News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:GDPR enforcer rules that IAB Europe’s consent popups are ... by endisneigh on Wednesday February 02, 2022 @09:13AM (#30177772)
> Advertising companies are ruining the internet for everyone, some people are just too unaware to realise it.

Sounds like projection. Though I'd agree that most internet users don't like ads, what's true is that most internet users don't like paying for things. Using YouTube as an example, the most popular site on the internet, the vast majority of people do not pay for YouTube premium even though it's available.

At the end of the day no one is stopping you from going back to circa-2000s internet, using IRC, going on plain text websites, using BBS, etc.

Re:GDPR enforcer rules that IAB Europe’s consent popups are ... by 9dev on Wednesday February 02, 2022 @09:25AM (#30177955)
I think the point is that megacorps' business structure is way too complex for anyone to actually understand. Why is Gmail free? It makes money for Google, that part is clear, but I have no idea how exactly. I'm not even sure they can measure it exactly.

Those companies have transformed the internet, and its users, by offering services for free, in exchange for user data. We have raised an entire generation (two, maybe?) of people taking that model for granted, nicely illustrated by completely ad-dependent YouTube superstars.

Of course, we cannot simply ban all advertising and start charging for everything. But I'm of the firm opinion that, in order to go forward, we have to leave this business model behind, as humanity. The only way to achieve this is by making it unattractive via legislation.

Re:GDPR enforcer rules that IAB Europe’s consent popups are ... by endisneigh on Wednesday February 02, 2022 @09:32AM (#30178050)
> Of course, we cannot simply ban all advertising and start charging for everything. But I'm of the firm opinion that, in order to go forward, we have to leave this business model behind, as humanity. The only way to achieve this is by making it unattractive via legislation.

What exactly are you proposing? Anyone who wants to pay for email can do so already.

It's very trivial to not use any of Google's services or be tracked. Install uBlock, and don't go to any Google or subsidiary service. Done.

What exactly is the issue?

Re:GDPR enforcer rules that IAB Europe’s consent popups are ... by 9dev on Wednesday February 02, 2022 @09:53AM (#30178349)
The issue isn't that I'm personally inconvenienced, this is not about me. It's that the internet is dominated by ad-based companies, and that is not a good thing?

I propose that we try to move humanity past this way of generating revenue, because it's wasting productivity and resources, encouraging shady behaviour, and leads to less freedom overall.

We have social networks manipulating users into staying on the platforms as long as possible, scrolling down infinite feeds, to expose them to as much advertising as possible, thus wasting productivity.

We have big players such as the IAB and its members tracking and spying on users to obtain more data to sell, as an alternative revenue stream to charging for their services.

We have quality journalism disappear in favour of whatever generates the most clicks, in order to expose more readers to advertisements. YouTube stars pushing hidden ads on children. Advertisers crossing ever more boundaries of privacy, by aggregating data from thousands of companies, with basically no oversight by anyone.

That is the issue. I think we should do something against that, and I think "something" may be to nudge the market into another direction, from ad-based to transaction-based revenue sources.

Re:GDPR enforcer rules that IAB Europe’s consent popups are ... by lowbloodsugar on Wednesday February 02, 2022 @12:40PM (#30180951)
Here's a job. You need a job. It pays in company scrip [1]. People took those jobs despite the negative consequences. The government eventually made such schemes illegal.

Your argument is "People have free choice, so anything that they do is legal."

The excuse of the perpetrators is "I'm not the one (directly) responsible for your poor economic situation, or your lack of education, so it's fair and moral for me to offer you a terrible proposition that you absolutely would not make if you were in a better economic situation." This is just where extreme capitalism gets you.

The list of examples is endless. Scrip. Children working in mines or cleaning chimneys. Click-through TOS. "Free" email. Indentured servitude.

At the end of the day it's no different than "You need to get on this boat to america, or this gentleman here is going to cut your wife's throat. Hey, it's not me doing the cutting. I'm the good guy. I'm trying to keep you safe. But its your choice."

It really depends on what we mean by "choice".

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Company_scrip

Re:GDPR enforcer rules that IAB Europe’s consent popups are ... by alkonaut on Wednesday February 02, 2022 @10:00AM (#30178453)
If a site offers the choice between either funding via "good" (Non tracking, no malware etc) ads, and a fee, then I'm completely happy with their business model. A lot of sites however, don't do this.

Of course, the reality is that if they _did_ use "good" ads, then the free version wouldn't make enough money (at least not in today's ad market). So either the free version couldn't exist, OR it would need to be subsidized by the paid version being even more expensive.

But this problem could go away if "bad" ads weren't allowed or possible. Because then the price sites get per impression on those ads could go up, as advertisers can't simply pay more for precisely targeted ads.

Now, there are a few risks with this: 1) There is every risk that money on the regular web dries up, as targeting is more effective in apps and other siloed environments. We have already seen this to some extent 2) If online advertising is less efficient because of worse targeting, then traditional advertising will again be relatively more attractive, so some of the money would leave the internet economy that way, returning to traditional advertising.

1 and 2 taken together might mean that a lot of "free" content (and I use scare quotes) will simply disappear. And I think that's a risk we should be willing to take. And not only that: I'd go so far as saying that even if 90% of internet users answered in a survey that "I don't care about tracking ads, I just want free content", that's not something regulators should care about at all.

Re:GDPR enforcer rules that IAB Europe’s consent popups are ... by endisneigh on Wednesday February 02, 2022 @10:06AM (#30178533)
I disagree with what you’re saying. Basically your point is that most content on the internet should go away because you don’t like ads.

Good luck with that. Instead, you should treat all the sites that have ads as inaccessible and personally use the small percentage that fit your needs.

Everyone wins.

Re:GDPR enforcer rules that IAB Europe’s consent popups are ... by alkonaut on Wednesday February 02, 2022 @10:36AM (#30179037)
> Basically your point is that most content on the internet should go away because you don’t like ads.

No. I'm conpletely fine with ads. This isn't about ads vs.no ads. This is about "bad" ads. The wholeseale trading in people's information. It's a transaction where the price (Being their PII sold somewhere) isn't visible to the buyer.

The reason we ended up where we are now where a site MUST use horrible adtech, is this: Because there exists ways of displaying pinpoint targeted tracking ads through unscrupulous adtech companies then that's what sets the baseline revenue for ads. Show ads that are 1/10th as efficient? You'll get just 1/10th the revenue. It's what a website has to do.

So if I'm a site that wants to show "ethical" ads, I can't. Because the ad market is such that ethical ads don't make money. If, however, bad ads don't exist - then ethical advertising could be able to make more money again. The endgame of all this isn't forcing all sites to either die or become paid services. To me the important outcome is to level the playing field between those that display (or want to display) "better" ads.

Re:GDPR enforcer rules that IAB Europe’s consent popups are ... by danaris on Wednesday February 02, 2022 @02:29PM (#30182718)
And, to go a step further:

At least according to what I have read, before "bad" ads existed, the overall advertising budget of the corporate sector was roughly the same as it is now. This means that ad-supported business models were just as viable without all this crap.

The problem is that the tracking and whatnot is perceived to increase value, so the ad spending shifted to prefer the more invasive and "targeted" types of ads. But if we outlawed invasive, targeted ads and the tracking required to generate them...yes, there would be a certain amount of redistribution of ad spend, but overall, it doesn't seem like it would actually dry up and blow away.

So there's no good reason to think that getting rid of the really bad stuff would reduce the overall amount of ad-supported content out there.

Re:GDPR enforcer rules that IAB Europe’s consent popups are ... by alkonaut on Wednesday February 02, 2022 @03:35PM (#30183649)
If the budgets stay the same then some content might go where the ad money is. For example, the internet strangled the free metro newspaper business because having an ad-supported print media in the 2000's was difficult. If internet ads became dumber, then print ads don't look so dumb. And some money might flow back into things like this: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Metro_(Swedish_newspaper) So if anything, the ad-supported content might shift to other places such as print.
Re:GDPR enforcer rules that IAB Europe’s consent popups are ... by parkingrift on Wednesday February 02, 2022 @09:46AM (#30178237)
>Though I'd agree that most internet users don't like ads, what's true is that most internet users don't like paying for things. Using YouTube as an example, the most popular site on the internet, the vast majority of people do not pay for YouTube premium even though it's available.

This is a bit circular. People would rather use a free service than a paid service. So long as free services exist it will be hard or impossible for paid services to exist or thrive.

>At the end of the day no one is stopping you from going back to circa-2000s internet, using IRC, going on plain text websites, using BBS, etc.

There's no reason that we should have to make this choice. We don't have to live in a spyware dystopia so that we can have cheaper internet services. This spyware economy is less than 20 years old, and we should throw it out.

Re:GDPR enforcer rules that IAB Europe’s consent popups are ... by endisneigh on Wednesday February 02, 2022 @09:52AM (#30178333)
> This is a bit circular. People would rather use a free service than a paid service. So long as free services exist it will be hard or impossible for paid services to exist or thrive.

Of course. If a paid product wants to thrive it needs to be better. People do use paid search engines, email, maps, etc. most people don’t because most people don’t value it that much.

> There's no reason that we should have to make this choice. We don't have to live in a spyware dystopia so that we can have cheaper internet services. This spyware economy is less than 20 years old, and we should throw it out.

I don’t think there’s a dystopia. If you want to regress you can do so alone. We have irc and bbs that won’t track you. I’m sure there are also some plain text sites you can peruse.

Not really understanding why you want to change things for others. Just change it for yourself and then you’re good.

Re:GDPR enforcer rules that IAB Europe’s consent popups are ... by Nextgrid on Wednesday February 02, 2022 @09:56AM (#30178382)
> paid search engines, [...], maps

Can you find me one? The only one I know about is Kagi which is in beta and invite-only.

The problem with the current status-quo is that as long as advertising powered by illicit data collection is possible in practice, it's not viable for a paid service to compete.

> Just change it for yourself and then you’re good.

It doesn't matter what you do if ad-tech scum will track you anyway and create a shadow profile by tricking your friends into giving out information about you such as how Facebook infers social graphs (including non-users) by sneaking into people's contacts lists.

Re:GDPR enforcer rules that IAB Europe’s consent popups are ... by endisneigh on Wednesday February 02, 2022 @10:09AM (#30178569)
Try out Neeva in addition to Kagi. If you pay and get your friends to, it’ll compete.

> It doesn't matter what you do if ad-tech scum will track you anyway

Stay away from sites that use trackers and you won’t be tracked. I recommend turning off JavaScript and sticking to plain text sites.

Re:GDPR enforcer rules that IAB Europe’s consent popups are ... by mopsi on Wednesday February 02, 2022 @10:50AM (#30179217)
> Stay away from sites that use trackers and you won’t be tracked.

That's not enough. If your friends give Instagram and the likes access to their contacts to "find friends", then they unintentionally leak your social circle too, and data warehouses sell this info to the highest bidder, lowest bidder, and everyone inbetween, and government agencies also tap into this for mass surveillance. Even the goddamn Mastercard sells transaction histories to Google. Everything's scraped and sold, doesn't matter if you use the internet at all.

Any notion of user consent to this is ridiculous, because barely anyone understands how much is truly collected, shared and linked together from various sources, and then used and abused. That's why Google, Facebook et al fight so furiously against legislation like the GDPR that mandates informed (!) consent.

Re:GDPR enforcer rules that IAB Europe’s consent popups are ... by parkingrift on Wednesday February 02, 2022 @05:04PM (#30184724)
Let's flip it. How about you continue with the spyware dystopia and the rest of us regulate away spyware businesses?
Re:GDPR enforcer rules that IAB Europe’s consent popups are ... by belorn on Wednesday February 02, 2022 @10:24AM (#30178836)
Why stop at circa-2000s internet when we got a whole past to go back to. We don't need to go far before much of current day market regulations didn't exist and people could freely choose to do things and not do things as much they wanted.

Coal mines that used indebted servitude out competed mines that did not, and if people didn't want to go into indebted servitude they could always choose to not sign the contract. The market spoke and the customers choose of their own free will to go to the company store, paying more than they earned, and increased their debt year after year.

Re:GDPR enforcer rules that IAB Europe’s consent popups are ... by Nextgrid on Wednesday February 02, 2022 @09:26AM (#30177966)
A lot of content on the internet isn't worth paying for. Taking your YT Premium example, I'd say over half the content on there is garbage clickbait that is only viable because of ads - it doesn't actually provide enough value to the viewer (and often completely wastes their time) but the current system rewards that because by the time the viewer realizes that it's already too late and they've been paid for their ad impression.

The problem with YT Premium specifically is that it still requires a Google account, agreeing to their "privacy" policy and provides no guarantee that Google isn't still going to stalk you.

Re:GDPR enforcer rules that IAB Europe’s consent popups are ... by endisneigh on Wednesday February 02, 2022 @09:31AM (#30178037)
I highly doubt you've personally watched even 1% of what's on YouTube, so you can hardly determine what's clickbait. That being said, who are we to say what's valuable?
Re:GDPR enforcer rules that IAB Europe’s consent popups are ... by Nextgrid on Wednesday February 02, 2022 @09:49AM (#30178287)
I'm extrapolating based on what I see on the front page and in suggestions as well as other social networks. Most of this content is only there to solicit an ad impression, not enough people would pay money for it.

> That being said, who are we to say what's valuable?

We can infer this based on whether enough people pay for the content. There's a reason you don't see a Patreon or other way of paying for the vast majority of clickbait content.

Re:GDPR enforcer rules that IAB Europe’s consent popups are ... by endisneigh on Wednesday February 02, 2022 @09:58AM (#30178419)
> Most of this content is only there to solicit an ad impression, not enough people would pay money for it.

Exactly. There’s no issue.

> There's a reason you don't see a Patreon or other way of paying for the vast majority of clickbait content.

The vast majority of content, clickbait or not doesn’t have a patreon to begin with. Most patreon have social media presence which includes ads. Sounds like the worst of both worlds.

Re:GDPR enforcer rules that IAB Europe’s consent popups are ... by Nextgrid on Wednesday February 02, 2022 @10:13AM (#30178623)
There is an issue.

The content is clearly not valuable enough for people to pay for it, and in fact it's called "clickbait" for a reason because people clearly feel cheated by what they got as opposed to what they were led to believe they were clicking on.

In a market where consumers of the content pay for it, this wouldn't fly. In a market corrupted by advertising, this flies and the by-product is wasted time, computing resources, pricing out good content from the market (as you can't compete with free) and the risks associated with advertising (the ads aren't properly reviewed, scams, spam and malware can and does fall through the cracks) and data collection.

This also subverts the entire market and is the reason you can't even buy a good TV or appliance anymore without going for niche, commercial-grade products. Do you want to live in a society where you literally can't buy a TV that doesn't spy on you or show ads?

Advertising in its current form is absolutely out of control and ends up being a tax that we all pay for both in time (whether watching the ads or playing cat & mouse with countermeasures such as AdBlock, Pi-Hole, etc) as well as money (as it's ultimately part of the price of the goods we all buy).

Re:GDPR enforcer rules that IAB Europe’s consent popups are ... by 9dev on Wednesday February 02, 2022 @10:08AM (#30178556)
> > Most of this content is only there to solicit an ad impression, not enough people would pay money for it.

> Exactly. There’s no issue.

Except all the work and energy wasted on creating trash content only intended for ad impressions? The world would be better off without it.

Re:GDPR enforcer rules that IAB Europe’s consent popups are ... by endisneigh on Wednesday February 02, 2022 @10:15AM (#30178660)
Nope. Trash content is just your opinion.

Just because you don’t like it doesn’t mean it shouldn’t exist.

Re:GDPR enforcer rules that IAB Europe’s consent popups are ... by Nextgrid on Wednesday February 02, 2022 @10:19AM (#30178728)
The fact that nobody wants to pay their hard-earned dollars for it suggests it's more than just his opinion.

In fact, let's imagine a system where one side provides ads that you can watch to accumulate a monetary balance and the other provides content (including the aforementioned trash).

Do you think people will still watch and choose to pay for said trash content? Or will they choose to spend that money on better content, or even cash it out and buy a meal or drink?

Re:GDPR enforcer rules that IAB Europe’s consent popups are ... by endisneigh on Wednesday February 02, 2022 @10:25AM (#30178862)
That’s not the situation so it’s irrelevant.
Re:GDPR enforcer rules that IAB Europe’s consent popups are ... by Helmut10001 on Wednesday February 02, 2022 @09:28AM (#30177993)
There is not much that would be lost if Youtube ceased to exist, either. People are wasting hours on this platform that could be spend better in many ways.
Re:GDPR enforcer rules that IAB Europe’s consent popups are ... by endisneigh on Wednesday February 02, 2022 @09:29AM (#30178008)
That's only your opinion. There are billions who disagree. At the end of the day no one is forcing you to use YouTube.
Re:GDPR enforcer rules that IAB Europe’s consent popups are ... by Nextgrid on Wednesday February 02, 2022 @09:58AM (#30178412)
There should be enough people in those billions to sustain a paid alternative.
Re:GDPR enforcer rules that IAB Europe’s consent popups are ... by endisneigh on Wednesday February 02, 2022 @10:19AM (#30178733)
There are paid alternatives.