries, etc. It is genuine OEM but apple obviously prefers you to buy a new device.
Re:Senate introduces bill to allow farmers to fix their own ...
by jacquesm on Wednesday February 02, 2022 @02:34PM
(#30182793)
That's pretty shocking. At the same time: this is a pretty strong case for market response, some other company should be able to get a significant price advantage out of this and make minced meat of JD in comparative advertising.
On every bid we sent them the #1 requirement was Proprietary Fit. There had to be some sort of IP lockout (always disguised as a valuable design feature, but it never was) to prevent end users from procuring replacement parts anywhere else. In many cases it even made the parts significantly worse, as useless bumps or ridges were added to the industry standard to make them physically incompatible.
The old model was we build a part for $8 and sell it to the end user for $10. Under Deere's new model, we build the part for $8, sell it exclusively to Deere for $11, and they sell it to customer for $16.
My former employer was very complicit in this behavior, but Deere was by far the most aggressive about and a big enough player to squeeze all their suppliers.
Edit: They pay all kinds of lip service to how this is better for the customer ("reliable supply chain", "Deere-guaranteed quality", etc) but that's only in their public PR. Behind the scenes it is 100% about securing a long term revenue source - customers pay out the ass for a piece of equipment, then have to keep coming back to Deere for 50 years for replacement parts.