Nevertheless, if BEAST is basically an exploit on the Bard attack that's been known for years, perhaps it suggests that there was an insufficiency of hype around the original publication.
I obviously have no way to know whether this is a big deal or not. These guys have a "proven track record" from the ASP.net thing, but remember that attack came after a number of less-than-earth-shattering releases from them around padding oracles in other circumstances.
These guys need to publish the details now. Let the baby be born and not try to prolong the delivery for their own personal reasons.
So, that attack is less valid because it was gradually developed. That phrase doesn't make any sense.
Also, 'SSL broken' it's a way abusive title to whatever hack relying on non encrypted http requests, javascript injection and so on.
But the real question: why do people pay so much attention to this here at HN? Why does it gets discussed as if would be given for a fact when all we have are rumors? I think people just like to talk vaguely about crypto, throwing a few concepts and hypothesis around migt be enough for many to feel intelligent...?
I find you own attitude on the mater as a security researcher rather unprofessional. I beleive you are speculating hardly on this not being a serious matter, and are in fact as detail-less as the journalists hyping this up.
For the past 8 years TLS was know to be theoretically insecure and yet the fix was not widely adopted. I would have hoped we had outgrown ignoring "academic" issues with crypto systems after the debacle with non provably secure RSA signatures in SSL/the Bleichenbacher attack that necessitated OAEP in the 90s.
Maybe the security community deservers the world it lives in where this kind of hype is acceptable and productive? Certainly it could have been avoided by paying attention to these issues in the first place.
I realize that the security industry is built on hype, but this is fucking dumb.